Comparison of Temptation in Macbeth and A Simple Plan Essay

Comparison of Temptation in Macbeth and A Simple Plan Essay

Length: 1599 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

William Shakespeare once stated, “Temptation is the fire that brings up the scum of the heart.”(William Shakespeare) Although slightly bleak, many works of art have this similar idea. Through this, similarities are found concerning aspects of each work. Differences occur in the protagonist’s own personal journey on the path of temptation. Undeniably, this parallel is found within William Shakespeare’s own infamous play, Macbeth and the two-time Oscar- winning film, A Simple Plan. Macbeth is fighting for the honor of kingship even though he is not liable to inherit the crown and only becomes acquainted with the idea through a prophecy of three witches. Hank Mitchell, the protagonist of the movie, is presented with 4.4 million dollars in an abandoned plane that he and his friends are first to find. The journeys of both Hank and Macbeth follow a similar plotline that deal with character changes, conflicts confronted and a tragic outcome which seem to root from the pull of temptation.
The personality changes of Hank and Macbeth seem to be largely similar and follow a certain course from beginning to end. Seemingly, Hank and Macbeth appear to be noble and respected within their community. Macbeth is even titled as a nobleman fighting in war for his King, Duncan. He fights along his companion, Banquo, and together they are able to defeat their allies and earn much respect from the other citizens. Hank starts out as approaching fatherhood and works for an insurance company. Many people within his community know him, such as the local sheriff Carl, for taking care of his younger and less successful brother, Jacob. Primarily, Hank and Macbeth hold strong values to do the right thing while being an average man.
Towards the unraveling of ...


... middle of paper ...


...cbeth devises his own simplistic plan to become King, while Hank devises a strategy to have the money remain a secret. Highly motivated and indulged for different reasons, Hank and Macbeth find themselves on killing sprees and eventually reach their goal just to have it easily taken away, mostly due to ignorance. It is quite grim to wonder if all humans were presented with a temptation as appealing as power or money, how much it could turn the most noble of humans to diabolical and greedy as seen within the tragedies of Hank Mitchell and Macbeth.




Works Cited

"William Shakespeare - Temptation Is the Fire That Brings up the Scum of the Heart. | Famous Quotes." 1,400,000 Famous Quotes | Lovely Quotes | Inspirational Quotes & Sayings - Friendship & Life Quotes - | Proverbs - Famous Movie Quotes! Web. 13 Dec. 2010. .

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Captivating Characters in Macbeth and The Crucible Essay

- The Captivating Characters in Macbeth and The Crucible For a play to meet with success, it is essential that it include a cast of interesting and captivating characters. Without interesting characters, the audience would not only be confused by each unimportant character, but possibly puzzled by the plot, disinterested in the theme and ideas, and worst of all, bored by the entire story. For instance, in "The Crucible" by Arthur Miller, we take an immediate interest in 17-year-old Abigail Williams....   [tags: comparison compare contrast essays]

Powerful Essays
1017 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on Temptation Cradle: Lady Macbeth

- Acute award-winning novelist J.K. Rowling once said, “Power was my weakness and my temptation.” Temptation is something everyone encounters at least once in their lives. Indubitably, most people deal with it every day. The hard part about coping with temptation is to decide whether to yield or succumb to this perpetual temptation. Determining what to do with temptation is something that sets people apart from having a fragile, or having a tenacious personality. Shakespeare’s Macbeth fully delves into and reiterates all aspects of temptation throughout the entirety of this timeless play....   [tags: Shakespeare play characters]

Powerful Essays
811 words (2.3 pages)

Macbeth And The Original Man Experience Similar Patterns Of Temptation Essay example

- Before their transgressions, Macbeth and the original man experience similar patterns of temptation. For example, Macbeth lives in an idyllic castle, overwhelmingly reminiscent of Eden in its depiction. After all, visitors, visibly impressed with the grounds, even exclaim, "this castle hath a pleasant seat. The air nimbly and sweetly recommended itself unto our gentle senses" (1.6.1-3). Canonically, the Garden of Eden is the epitome of beauty. However, Adam, senselessly pursuing temptation, grows disenchanted, dreaming of the forbidden fruit....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Original sin, Garden of Eden]

