Closely Watched Trains by Jiri Menzel and My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done?, directed by Werner Herzog

906 Words2 Pages

Closely Watched Trains is a Czech New wave film set in Czechoslovakia during the Nazi occupation in World War II. It revolves around the life and coming of age of Milos, a train officer. The major theme of the movie is the way it satirizes Soviet Russia during this historical time period, which is unconventional for a movie set in World War II. Other themes emerge as well, such as sexuality (or the repression of sexuality), gender roles and masculinity. There was also a scene that stuck out to me at the beginning of the movie, where Milos’ mother seems to crown him with his conductors’ hat, maybe signifying the important role that Milos being a train officer plays at the end of the film. I also thought it was interesting that the movie did not demonize the Germans, as is usually the case with films set in World War II. The Germans are portrayed as benevolent in two scenes; the first is the portrayal of the German soldiers with the nurses, which demonstrates the loneliness of war. The second scene is when the Germans capture Milos, only to let him go after seeing his attempt at suicide. As mentioned in class, the film is a masterpiece due to its subversive use of metaphor. The young Milos is a symbolic representation of the whole Czech state. He is, to put it lightly, “socially retarded.” He’s sexually repressed, juvenile, awkward, and shows a disinterest towards work. The metaphorical message is that Soviet Russia and the hand of communism never let anyone grow to full maturity, and that the Czech state was suffering from this adolescence. This movie is a demonstration of the ways in which sexuality can be transformed into a political message. Entry 4: September 23d, 2011: My Son, My Son, What Have Ye Done? Directed... ... middle of paper ... ...e overall theme of the movie is one of liberation. The reason why I think this is because at the end of the film as he’s getting into the cop car, Brad mentions how he sees ostriches running in a field. Then there’s cinematic shot of a pack of ostriches running freely. I believe that Brad may have felt suffocated by his mother, which eventually led him to kill her. However, he was also mad, and it is possible he could not distinguish reality from Greek tragedy, and simply wanted to play the part he was assigned before getting kicked out of the play for not reciting his lines correctly. I also thought it was interesting to see two great directors come together to make a movie, and incorporated both of their signature styles in a few scenes. Even though Herzog directed the film, the incorporation of flamingos and a midget reminds you that Lynch also had a hand in it.

Open Document