Defining Spinoza 's Reasoning Behind His ' Deus Sive Natura ' Essay

Defining Spinoza 's Reasoning Behind His ' Deus Sive Natura ' Essay

Length: 869 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

This essay hopes to define Spinoza’s reasoning behind his ‘Deus sive Natura’, arguing that God and Nature, or the universe, are but one substance. This separation is distinct to Spinoza’s substance monism, and argued through a geometric essay structure that allows reasoning to be accessible, as well as logical should the reasoning at each step have validity.
Spinoza defines a substance as something ‘conceived through itself’ , there cannot be anything that causes a substance as it is ‘self-explanatory’ . Therefore, Spinoza reasons, it comes to follow that one substance cannot be caused by another, and so two substances must essentiality not share any attributes.

However, having two, or more, substances, cannot explain why this number of substances exist, and so, Spinoza explains the world as having just one substance with infinite attributes, which avoids having to make this impossible explanation. Spinoza’s reasons his argument in proposition V by stating that ‘there cannot exist in the universe two or more substances having the same nature or attribute’ .

He argues to highlight the difference between substances and the importance of distinguishability, as based on his earlier propositions I and IV, that there ‘cannot be granted several substances, but one substance only.’ Whilst inspecting Spinoza’s work it is important to analyse previous arguments and the assumptions that the focused proposition is set upon. For example proposition V rests upon axioms I and IV, as well as, definitions III, V, VI. By backwardly engineering the argument, Spinoza lays out a firm, clear argument that builds from the basic definition of a substance to an argument pertaining the reasoning of his argument.
Substance monism expresses one subst...


... middle of paper ...


...rehand be proved that the statement itself is true. The problem remains that, there is nothing to validate the definition of Spinoza’s ‘substance’ any more than ‘substance’ defined by Plato or David Hume for example. The subjectivity of definition as a principle, especially if taken only at face value of the reader, leaves a poor foundation for a philosophical argument. This remains to be Spinoza’s biggest weakness of his ‘Deus sive Natura’.

Spinoza develops his ideas of substance in relation to God and/or Nature in the Ethics, the reasoning he uses is based off of his idea that the universe is not a culmination of materials and a separate deity, but rather that to two are intrinsically linked. His argument, though sometimes difficult to read, is coherently traceable back to the beginning to show the reasoning that leads to the assumptions made in the propositions.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Review Of Benedict Xvi 's ' Deus Caritas Est ' Essay

- DEUS CARITAS EST In Deus Caritas Est, written by Benedict XVI, talks about love. There are two part of the letter. The first section talks about the love that God has offered to all of us. The second part talks about charity. Also talks about loving neighbors and God. Within the first part of the letter talks about how we use love to describe our feelings for objects and each other. We say we love doing something or a type of music. We have been using the word love so much that the word itself has started losing its meaning....   [tags: Love, Greek words for love, Deus Caritas Est]

Better Essays
978 words (2.8 pages)

The No Child Left Behind Act Essay

- On December 10, 2015, President Barack Obama signed a revised version of the No Child Left Behind Act called the Every Student Succeeds Act (ESSA). ESSA is a US law designed to govern the nations K-12 education policy. This policy ensures success and provides equal opportunity for students and schools. ESSA guarantees that our nation will set high standards furnishing students with the opportunity to graduate high school and become college or career ready, maintain accountability and provide adequate resources to improve low performing schools and students, confirm annual state assessments measuring students’ progress assessable to educators, students, families and communities and support s...   [tags: High school, No Child Left Behind Act, Education]

Better Essays
1443 words (4.1 pages)

The, Death, By De Rerum Natura Essay

- In the section “Death” in De Rerum Natura, Lucretius addresses to our mortal fear that death brings the loss of everything we are, and that we must one day forfeit ourselves to the universe. Unfortunately, he does this by urging you to come to the understanding that losing every aspect of what a person is, both physically and in the world of forms, is inevitable. Death eradicates both mind and body; the two are intrinsically linked in life and death. Furthermore, it should be by this very fear of the inevitability of personal oblivion that we are soothed....   [tags: Meaning of life, Existence, Life, Lucretius]