Powerful Essays
1377 words (3.9 pages)

The Temptation od Power Analysis Essay

- In Macbeth, Shakespeare uses motifs and themes in his writing to highlight significant points and messages throughout the play. In the tragedy, Macbeth, a once valiant solider, gets promoted to thane but his ambition to be King runs too far after the witches’ prophecies show that he will become king one day. Macbeth eventually becomes king by killing Duncan and his best friend as he turns violent, insane and greedy for absolute power. Using the motif of temptation, Shakespeare portrays violence, insanity and greed through Macbeth in order to show the consequences associated with absolute power’s corrupting nature....   [tags: william shakespeare, macbeth]

Powerful Essays
914 words (2.6 pages)

Temptation and Sins of Comission Essays

- Several topics in this class have reminded me of what it means to be a Christian and how to be a Christian. The two topics I will discuss in the Reflection paper are Temptation and Sins of Commission. Temptation often leads to sin which can include sins of commission. Part One -Temptation a. Theological Definition Temptation is something experienced by a person with thoughts or desires which are contrary to how God desires man to act. When a person acts on these thoughts sin is committed. A person can be tempted by thoughts of money, lust and greed....   [tags: christian, temptation, sin]

Powerful Essays
552 words (1.6 pages)

The Eagle and the Elephant: a Simple Comparison Essay

- Human history has always been full of ups and downs. Successes and failures, treaties and war. And just as human history, a human life can get lost in they're own challenges and experiences. Often oblivious to the plight of others, most just live out their lives. Taking what they have for granted, they live inside their glass shell, unable to imagine a world without. Take the United States of America for instance. With a GDP (Gross Domestic Product) of $47,400, the United States of America is the 10th wealthiest nation in regards to GDP ....   [tags: Government ]

Powerful Essays
1194 words (3.4 pages)

Comparing Macbeth and A Simple Plan Essay

- Why is that money and power can changes an individual’s personality. Well, when some humans see something desirable and valuable that doesn’t belong to them, they will go to a great extent to have it. Whether, that is stealing, lying or even killing loved ones. This is simply described as greed. Greed and ambition is a common theme in both Shakespeare’s tragic play, Macbeth and the movie “A Simple Plan”. They both share the concept of wanting something and committing crime after crime to achieve it....   [tags: compare contrast essay]

Powerful Essays
871 words (2.5 pages)

Essay about Macbeth As A Tragic Hero

- Macbeth is one of Shakespeare’s most well known plays. Shakespeare enjoyed writing a variety of play types, like comedies and tragedies. Shakespeare liked how tragedies could make the audience feel emotions towards the character while learning a lesson about life. Tragedies contain a tragic hero, who experiences a downfall, and a tragic flaw in the hero, which causes the downfall to occur. The main character in the play Macbeth, is a man named Macbeth, who nobly represents the king of Scotland until he meets three witches....   [tags: Macbeth, Tragic hero, Macbeth]

Powerful Essays
1055 words (3 pages)

Essay on A Comparison of Macbeth and Hamlet

- A Comparison of Macbeth and Hamlet MACBETH stands in contrast throughout with Hamlet; in the manner of opening more especially. In the latter, there is a gradual ascent from the simplest forms of conversation to the language of impassioned intellect,—yet the intellect still remaining the seat of passion: in the former, the invocation is at once made to the imagination and the emotions connected therewith....   [tags: Papers]

Powerful Essays
2680 words (7.7 pages)

Essay Temptation

- Temptation Tonight, let us think through the M.O. of Temptation. I believe we are made in the image of the triune God. We have a soul, a body and a spirit: a triune nature. When we are tempted, it will either be in the area of the soul, the body or the spirit. It is important that we understand this concept if we want to know how to overcome temptation. The world will primarily tempt us in the area of our soul. The word for soul is psyche, which we use to describe an individual's mind, will, and emotions....   [tags: Tempting Religion Soul Religious Essays]

Powerful Essays
1806 words (5.2 pages)