Chinese Parenting Over Western Parenting Essays

Chinese Parenting Over Western Parenting Essays

Length: 791 words (2.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Amy Chua believes that Chinese mothers are more superior than any other mothers because they raise such stereotypical successful kids. In her document “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” I believe that she does a great job of explaining why she believes they are more superior. Amy Chua uses examples, facts, and emotional connections to provide information to the reader about why Chinese mothers are superior. Rhetorical appeals can be defined as three elements that are used in the art of persuasion. They are logos, ethos, and pathos. In the article “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” Amy Chua I believe that the rhetorical appeals that Amy Chua uses are effective in informing the reader about Chinese parenting over Western Parenting.
The first rhetorical device that Amy Chua uses that is effective is logos. “Logos is a statement, sentence or argument used to convince or persuade the targeted audience by employing reason or logic.” Amy Chua uses statistics and facts in her argument from the beginning of the article. Chua starts out the article with statistics on the percentages of Chinese and of Western mothers who believe that being strict about academic success is not good for their children. In the study it is said that zero percent of Chinese mothers believe that stressing success is not good for their children. Amy Chua also says that Chinese mothers do not allow their children to participate in extracurricular activities. Using statistics such as these help Amy Chua persuade even more that Chinese mothers are superior. The reason authors use logical appeals because it is hard for a reader to argue with facts. The only downside of her logical appeal is that she does not cite her sources for her facts. The problem with this is th...


... middle of paper ...


... the same because they care for their children. To me this was confusing because in the article she said that western parents are setting their children up for failure because of the way they treat them. Then she says Chinese and Western parents are the same because the care. The emotional appeal in this article gets a little confusing at times when Amy Chua goes back and forth on the Western parenting style, however I still believe she did a good job of getting her point across of why Chinese mothers were more superior.
Chua uses the three rhetorical devices trying to persuade to the reader that Chinese mothers are more superior. I believe that she did a very good job in explaining the difference in the parenting styles of Chinese and Western parents, however as far as persuading the reader that Chinese mothers are better I think she could have done a better job.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Chinese Parenting Over Western Parenting Essays

- Amy Chua believes that Chinese mothers are more superior than any other mothers because they raise such stereotypical successful kids. In her document “Why Chinese Mothers Are Superior” I believe that she does a great job of explaining why she believes they are more superior. Amy Chua uses examples, facts, and emotional connections to provide information to the reader about why Chinese mothers are superior. Rhetorical appeals can be defined as three elements that are used in the art of persuasion....   [tags: Rhetoric, United States, Logic, Appeal to emotion]

Better Essays
791 words (2.3 pages)

Two Different Mindsets of Parenting: The Chinese and the Western Approach

- ... These things clearly are not being brought into the Chinese parenting style which will have a negative effect on their kids when grown and have to work in fields that involves in participating in events and with people. Furthermore, the story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan basically speaks about a Chinese mother that makes her daughter do all different types of exercise of studies and instrumental lessons. Her mother’s way of parenting is clearly Chinese parenting style. Nothing was good enough for her; she always wanted better for her daughter....   [tags: memorization vs kinesthetic learning style]

Better Essays
1060 words (3 pages)

Chinese Parents Are More Successful Than Children Raised By Western Parents

- There is no manual for being the perfect parent, so parents have to go through a series of successes and fails in order to find what is best for their family. Nevertheless every parent believes that their way of parenting is the best and the way others should raise their children. In her article “Why Chinese Mothers are Superior”, Amy Chua explains why children raised by Chinese mother are more successful than children raised by western parents. She believes that Chinese parents raise more successful children because of strict rules when it comes to education and social interactions....   [tags: Parent, Childhood, Parenting, Child]

Better Essays
964 words (2.8 pages)

