Over the past month and a half, many articles and people battled my close-minded view. I expected Amy Levine’s Agree to Disagree presentation to illustrate differences in Jews’ and Christians’ interpretations with specific Old Testament verses, but she validated both religions’ interpretations because, “they are following their own set of rules.” For example, the Old Testament has no punctuation, and some significant differences between Jewish and Christian interpretations are because of the placement of punctuation breaks. Amy argues that both Jews and Christians arrived at credible conclusions about the punctuation. Confused, I asked myself, “How can both be right? Isn’t it one or the other?” I wasn’t willing to accept both interpretations as valid. I just wanted to ignore her reasoning and continue believing the Christian explanation. I have a tendency to look at differing perspectives like a computer: True or False. However, people like Amy have challenged me to move away from dualism and towards multiplicity by making me aware of the other respectable perspectives.
My close-minded view is also characterized by my stubbornness to change my mind. I was taught to defend my beliefs in all situations. In the trolley dilemma we discussed in class, I continually used my opinion that each life is worth the same value to support ...
... middle of paper ...
... culture, I will continued to be trapped by it.
Before college, dualism satisfied me because of its simplicity. However, through the difficult discussions I have had in the last six weeks, I noticed the flaws of this critical thinking approach. I am learning how to search for multiple perspectives and opinions and validate multiply options both logically and emotionally. An important realization is how powerful awareness can be for understanding myself and how to better understand and interact with my communities and cultures. Now, I am striving to understand and (practice) relativism. What is the better option? Honestly I do not know yet. My new goal is not about deciding what is right and what is wrong but which approach is better compared to others. I look forward to making the transition between multiplicity and relativism during the second part of the semester.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- The Different Interpretations of The Binding of Isaac in Abraham by Bruce Feiler The binding of Isaac, also known as Abraham’s sacrifice of his youngest son Isaac has been named as one of Abraham’s defining moments next to the call. The sacrifice of Isaac has been talked and written about for centuries. Also, it has been given various interpretations depending on the religion one follows. Through critical analysis, I will be going through the different interpretations of the binding of Isaac in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam.... [tags: Islam, Jesus, Binding of Isaac, Isaac]
1398 words (4 pages)
- While most westerners know the story of Joseph as a passage from the end of the book of Genesis in the Bible or the Torah, understanding the story and its intricacies in sura 12 of the Qur’an proves equally important. Joseph’s story in Genesis emphasizes his personal abilities and God rewarding him and his people’s loyalty and faith amidst hardship. The Qur’an takes the same plot and enforces the theme of monotheism and Joseph’s prophetic role in its spread. The Qur’an’s interpretation serves as a more influential religious text in the context of its body of belief, whereas the Biblical story of Joseph, with its thematically intriguing story line and embellishments, comparatively serves a g... [tags: genesis, christian, islam]
1171 words (3.3 pages)
- For years people have had a hard time distinguishing the difference between Christians and Jews. Even when reading about these two religions, they are very similar. There are two main differences that stand out the most amongst these religions. One of them is that Christians believe that Jesus is the Messiah while Jews believe He was a prophet. The other difference is their opinions on sacred texts. Jewish people and Christians both have sacred text; however, Christians believe that the Bible is meant to be read as a whole.... [tags: Bible, Old Testament, Christianity, Jesus]
1118 words (3.2 pages)
- Both Christianity and Judaism are religions that have some relationship between them as much as they also have differences. Judaism and Christianity developed on the basis obeying God, on adherence to his rules and fulfillment of God’s will is a duty of a Jewish or Christian person, both religions fall into the rule deontological category. In Judaism, God is seen as having a contractual relationship with the Jewish people where they must obey his holy laws in return for their status of the chosen people.... [tags: Judaism, Christianity, Old Testament, Torah]
1015 words (2.9 pages)
- Unity in Variety Rahner’s idea that the experience of a human being is key to religion spreads through the religious traditions of Judaism, Buddhism, and Hinduism. His emphasis on the transcendence of the human being points toward using the incomprehensible mystery in human experience to measure understanding, rather than attempting to capture the Divine within anthropomorphic knowledge. Through Philip Sheldrake’s “Jewish Spirituality” and “Buddhist Spirituality”, Frank Whaling’s Understanding Hinduism, and Reverend Myo Denis Lahey’s “Is There Anybody There.... [tags: Religion, Hinduism, Buddhism, Spirituality]
1299 words (3.7 pages)
- Parallelisms and Differences:Rastafarianism and Judaism The two religions of Rastafarianism and Judaism embody many of the same characteristics, as well as their ancestry. Although the Rastafarians, at times, inaccurately explain the bible, their belief in the Old Testament is still prevalent. Many of the customs are almost identical, but the rationale behind the traditions and laws contrast greatly. In 1933, when Leonard P. Howell was arrested for using"seditious and blasphemous language,"to boost the sale of pictures of Haile Selassie, he stated that Selassie was,"King Ras Tafari of Abyssinia, son of king Solomon by the queen of Sheba."1 Howell knew that in later years factual informatio... [tags: Rastafarianism Judaism Religion Essays]
6351 words (18.1 pages)
- Possibly mimicking the Jewish Torah, Christians have their beliefs written down in the Bible. Like the Torah, the bible contains rules to abide, miracles, guidance and history (Biblica, 2013). But in my academic opinion, the main similarity is that both texts contain the Pentateuch/old testament. Yes, Christianity has the added New Testament with stories of Jesus Christ, but it’s important not to forget the Jewish origins of the Bible and that Jesus himself, and even the word messiah, is Hebrew.... [tags: Judaism, Torah, Christianity, Bible]
927 words (2.6 pages)
- Beth El Congregation is a Jewish congregation located in Central Phoenix. They are affiliated with the Conservative Judaism movement. According to leader of the congregation, Rabbi Lavinsky, this locates their convictions and interpretation of the Torah somewhere in the middle between the orthodox and liberal groups. He stated this is reflected in the motto of the movement: “Tradition and Change.” I visited Beth El Synagogue for a Saturday morning Shabbat service. The set up of inside the sanctuary was similar to a Catholic church.... [tags: Torah, Judaism, Christianity, Jewish services]
774 words (2.2 pages)
- Jewish Perceptions of Jesus Christ Christianity and Judaism are major world religions which, though they worship the same God, have marked differences which have caused two thousand years of strife and animosity between the two religions. In his book We Jews and Jesus, Samuel Sandmel likens the link between Judaism and Christianity to a type of parent-child relationship, saying, “Early Christianity was a Judaism; within a century after the death of Jesus it was a separate religion. It was critical of its parent, and hostile to it, and elicited from its parent reciprocal criticism and hostility.”1 Opposing views of Jesus Christ caused the initial rift between Judaism and Christianity a... [tags: Judaism Christianity Christian Religion Religious]
5216 words (14.9 pages)
- While we speak about the tenuous relationship between Christians and Jews dating back to the time of Christ, the seeds for the schism within Judaism may have been planted more than 500 years prior. Jeremiah was one of a group of distinguished prophets whose works became part of the Old Testament canon. The Jewish "wisdom" prophets lectured, warned and blamed all who would listen about the sins of their own people, the resulting punishments that God had prescribed for them, and what they had to do to get back into God's good graces.... [tags: essays research papers]
1925 words (5.5 pages)