Essay on Culture of Critique

Essay on Culture of Critique

Length: 950 words (2.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Americans have embraced debate since before we were a country. The idea that we would provide reasoned support for any position that we took is what made us different from the English king. Our love of debate came from the old country, and embedded itself in our culture as a defining value. Thus, it should not come as a surprise that the affinity for debate is still strong, and finds itself as a regular feature of the mainstream media. However, if Deborah Tannen of the New York Times is correct, our understanding of what it means to argue may be very different from what it once was; a “culture of critique” has developed within our media, and it relies on the exclusive opposition of two conflicting positions (Tannen). In her 1994 editorial, titled “The Triumph of the Yell”, Tannen claims that journalists, politicians and academics treat public discourse as an argument. Furthermore, she attempts to persuade her readers that this posturing of argument as a conflict leads to a battle, not a debate, and that we would be able to communicate the truth if this culture were not interfering. This paper will discuss the rhetorical strategies that Tannen utilizes, outline the support given in her editorial, and why her argument is less convincing than it should be.
Firstly , Tannen introduces the term “culture of critique” by beginning three successive paragraphs with the term so that the reader will not forget it. Tannen then identifies the problem presented by the “culture of critique”, that is, a tendency to attack the person making an argument, or misrepresenting the issue, rather than arguing against their position itself. She points out that instead of listening to reason, people who are caught up in the culture of critique debate as i...


... middle of paper ...


...dibility by mentioning that journalists and television producers defer to her as an authority, but she does not make a case for being an expert. Moreover, she maintains a detached tone for a majority of the editorial, as an appeal to her authority on the matter, but switches to and involved perspective when giving illustration. This would otherwise be acceptable, except that the illustration is given in place of supporting theory or fully supported argument. To that end, Tannen’s argument would be much more persuasive if she had articulated her position with an even tone, and avoided sensationalism when giving examples.


Works Cited
Robinson, David. “Web Page of Deborah Tannen.” Georgetown College - Georgetown University. 28 Feb 1998. 15 Jun 2008
Tannen, Deborah. “The Triumph of the Yell.” New York Times 14 Jan 1994.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Mass Culture Critique And Perezhilton.Com Essay

- The past two years has seen the media landscape undergo significant developments. New technology, such as the Internet, has fuelled the emergence of new media forms and schisms within the media industry. Mario Armando Lavandeira’s Hollywood celebrity gossip website, PerezHilton.com, exploits a new brand of journalism – blogging. There are innumerable media theories which could be used to analyse such a specific example of the media. This essay will explore Mass Culture Critique and its critical relation to PerezHilton.com by investigating mass communication concepts such as hegemony, aesthetic levels, economic motivation, and passive consumers....   [tags: Mass Culture Media Popular]

Better Essays
1835 words (5.2 pages)

Teodor Adorno 's Critique on Mass Culture Essay

- Teodor Adorno 's Critique on Mass Culture “ When I was, later, confronted to the problematic of measuring culture, I understood that culture had to be precisely this condition that exclude any mindset able to measure it” - Teodor Adorno - Before the development of education and mass communication techniques, the production and diffusion of culture followed a simple logic: only a cast of privileged – aristocrats and bourgeois - had access to a “high culture” (Curran, 1997). Only since the XXth century and the change of the political landscape as well as the evolution of technology and the liberalisation of the economy has this trend started to change....   [tags: aristocrats, bourgeois, culture]

Better Essays
1115 words (3.2 pages)

Article Critique On Attachment, Culture, And The Caregiving System Essay

- ... From the videotaped interactions, maternal sensitivity, emotional expression, and physical control was measured using a nine point scale where "one" represented the lowest amount of interaction observed and "nine" the highest (Carlson, Harwood, 2003). A week after the twelve month visit, mothers participated in the Strange Situation. When looking at interactions in the Strange Situation, the percentage of securely attached infants were pretty even among the two groups. Fifty-two percent of the Puerto Rican infants and fifty-nine percent of Anglo infants were securely attached....   [tags: Attachment theory, Mary Ainsworth]

Better Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Essay on A Qualitative Critique of a Culture of Mutual Support

