Do You Have a Self? Essay

Do You Have a Self? Essay

Length: 983 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In this paper, I will look at the no-self view Nagasena argues for, and question its demand for a permanent self. I will argue that the self exists because it is created, that the self does exist from its point of creation. I will then attempt to justify my argument’s premise as they help to resolve the contention that the self’s memory and history, which Nagasena does not account for, are what defines the self.

In The Questions of King Milinda, Nagasena argues that the self does not exist. Using the analogy of the chariot, he argues:
1) The chariot is not its pole, its axle, its wheels or any other of its constituent parts only.
2) The chariot is not anything outside its constituent parts.
3) The chariot is not all of its constituent parts.
Therefore, the chariot does not exist.
Rather, the name “chariot” is only a “generally understood term” for something that has all the constituent parts of the chariot put together. Names of composite things are merely empty sounds that exist as ideas, and are used to refer to the collection of its constituent parts when they put together in reality.

In relation to the self, the names we assign to the self would then have “no permanent individuality implied in [the] name,” because the there is no fixed collection of constituent parts that would form the same self. The constituent parts of the self are continuously changing, and hence, the name we use to refer to a self does not refer to the same combination and arrangement of a particular group of constituent parts through time. That is why he believes that “there is no permanent individuality involved in the matter,” where the matter refers to his name, “Nagasena” and the self to which the name refers to. As such, the name we use to re...


... middle of paper ...


...the previous. Because he requires the self to have permanent individuality, the self does not exist. If we remove that requirement, the self can then exist. However, basing the existence of the self on memory and history gives rise to the contentions. To answer these contentions, I thus propose to relate the self to its creation in time as permanent factor. This relation does not limit the existence of the self to require all its constituent parts to remain permanent, so the changes the self undergoes can be considered part of it, but at the same time have a permanent property, which is the point in time it was created.



Works Cited

'Maverick Philosopher: Can the chariot take us to the land of no self?'. N.p. 18 Mac 2011. Web. 22 Nov. 2013. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Is Self Reliance Right For You? Essay

- Is Self Reliance Right for You. What is most confusing about Ralph Emerson’s Self-Reliance is his overwhelming selfishness. If everyone listened to Emerson’s writing, the world we live in wouldn’t even be possible because no one would work together and everyone would hate each other because they would not need them. The reliance on others is the only way to build a working society, but that does not mean Self-Reliant people are out of the picture in this world. Only certain people fall under the category of Self-Reliant and differ from Emerson’s harsh arguments....   [tags: Ralph Waldo Emerson, Walt Whitman, Leaves of Grass]

Better Essays
1404 words (4 pages)

Essay on Do You Have a Low Self-esteem?

- “You are altogether beautiful my darling; beautiful in every way.” This verse from the Bible sums up what I think about every woman. I believe that every woman, teenage girl, or pre teen should stop putting themselves down. Confidence is key to living a happy and joyful life. Being depressed, being unhappy, giving up on things, being introvert and not feeling good about oneself are some characteristics of a person that does not have self confidence. I believe that in order to succeed and be successful in life you must have self-confidence....   [tags: Bible, women, self-esteem, happiness, depression]

Better Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

The Bad Guy, or Not? Social Media Influence on Self-Perception Essay

- ... “Body dissatisfaction involves subjective disapproval of one’s own body shape or form and the belief that it is unattractive to others” (In The Eye Of The Beholder 20). There are many speculations on why people start disliking their bodies. One of them can be media giving them the “Ideal Perfect Body”, but there is another reason of why and this is the peer influence. The peer influence can be found around the person on question, it either can be his or her own family and friends or maybe the next door girl who is skinny and has everything this person desire....   [tags: self esteem and body image, happiness within you]

Better Essays
985 words (2.8 pages)

Do You Have a Self? Essay

- In this paper, I will look at the no-self view Nagasena argues for, and question its demand for a permanent self. I will argue that the self exists because it is created, that the self does exist from its point of creation. I will then attempt to justify my argument’s premise as they help to resolve the contention that the self’s memory and history, which Nagasena does not account for, are what defines the self. In The Questions of King Milinda, Nagasena argues that the self does not exist. Using the analogy of the chariot, he argues: 1) The chariot is not its pole, its axle, its wheels or any other of its constituent parts only....   [tags: The Questions of King Milinda, Nagasena]

Better Essays
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on What Your Inner Self Can Help You?

- ... 8. Remove Any Guilt If you are holding on to guilt, then you will have a harder time seeing things clearly and making a decision. Guilt is the feeling that you have done something in your past that was unethical or that hurt you in some way, and that feeling will keep you weary about making any other decisions that could result you feeling even more guilt along the way. For instance, a friend of mine spent a few years working towards creating a successful candle business. She didn 't earn much income, her husband supported her, and in the end it didn 't work out....   [tags: Decision making, Flipism, 2002 albums]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on The Future Is Now : What You Should Know About Self Driving Cars

- The Future Is Now: What You Should Know About Self-Driving Cars If you’re still among the many people who believe that self-driving cars are the stuff of science-fiction – or that they won’t make an appearance for another decade or so – you may be surprised to learn that these machines are closer to materializing on roads than you thought. In fact, Google has already begun production of the driverless vehicles, in order to start testing them as soon as possible. The goal is to get the cars on the road within five years, so you could be relaxing in one of these autonomous products by the early part of the next decade – and you won’t even need a steering wheel to guide you to any of the place...   [tags: Automobile, Driverless car, Transport, Wheel]

Better Essays
909 words (2.6 pages)

You Can Be Anything You Want to Be: How Self-Image Effects Quality of Life

- You Can Be Anything We Want You to Be It is a known fact that one’s physiology and sociology affects one’s psychology, but there are many different factors that lead to different outcomes. The way one appears to others and self-image has a major role in the way one behaves, as well as the greatest factor the quality of one’s life (e.g., Economic status, community, (slums or suburbs) and nationality). I believe that the stereotypes society puts on individuals are the biggest role in one’s psychology, basically people say “I am going to behave the way I am because I am expected to behave like this.” Body image has been defined as the unconscious mental representation of one’s own body....   [tags: identity, stereotypes, behavior]

Better Essays
793 words (2.3 pages)

Defining the Concept of Self Essay

- Who am I. There are many of us walking around trying to figure out who we are and what we stand for. Self-reflection can be conveyed in many different ways, using many different adjectives to describe the person we are. There are some who will give an honest description of one’s self and then there is some who become delusional with the perception they want others to see. Most people on social sites create a profile which can be so far from whom they really are, it is usually a perception of who they want to be....   [tags: self-reflection, self-esteem]

Better Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

Self-Esteem and Self-Concept Essay

- In today’s age and the growing trend in American society of “what’s hot and what’s not”, is having a huge impact on young children’s self-concept and self-esteem. Self-concept “refers to the beliefs, attitudes, knowledge, and ideas people have about themselves,” whereas self-esteem is “a personal judgment of worthiness that indicates the extent to which the individual believes himself to be capable, significant, successful, and worthy (392).”      My interest on this subject was peaked after spending the evening with my five year-old cousin, Sami, last week....   [tags: Self Image Self Perception Essays]

Free Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

Self-Concept Essay

- The Self-Concept is a complicated process of gaining self-awareness. It consists of mental images an individual has of oneself: physical appearance, health, accomplishments, skills, social talents, roles, intellectual traits, and emotional states and more –all make up our self-concept.      The development process begins at about six or seven months of age. The child begins to recognize “self” as distinct from surroundings. They stare at anything they see, including their own body parts; hands, feet, toes, and fingers....   [tags: Self Concept]

Better Essays
1467 words (4.2 pages)