Definition, Logical Consistency, Testability And Empirical Validity Of A Theory?

Definition, Logical Consistency, Testability And Empirical Validity Of A Theory?

Length: 731 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Although there are many theories that are evaluated, only some of them are considered good theories based on certain evaluation criterion that is met. Too be considered a good theory there are several evaluation criterion that need to be met such as the logical consistency, testability and empirical validity. The logical consistency has two elements, the scope and parsimony, both are interrelated. The scope of a theory refers to the range of explanation (Akers & Sellers, 2013, p. 5). If the scope of a theory is limited then the theory itself is limited. For example, if a theory only focuses on one crime rather than several crimes then the scope of the theory may be limited. In addition to scope, parsimony refers to “using as few concepts and propositions as possible to explain the widest range of phenomena” (Akers & Sellers, 2013, p. 5). With parsimony, it needs to be simple, but sufficient. An example of a theory with logical consistency is Deterrence Theory. Logical consistency is applicable to the theory because it recognizes that all crimes have threat/risk of punishment which leads to deterrence of committing crimes. As a result, the theory is simple, but also covers a wide range of phenomena, such as all crimes, that encompasses both a large scope and parsimony.
In addition to logical consistency, testability is an important piece when evaluating a theory. According to Akers & Sellers (2013), “a theory must be testable by objective, repeatable evidence” (p.5); thus, if the theory is not testable then it has no scientific value. There are several reasons why a theory might not be testable; such as its concepts may not be observable or reportable events and tautology. Tautology refers to a statement or hypothesis that is tr...


... middle of paper ...


...eled a criminal (X) renders the occurrence of them continuing that lifestyle (Y) more probable.
In addition to theories causality, the quality of the empirical test is important. A theory that doesn’t measure the independent and dependent variables correctly could cause inadequate methodological quality. Also, it could cause issues with hypothesising. Furthermore, if the theory doesn’t collect enough data from a related, large and diverse sample then the theory is insufficient. All of these pieces correlate to contribute to a sufficient empirical test. For example, if a theory suggests all men who grow up in a violent house hold will commit violent acts in the future, but doesn’t collect data from a large enough population or includes women in the study then their empirical testing could be insignificant, which would lead to the theory not being empirically valid.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Definition Of An Experiential Proposition Essays

- The criterion of verifiability says that a sentence is meaningful if and only if it has some relation to observation. The message Ayer is trying to establish is the meaningfulness of some sentence by relating it to some set of observation sentences, and does not require the observations to be made. All that is required is that in principle we can make those observations. Ayer defines meaningfulness in terms of what he calls strong verifiability and defines meaningfulness in terms of either conclusive verification or conclusive falsification....   [tags: Scientific method, Falsifiability, Hypothesis]

Better Essays
848 words (2.4 pages)

Argument And Validity Of Validity And Soundness Essay examples

- Paper Topic 3 For this paper I will break down the following argument in terms of validity and soundness: If an argument has a true conclusion, then it is both valid and sound. If an argument is sound, then it is valid. An argument will have a true conclusion if it is sound. An argument has a false conclusion only if it is valid. If an argument has a false conclusion, then it is invalid. An argument is both valid and invalid. Therefore, an argument is sound if and only if it is sound. I have prepared a dictionary to more clearly distinguish the different premises....   [tags: Logic, Argument, Validity, Soundness]

Better Essays
1064 words (3 pages)

Instrumentation : Instrument And Instrumentation Validity Essay

- 1. INSTRUMENT/INSTRUMENTATION VALIDITY Definition: Instrumentation validity determines where the instrument is actually measuring the proper content (Straub, Boudreau, & Gefen, 2004). Example: A practical example of instrumentation validity in business is the use and validity of annual employee satisfaction surveys or questionnaires. Firms place significant emphasis on addressing the employee satisfaction issues derived from the survey. My employer, AECOM, requires senior executives to developed actions plans to address and make changes based on the results of the survey....   [tags: Validity, Psychometrics, SAT, SAT Subject Tests]

Better Essays
963 words (2.8 pages)

The Bornstein Pf Model And Traditional Model Of Validity Essay

- This paper discusses the Bornstein PF model and traditional model of validity. It discusses how Bornstein maintains that it is important to use the PF model of validity. It discusses the tools used to group categories of mental activities and behaviors when responding to test. Furthermore, it discusses how Bornstein’s PF model could assess with validity in assessment of children with autism and difficulties with social functioning. Validity is how well a test or measurement tool measures what it purports to measure....   [tags: Psychometrics, Validity, Assessment, Autism]

Better Essays
1574 words (4.5 pages)

Validity: Critical Thinking About A Research Project Essay

- Validity A research is valid to the world when a number of key concepts are used in the research design. The document must be organized and planned according to the criteria used in the field. Some important concepts to know include: validity, variable, operationalization, sample, measurement, measurement error, causation, plausible rival explanations, hypothesis, reliability, and unit of analysis. The researcher must learn how to apply each key concept in an effort to make the research study valuable....   [tags: validity, variable, operationalization]

Better Essays
1596 words (4.6 pages)

Validity and Effect of Emotional intelligence on Effectiveness of Organizational Leaders and the Enterprise

- Introduction Validity is the extent to which a test measures what it claims to measure. It is essential for a test to be valid in order for the results to be accurately applied and interpreted. Validity isn’t determined by a single statistic, but by a body of research that demonstrates the relationship between the test and the behavior it has set out to measure. This paper examines the issue of validity research, comparing, and contrasting the characteristics of internal, external, and construct validity, while identifying the threats to them....   [tags: information security, research, content validity]

Better Essays
1371 words (3.9 pages)

Internal And External Validity Of A Research Study Essay

- Define internal and external validity. Discuss the importance of each. Internal validity refers to whether the effects observed in a study are due to the manipulation of the independent variable and not some other factor. In other words there is a causal relationship between the independent and dependent variable. External validity is the validity of generalized (causal) inferences in scientific research, usually based on experiments as experimental validity. In other words, it is the extent to which the results of a study can be generalized to other situations and to other people....   [tags: Scientific method, Validity, Reliability]

Better Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Validity: External, Internal, and Construct Essay

- Validity In research paradigm, validity and reliability are the most basic characteristic issues used in qualitative and quantitative analysis. Validity as a psychometric standard is embedded in a positivist approach, which is relevant in reflecting on the qualitative point of view ascribed to the establishment of the truth. In view of this, definition of positivism ascribe to a theory systematic to validity. Additionally, other empirical conceptions culminating from resided validity include truth, deduction, universal laws, evidence, reason, and actuality among others....   [tags: Business Management ]

Better Essays
2019 words (5.8 pages)

Definition Essays : Definition Essay

- EXTENDED DEFINITION ESSAY A definition essay entails more than just a simple dictionary definition. Definition essay extends the definition by providing more examples to enable the reader to understand the terms and concepts being defined. In other words, a definition essay is an article that gives explanation on a term’s meaning. In some cases, some words have certain substantial meaning, for example, jug, pencil, or tree. And some terms such as integrity, virtue, or hero is conceptual and they depend more, on how a person views them, their definition will also depend on the context in which the person is....   [tags: Love, Interpersonal relationship, Definition]

Better Essays
892 words (2.5 pages)

Validity Essay

- Validity The use of music seems to be a good way of operationalising the IV as many people do learn to the sound of music so therefore the difference between the music and no music condition should be marked. Also, getting the participants to write down the words is a good way of measuring the DV as it means it is easy to collect and analyse the data. The study itself was quite simple and it seemed to measure what effects music has on learning....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
949 words (2.7 pages)