Traditions of Child Parenting in China Essays

- Have you ever thought about having kids and raising them in a way where your family, friends, and even your own kids judge you and see you as this monstrous savage of a being. Being raised by the Chinese style of parenting or better known as “Tiger Parenting” I understand what it was like being put through what Amy Chua put her kids through. Therefore, I understand completely what Amy Chua is trying to explain in her book Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother. The advancements and traditions of child parenting have significantly impacted society by their many techniques of parenting....   [tags: chinese mothers, amy chua, tiger parenting]

Better Essays
1487 words (4.2 pages)

Parenting Styles : Parents, Western Culture Mothers And Helicopter Mothers

- Parenting Styles Parenting styles differ from parent to parent. Some may be strict and demanding while others may be more calm and lenient. In this essay, we look at three unique parenting styles: Chinese mothers, Western culture mothers and Helicopter mothers. The mothers described in these three articles are very diverse. They all come with strengths and weaknesses, and they all have a different viewpoint on how they think a child should be raised. While none of the mothers described in the articles have a perfect parenting style, they do have some worthy objectives....   [tags: Parenting, Slow parenting, Forest kindergarten]

Better Essays
866 words (2.5 pages)

The Social Norm For Parenting Essay

- The social norm for parenting is that parents should encourage their children to do their best. Parents should be happy for their children’s success, no matter how big or small the success is. Parents should always offer words of encouragement to their children. These are parents’ guideline that most children grew up with and that parents follow. Amy Chua does not follow these social norms parent guides. Chua is a Chinese mother that orders her children to be the best, her words of encouragement are insults to the Western parents, and there is no celebration of success because her children are expected to succeed in everything....   [tags: Mother, Parent, Childhood, Parenting]

Better Essays
1044 words (3 pages)

Essay on Chinese Parents Vs. Chinese Parenting

- As Amy Chua (2011) points out, there are three differences in the mindsets of Chinese and Westerners when it comes to parenting. The author starts the article with several stories to demonstrate these glaring differences: Chinese parents believe their kids are "the best;" Chinese parents force their children to practice a subject until they master and enjoy it; and Chinese parents call their offsprings "garbage" and "fat" to make them improve. However, according to Chua, the Chinese parenting method, strange to Westerners, has created successful sons and daughters....   [tags: People's Republic of China, The Child, Confidence]

Better Essays
776 words (2.2 pages)

Essay about The Type Of Parenting Technique Is Authoritarian Parenting

- One such type of parenting technique is authoritarian parenting. Authoritarian parents are the parents that are involved in a child’s life from the second the child is born into the family. The parents are in charge of everything. From the small things like which toy a child to get to the ideas of a child must play an instrument, must be at least bilingual and other extracurricular activities. Authoritarian parents are a synonym to Indian parenting styles. Research has shown that almost 85% of parents in India in the early 2000s used authoritarian parenting when raising a child till the age of 15....   [tags: Parenting styles, Childhood, Parenting]

Better Essays
2040 words (5.8 pages)

Essay on A Study On Chinese Mother

- At the beginning of the article, author Chua gives the reader a list of things that she forbidden her two daughters, Sophia and Louisa, to ever do. The list contains items such as: no sleepover, no play date, no school play, no TV nor computer, no grade less than A, no other extracurricular activities without parent 's approval, no other instruments besides piano and violin. Author Chua claims that this is the list “Chinese mother” would apply to create genius kids such as “math whizzes and music prodigies” (1)....   [tags: Parent, Mother, Parenting styles, Parenting]

Better Essays
1081 words (3.1 pages)

Extreme Parenting : A Difficult Job Essay

- Extreme Parenting In the contemporary world, parenting is a difficult job. Different parenting styles will result in different outcomes. Amy Chua, an author who published a controversial article about parenting her children in an “authoritarian” way. Authoritarian parenting is a way to restrict your children away from participating in any activities besides academic-related. She believes academics are more important than everything else so she does not let her children choose their own extracurricular activities and get any grade less than A....   [tags: Parenting styles, Parenting, Parent, Childhood]

Better Essays
1526 words (4.4 pages)