- Clarity and Significance of Phenomenon Phenomenon Clearly Described Phenomena are those things that are perceived by the senses; it is the lived experience (LoBiondo-Wood, G., Haber, J. 2010). While reading the study readers may feel that they need to come to their own conclusion about what the phenomena of the study was, it is not clearly describe by the researchers. The reader may find several ideas that the researchers might be wanting to get across to the reader, but because of disorganization, it is hard to find a clear phenomena....   [tags: Health Care]

Better Essays
1720 words (4.9 pages)

Article Critique : Work Life And Patient Safety Culture Essay

- Summary Article Critique: Work Life and Patient Safety Culture in Canadian Healthcare Introduction Poor job satisfaction can lead to potential burnout and reduced productivity and quality of work, is an accepted fact in most of Canada. However would the same be true about healthcare workers and their effects on patient care and outcomes. Health care workers are held to high standards and strict policies about the care that they provide. The argument is that due to these high demands and decreased time and support, the patients of healthcare staff that have a poor work life and suffer from burnout are also suffering....   [tags: Health care, Health care provider, Patient]

Better Essays
1219 words (3.5 pages)

Essay about A Critique of Culture Shift by David W. Henderson

- A Critique of Culture Shift by David W. Henderson The church has a problem. The eternally relevant message with which she has been entrusted no longer readily finds a willing ear. According to Henderson, the solution lies in first understanding how our world thinks and then, beginning where people are at, bring them to see "the functional relevance for their lives of the actual relevance of our message". In high school speech classes, we were taught to "know your audience." As a careless high schooler, I didn't really care what she meant, but it eventually made sense (once I actually decided to think about it)....   [tags: Religion Religious Essays]

Free Essays
1358 words (3.9 pages)

Harold E. Stearns’ Critique of American Culture in the Book, Civilization in the United States

- Harold E. Stearns’ Critique of American Culture in the Book, Civilization in the United States Harold E. Stearns and his colleagues set out on a mission to enlighten and inform the American society of the 1920’s in their book entitled Civilization in the United States. Thirty-three authors with the aid of an editor, Stearns, instead produced a highly controversial and inadequate account of certain aspects of life in American society. According to critic Arthur Schlesinger the writers of Civilization in the United States fell short of their goal of producing a critical depiction of American society and instead wrote "supercilious reflections" (167)....   [tags: American America History]

Free Essays
1467 words (4.2 pages)

Color Coded: A Cultural Critique of the Role of Color in African American Culture and its Effect on the African American Woman

- As a race of people that have an extensive history of being enslaved and oppressed for several generations, African Americans have gained a myriad of twisted ideologies that have been passed down for generations. One that is very intrinsic to general mindset of the community is the belief that light skinned African Americans are superior to their dark skinned counterparts. Furthermore, this ideology has also affected the standards of beauty within the race and has altered the self-image, aspirations, and overall psyche of the black woman....   [tags: Race]

Better Essays
1472 words (4.2 pages)

Film Critique of Dances with Wolves Essay

- Film Critique of “Dances with Wolves” This is a wonderful movie that is set in 1863 during the civil war. The main character is John Dunbar, a Lieutenant in the United States Army, who is played by Kevin Costner. The movie begins with Dunbar in the field hospital with a severely wounded leg that the Dr.’s are planning to amputate. Dunbar decides that he does not want to live minus a leg and leaves the field hospital, takes a horse and rides across the length of the enemy lines where he expects that he will meet his death....   [tags: Soldier, Sioux, Culture]

Better Essays
1003 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on A Critique of Berger's Uncertainty Reduction Theory

- A Critique of Berger's Uncertainty Reduction Theory How do people get to know each other. Bugs Bunny likes to open up every conversation with the question, "What's up Doc. Why does he do this. Is Bugs Bunny "uncertain". Let's explore this idea of uncertainty. Shifting focus now to college students. As many other college students at Ohio University, I am put into situations that make me uncertain of my surroundings almost every time I go to a class for the first time, a group meeting, or social event on the weekend....   [tags: Psychology Culture Essays]

Better Essays
886 words (2.5 pages)