Case Analysis - Terry Timber Inc

Case Analysis - Terry Timber Inc

Length: 1448 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Excellent

Open Document

Essay Preview

More ↓
To : Mr. Taylor, President, Terry Timber Inc.
From : External Auditor, Terry Timber Inc.
Subject : Advice on accounting policies of stated matters of Terry Timber Inc. (TT)
Dear Mr. Taylor
Enclosed is the report you requested regarding the adequate accounting policies for the stated matters for financial statements of TT. My objective, as an external auditor for TT, is to come up with reasonable and justifiable treatments for the accounting matters that result in meeting the goals of the company and objectives of all users.
The Financial Statements (FS) of TT have primarily four users with different objectives, Shareholders – to evaluate the performance and growth of the company, to increase return on their investment, and to ensure accurate reporting. Bank - to determine, if company complies with covenants, to ensure repayment of their loan and accurate reporting, Union - to evaluate ongoing and future gains of the company and to see maximum profits, and Mr. Taylor, president of TT (preparer of FS) - to maximize profits, to evaluate growth of the company, to meet bank covenants, to minimize taxes and to ensure accurate financial reporting. There are other users as well like CRA/Auditors - to ensure accurate reporting by TT, Court (if requested during trails) – to see if FS reports are fairly stated or not.
TT is a publicly traded company listed on Toronto Stock Exchange therefore it is constraint by GAAP and has to meet the requirements of the securities laws of Ontario and the rules of the stock exchange. TT is also constraint by covenants set by its Bank, and has to be extra careful about the Current Ratio.
Also, union is expecting a significant gain-sharing plan therefore incomes reported in this year financial report will play crucial role in the negotiations. Further this time; auditors will be extra careful during audits because of the lawsuit filed by the shareholders, therefore, scrutiny will be high. Following are the issues that need to be addressed, while complying with the Financial reporting constraints.
Court Cases : TT has two potential court cases against it, first, by Shareholders and second by Mr. MacDonald, ex-president of TT. According to GAAP, if likelihood of the event happening is known, damage is material and measurable then accrue the cost and disclose in financial notes but if any one of the three components are not known than disclose it in Financial Notes. In Mac Donald’s Case - even though damage is known and is very much material, likelihood of happening is not known.

How to Cite this Page

MLA Citation:
"Case Analysis - Terry Timber Inc." 14 Aug 2018

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Analysis of Waiting to Exhale by Terry McMillan

- Analysis of Waiting to Exhale by Terry McMillan The first chapter of the book begins with Savanna Getting ready for a New Years eve party. Her younger sister encouraged her to meet a guy named Lionel, who is the friend of Sheila’s husband. After Thanksgiving they talked on occasions and now he invited to meet her at this party. While she is getting ready she explains that she is moving to Phoenix and one of the reasons is because “the men are dead in Denver”. In the past nine years she has spent it living with three different guys and she just can’t find the right one....   [tags: Waiting to Exhale Terry McMillan Essays]

Research Papers
6791 words (19.4 pages)

Non-Timber Forest Products Essay

- Non-timber Forest Products does not increase the rate of deforestation because they are harvested without damaging the trees and timbers. Plus, most of the NTFPs are based on forest environment. That means without forests, it is not really possible to acquire NTFPs. Besides traditional timber forest products, NTFP is another major resources from forests. Technically, NTFPs are defined as “all biological materials, other than timber, which are extracted from forests for human use.” These include rattan and other materials for craft making, forest fruits, resins, gums, medicinal plants and honey....   [tags: deforestation, environment, timber, trees]

Research Papers
679 words (1.9 pages)

Analysis of Defects in Timber Frame Buildings Essays

- Introduction In this document I will be reviewing secondary data that goes over some of the defects that have been observed in timber frame constructed buildings. I will be using data that has been put together both by experts in this field that have carried out their own investigations. I will be comparing the findings of the experts that have a duty of care to only speak facts and findings, to those views of the organisations that try their upmost to keep us safe. My aim is to draw to a conclusion over whether: The opinions of the CFOA and other concerned parties are substantiated Timber frame construction is something that could be our new “traditional construction method” Timber frame c...   [tags: Secondary Data, Modern vs Historic]

Research Papers
2511 words (7.2 pages)