Better Essays
1221 words (3.5 pages)

Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Essay

- Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Ian Buruma was born in the Netherlands in 1951. He went to school in both Holland and Japan, and he has spent a great deal of time in Japan. Ian Buruma is an author, journalist and a professor at Bard College in New York. He sometimes writes for the New York Review of Books, the New York Times Magazine, the New Republic, the New Yorker, and the Guardian. The book, Behind the Mask, was a very interesting one. This book is filled with lots of Japans history that most people know nothing about....   [tags: Ian Buruma Behind the Mask]

Free Essays
468 words (1.3 pages)

The No Child Left Behind Act Essays

- President Bush quoted, “Clearly, our children are our future…Too many of our neediest children are being left behind” (www.ed.gov). The “No Child Left Behind” Act expands the federal government’s role in elementary and secondary education. The NCLB act was enacted January 8, 2002, and has four reform principles to the act: Accountability, flexibility, Researched-based reforms and parental options. Accountability begins with informed parents, communities and elected leaders so we can work together to improve schools....   [tags: No Child Left Behind, USA, ]

Better Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

Falling Behind by Robert Frank Essay

- Robert H. Frank’s book Falling Behind is a short, lucid, and compelling account of what is going on with the middle class”(Alexander Kemestrios Ben). That is what one reviewer on Amazon.com commented about Frank’s book Falling Behind: How Rising Inequality Harms the Middle Class. In order to engage readers and support their ideas, most argumentative nonfiction books use statistics, logical reasoning, personal anecdotes, and real-life examples. While all of these strategies such as should make an interesting and compelling argument, the question is not of how interesting the book is, but rather is it or is it not a quality argumentative nonfiction book....   [tags: Falling Behind, Robert Frank]

Better Essays
2328 words (6.7 pages)

The Crusades: Deus Vult Essays

- “Deus vult!” These two words would spark one of the most controversial events in history, the Crusades. Spoken by Pope Urban II, “Deus vult” means “God wills it” in Latin. These two simple words were said to inspire the masses of Europe. They would also cause the bloody conflict that would ravage the Holy Land and drag generations of warriors into the chaos. Today many believe the crusades were a war between Islam and Christianity. That religion was the main cause and only cause of this event. They are right in thinking this, for religion was a cause, but it was not the only cause but one of many factors....   [tags: History]

Better Essays
1066 words (3 pages)

Essay on The House Behind the Cedars by Charles Chesnutt

- Tryon’s Transformation Norman Vincent Peal once remarked: when a person changes their thoughts, they change their world. Unfortunately, too many individuals do not want to make that change. Human nature causes one to stick to what he knows, to be cautious and remain within his own boundaries. Some people, however, accept differences and embrace change; they may not know what to expect but they are ready to change. In The House Behind the Cedars, Charles Chesnutt writes of George Tryon, who is able to take such a step....   [tags: House Behind Cedars Charles Chesnutt]

Free Essays
1376 words (3.9 pages)

Concealment in Chesnutt’s The House Behind the Cedars Essay

- Concealment in Chesnutt’s The House Behind the Cedars Who has something to hide. Everyone in The House behind the Cedars has something to hide. With the possible exception of a few minor characters and children (innocents/ innocence), most characters have something to conceal. Taking this into account, this is more than likely Chesnutt’s acknowledgement of human nature before he gets into the varying motives. Is concealment ultimately worthwhile. Who is hurt and who is helped – or is there any difference....   [tags: House Behind the Cedar]

Better Essays
729 words (2.1 pages)

Imagery and Symbolism in David Guterson’s The Country Ahead of Us, The Country Behind

- Imagery and Symbolism in David Guterson’s The Country Ahead of Us, The Country Behind In David Guterson’s anthology, The Country Ahead of Us, The Country Behind, characters are portrayed effectively and succinctly through the imagery of their surroundings. Many of his stories are symbolic in that they reflect relationships and feelings of characters. Guterson’s titles have a more complex and deeper connection to the story than is first apparent. They too are often symbolic of a main character, or of relationships....   [tags: Guterson Country Ahead of Us Country Behind]

Free Essays
2054 words (5.9 pages)