Decline in Comprehensive Urban Planning Essay example

Decline in Comprehensive Urban Planning Essay example

Length: 1494 words (4.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The decline in comprehensive urban planning was one of the major assets in determining the capitalist view facing social resistance. This made it difficult for planners considering the number of critiques that persistently argued about the impact of planning. This is because cities have changed; there was no way to hold a consistent plan. The conflict between the central controls needed to perform comprehensive urban planning versus the capitalism in which individual property holders say about of how things are done because of their interests in their property. The increasing power of property holders made it more difficult for planners to take comprehensive approaches. Critiques argue that being able to restructure the urban infrastructure plans would only lead to failure in terms of economic and technological demands. Roughly, there were a lot of individuals that owed their own property and did not want comprehensive planning; therefore capitalism was the cause of the fall of the comprehensive ideal in the urban planning.

Most of the planners were questioned by critiques in regards to the infrastructure ideal, such as, highway, road, airport and rail. Local state employers found that if everyone owned their own property in the city, they will eventually have their own wants and needs. This would explain the evolution into planning on a much smaller scale. This would create problem because it would not keep cities planned, or under no control. Another association with comprehensive urban planning is modern planning that is also discredited by criticisms. During the 1960s and 1980s, it was unable to carry out modern planning because of the alternation of social, economic and cultural aspects. Sandercock indicates that the Chi...


... middle of paper ...


...instance, let's say you build a system of roads, bridges, water, sewer etc. throughout an entire city. All those factors cost millions in taxpayer funds. If those projects do not attract businesses and increase employment in the city which generates tax revenues, how is the city going to pay off the bonds it sold to pay for the infrastructure? So they decided to target certain areas and projects with specific goals. Edward W. Soja, author of the book, Postmetropolis: critical studies of cities and regions states, “Even in its most progressive forms, urban planning was seem as functioning primarily, if often unintentionally, to serve the basic needs of capital and the capitalist state.” This again goes back to the small-scale infrastructures that are accompanied by planners. To illustrate, Boston Tunnel, is famous infrastructure project known as "The Big Dig".



Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Comprehensive Plans Essay

- Throughout the western world once the need for urban planning was recognized albeit gradually there had been many stages of improvement in the way Planners approached urban problems. Various time periods saw evolution of different methodologies and strategies in the way planners plan. The paradigms shifted from focusing initially on large plans and city beautiful movements to more neighborhood based community improvement plans today. However, the most important change that had occurred over the period of time in planning thinking should be the way the focus had shifted from physical aspects of a city to community participation and intermittent process involved in making a plan....   [tags: Economics ]

Powerful Essays
1326 words (3.8 pages)

The Construction Of Urban Planning Essay

- Introduction Urban planning is a process that relates to the use of a piece of land; its development, maintenance and protection. Primarily, it involves creating a practical design that distributes each component of the city while including unique values dedicated to a certain group of people. The plan has to follow a certain criteria concerning regulations, environmental issues, public facilities, and economic growth. This process is important to determine and assure that an available space will be used in the most functional way possible and that its citizens will be satisfied with their surroundings....   [tags: City, Urban planning, Urban area]

Powerful Essays
1107 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Urban Planning For Los Angeles

- Urban Planning in Los Angeles In this paper, we will discuss Planning management system in Los Angeles Planning control institutional subsystem Las Angeles is one of those cities of California, which have an active governing system. Mayor is the administrator of this town, so Los Angeles city has strong mayor-council structure. Mayor is responsible for the appointment of Director of planning in the city, who leads the department of city planning in Los Angeles. City planning department of Los Angeles founded in 1941....   [tags: City, Urban planning, Los Angeles, Lewis Mumford]

Powerful Essays
1036 words (3 pages)

Essay on Participation in Urban Planning of China

- Participation in urban planning of China Introduction With the development of society and economic, public participation has been a popular topic which attracted people from different fields. On the basic of various theories of urban planning, a great amount of market economy countries have successively established public participation system in the field of urban planning. These successful experiences provide a good guide for China urban planning to use for reference, the changes in Chinese politics, economic system and social culture also provide an opportunity to do a new change on urban planning system of China....   [tags: planning theories]

Powerful Essays
923 words (2.6 pages)

The Impact of Contemporary Urban Planning Principles and the Setback Regulations Implemented in Riyadh

- Since the 1950s, the cities of Saudi Arabia witnessed significant changes in the composition of the population and the arrangement of the built environment. The Saudi society has transformed from a nomadic pastoral society to a highly modernized one as a result of the increase in national revenues from oil production. Rapid growth and improved economic conditions led to the adoption of modern planning principles which are in contrary to the traditional city. Although modernization had contributed to raising the living standard of the neighbourhood, it led to the creation of social, cultural and climate problems as well....   [tags: Urban Planning]

Powerful Essays
2694 words (7.7 pages)

Essay on Japanese Urban Planning

- Since 1918, urban planning throughout Japan has continuously been changing. When Japan first began urban planning, the main focus was of the industrial society that was dominated numerous of Japan’s cities. As time went on, the industries stayed in the cities and the government then had to deal with the problems of industries, including environmental problems along with population increases. At the beginning, numerous of the plans and strategies were based on what other cities Europe had done and this strategy continued throughout the urban planning process....   [tags: Urban Development ]

Powerful Essays
1632 words (4.7 pages)

Using Spatial Planning For The Rural Urban Divide Essay

- Using Spatial Planning to Lessen the Rural-Urban Divide A high quality spatial plan carries a high degree of legitimacy (Elbakidze, et al., 2015). This high level of legitimacy is important to ensure buy-in from all stakeholders. Spatial plans effectively lessen the rural-urban divide by connecting local with broader spatial agendas, plans not only plan for the urban areas but are aware of and plan for the sub-regional and regional areas as well (Gallent & Shaw, 2007). Sustainable lifestyles focus on livability for all rather than the few....   [tags: City, Rural area, Urban sprawl, Rural]

Powerful Essays
917 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The Spectrum of Urban Planning

- The Spectrum of Urban Planning Urban Planning is the process of planning the development of land and other resources to improve a community in ways that benefit the lives of people within these communities. Urban Planning is a complex area of study because of the many different factors involved and the people it has an effect on. Planning can be controversial, political, and cause anger towards officials if it is not executed correctly. Urban planners must weigh their decisions and base them on the good of the environment and the people....   [tags: City Planning, Engineering]

Powerful Essays
1940 words (5.5 pages)

Essay on Urban Planning History

- There have been many significant movements throughout urban planning history which have influenced the way that planning theory is shaped and thought. Combined Modernist and Neoliberal planning theories have influenced the erection of a vast amount of planning project that have left an imprint on the way that urban planning is practiced today. In this paper, I will begin by describing the components of modernist and neoliberal planning practices. Then, I will outline a brief history of the project and explain how the Los Angeles South Central Farm was influenced by both modernist and neoliberal planning theories....   [tags: Urban Research ]

Powerful Essays
1650 words (4.7 pages)

City Planning As A Movement Essay

- According to Park Dixon Goist (1977). “city Planning emerged as a movement and then a profession in the late nineteenth century and the early twentieth century“ which was formed by a number of related interests such as included landscape architects, architects, progressive politics, housing reform, the city beautiful movement, the Garden city or the new towns idea, regionalism and zoning. (Goist, 1977, page 121). The idea of city planning therefore emerged at the time when the industrial revolution was at its peak and people were flocking from the villages into cities for better jobs and pay....   [tags: City, Urban planning, Landscape architecture]

Powerful Essays
1928 words (5.5 pages)