Essay on Terry Tempest Williams' Refuge

- Terry Tempest Williams' Refuge Everything known to man is held in some sort of balance. It is a delicate balance, one which swings rhythmically to the ebb and flow of this world. Many have studied it but it has proven too complex, too broad to understand everything that is at work. That is why it must be preserved. One such movement has recently begun which looks exclusively to preserve this balance, ecofeminism. Terry Tempest Williams is just that, an ecofeminist. In her memoir Refuge¸ Williams attempts to examine the ecological and social worlds that balance on this pendulum....   [tags: Terry Williams Refuge Memoir Essays]

Free Essays
1266 words (3.6 pages)

Analysis of Brazil, Directed by Terry Gilliam Essay

- Analysis of Brazil, Directed by Terry Gilliam As a child develops into an adult there are critical developmental steps that are necessary for a complete and successful transition. The physical transition is the most obvious change, but underneath the thick skin and amongst the complex systems, exists another layer of transitions. Ideas, rationales, ideologies and beliefs all dwell within this layer of each being. It could be said that a nation can also fit this transitional framework. A nation grows in both size (wealth, population, power), and in ideological maturity (emancipation of slaves, civil rights, women’s rights…etc)....   [tags: Film Movie Movies Brazil Gilliam Essays]

Research Papers
1640 words (4.7 pages)

Arctic Timber Essay

- 1. Statement of the Problem In 1996, Arctic Timber Engineered Woods Division, a highly mature business unit, faced a market downturn and began losing millions of dollars each month. Before becoming the President of the Engineered Woods Division, Bjorn Gustavsson had already determined that the company could not sustain its commodity business and was not aligned with the new direction devised by Peter Hammarskjöld, the CEO of Arctic Timber. According to Gustavsson, in order to prosper in a more challenging market environment, developing a specialty business was the only viable approach....   [tags: Business Analysis Management]

Free Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on Analysis of The Terry and Gaby Show

- Analysis of The Terry and Gaby Show Chris Evans launched “The Terry and Gaby Show” on Five in 2003, in an attempt to compete with ITV’s “This Morning”. In less than a year it had been axed. Looking in detail at an episode from each show, identify the codes and conventions of the daytime TV genre, and suggest why “The Terry and Gaby Show” failed to dent the popularity of “This Morning”. After looking at each of the episodes I found that the presenters in each one were quite the same....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
865 words (2.5 pages)

Hbs Tivo Case Analyais Essay

- TiVo's problem rests in its inability to convince consumers to change their television consumption habits. Improper targeting and positioning have led to an ineffective product, price-point and promotion strategy that has stranded TiVo in the chasm between the early market and the early majority. TiVo is a truly discontinuous innovation, a product that requires consumers to dramatically change their past behavior with the promise of gaining equally dramatic new benefits. TiVo's main challenge is convincing the consumer to buy an expensive product in a new product category....   [tags: Business Case Study]

Free Essays
2172 words (6.2 pages)

Mcdonalds Case Analysis Essay

- CASE ANALYSIS McDonald’s, Inc. COMPANY NAME: McDonald’s, Inc. INDUSTRY: Food Service COMPANY WEBSITE: COMPANY BACKGROUND: As a company, McDonald’s was first introduced in Des Plaines, Illinois in 1955. This was the very first McDonald’s restaurant, which all started in San Bernardino, California in 1954 when Ray Kroc approached the McDonald brothers with a business proposition to start a new company. In 1965 McDonald’s went public and was later, in 1985 added to the Dow Jones Industrial Average....   [tags: Case Study SWOT Analysis McDonalds]

Free Essays
1425 words (4.1 pages)

McDonald's Case Analysis Essay

- McDonald's Case Analysis I.     Objectives McDonald's mission was to provide customers with quality food at a low price with a focus on the speed, service and cleanliness they received while patroning one of their restaurants. The case focuses on a specific segment of the McDonalds restaurant chain that was opened in 1996, McDonald?s India. This segment of the restaurant giant had a more specific mission/philosophy to fulfill and had developed a special menu for these Indian customers to take into account their culture and religion....   [tags: Mcdonalds business Case Analysis Essays]

Research Papers
1183 words (3.4 pages)

In Shareholders Case – neither the likelihood of happening is known nor the damage amount. Therefore, I would recommend just to disclose these Cases in financial notes and not to accrue the claimed amount.
Land and Timber Valuation : Conservatism is a fundamental GAAP concept that serves to ensure that assets, revenues and net income should not be overstated. Therefore, under GAAP, capital assets (in this case, Land) is always reported at the historical cost and GAAP accounting is not intended to capture the changes in the market values. Similarly, inventory (in this case, Timber) is valued at the lower of its historical cost and market value. Although the historical costs of land and timber are negatively affecting the current ratio, values cannot be appreciated to the present market values.
Two Events (Government Regulations and Strike) : According to GAAP, any losses or gains due to event, which is not expected to occur frequently, not a typical of the entity’s business and not primarily the result of the management decision can be categorized as Extraordinary item (EOI), but the one which do not meet definition of EOI but not expected to occur frequently or not considered part of the normal business activity is categorised as Unusual item. These events are classified separately (according to Sec-1520 of CICA handbook) in the income statement. Therefore, these losses can be excluded from the cost of sales, preventing TT from distorting the gross profit margin for 2006-07.
Revenue Recognition : There are number of alternatives to account the revenue generated from the sale of furniture to Aussy company. At the signing of Contract (does not meet GAAP, too aggressive, although amount of revenue and cost can be measured but performance not occurred and full payment is not collected, estimate for bad debt required), at time of shipment (does not meet GAAP, although amount of revenue and cost can be measured but rights and risks of ownership not transferred to the customer and full payment is not collected, estimate for bad debt required), at receipt of shipment (does not meet GAAP, although amount of revenue and cost can be measured and ownership is transferred but full payment is not collected, estimate for bad debt required and it is difficult to know accurate time of receipt of shipment), or after 30 days of receipt of consignment (meets GAAP, amount of revenue and cost is known, ownership transferred and payment is received and if not then estimation of bad debt will be more reliable but it is too conservative).
As the contract is non cancellable, I would recommend the policy of gradual recognition (% completion) i.e. recognize total revenue minus the additional revenue charged because of a special coating, at the time of shipment of furniture and balance revenue from the additional amount charged because of a special coating, at the time of shipment of the premium coating. However, estimate for bad debt and ownership transfer cost will be required and it can be done through the past experience of the company. This will help to recognize cash received upfront, thus increasing its current ratio. Although, the current ratio using this methodology will be less as compare to the total revenue recognition at the time of shipment, it addresses the GAAP rules more appropriately than the former. Also, missing delivery deadline can cause severe penalty to TT, which seems to be very much material. Therefore, I would recommend including the Note in the FS about the consignment agreement and appraising the Aussy Company about the progress of the manufacturing of the premium coating and if possible, negotiate the delivery clause of the contract.
Consignment Inventory : As per the accounting principles, consignment inventory should be included in the inventory account of the owning entity and not in the inventory account of the selling entity, even though owning entity does not have the physical custody of the inventory. Further, revenue on the sale of the consignment inventory can only be recognised when the inventory is sold by the selling entity to a customer. Therefore, TT has to include this as the component of inventory ($800,000) not of sales ($1,200,000), which will affect the current ratio negatively.
Inventory Valuation Method – The furniture division of TT is using LIFO method for valuation of inventory for lumber that was purchased in bulk in late 2007, when there was depression in the prices of lumber predicting that its price will rise in near future. GAAP identifies four inventory valuation methods - LIFO, FIFO, average cost and specific identification. In predicting the future cash flow and evaluating the company performance, FIFO based inventory value is more useful than alternatives because it gives a more current indication. Also, when inventory prices are rising, FIFO gives the lowest cost of sale and the highest inventory value, whereas LIFO gives the highest cost of sales and the lowest inventory value. Average cost gives between these two. Therefore, as indicated that price of lumber is expected to rise, I would recommend to use FIFO as the inventory valuation method because with FIFO, the reported amount of ending inventory is always higher as compare to other alternatives resulting in higher current ratio. Moreover, according to Income Tax Act, LIFO cannot be used in Canada.
Allowance of Account Receivable : Normally, management can change the percentages for allowances based on the historical information about the proportions of the receivables that are not corrected in recent past. But in order to convert old receivables into current receivables by revising the invoice date is not legal. Therefore, I would recommend using the same percentages, which were consistent over last few years, for un-collectable accounts receivable and not revising the date on the invoice, even though this will hurt the current ratio and decrease the income.
Based on the above-mentioned context, I have made recommendations that are supportable in term of GAAP, fairness and accrual accounting. Any change in the context and assumption, would seek reconsideration of the analysis conducted on the financial reporting of TT. I hope this will provide you sufficient information about the accurate accounting treatments of the stated matters. If necessary, I would be glad to provide any further information you might need.
Yours Sincerely,
External Auditor
Return to