Beating Goliath: An Analytical Review Essay

Beating Goliath: An Analytical Review Essay

Length: 2151 words (6.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Term Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Jeffrey Record's Beating Goliath: Why Insurgencies Win uses the age old anecdote of the struggle between David and Goliath to explain why the strong sometimes lose to the weak – that is, why Davids are sometimes able to triumph over Goliaths despite myriad obvious disadvantages. Jeffrey Record specifically focuses on "states fighting non-state actors" (Record ix), or in other words, states confronted with domestic or international insurgencies. He then goes on to explore the role that external assistance plays in war outcome determination. By examining instances in which the United States has lost against materially weaker opponents, Record is able to partially explain the causal factors of these types of defeats by using a three component model that encompasses will, strategy, and type of government. Beating Goliath: Why Insurgencies Win scrutinizes the role of external assistance on the outcomes of such conflicts, and Record ultimately concludes that intentional (and to a significantly lesser extent, unintentional) external assistance to insurgencies or guerrillas conducting nonconventional warfare has the ability to facilitate a crucial change in roles: the initially weaker actor can and often does becomes the stronger actor with the aid of said external assistance. Record thus valorously postulates, "the presence or absence of external assistance may be the single most important determinant of insurgent war outcomes" (Record 23).
Jeffrey Record states that "all major failed U.S. uses of force since 1945...have been against materially weaker enemies" (Record vii), but he strangely ignores one of the most recent and highly publicized defeats of failed U.S. counterinsurgency action: the U.S. led intervention in Somalia aga...

... middle of paper ...

...he contras in El Salvador as another case, as it is a good example where indiscriminate use of force severely hindered successful operations from a public standpoint, another side argument that he again brought up in the conclusion as one of his main points. Perhaps Record's book is suffering an identity crisis: he could benefit from deciding whether he wants to explain a possible independent variable, external assistance, or whether he wants to draw conclusions from previous works and use this information to exact policy prescriptions. What he ends up with, unfortunately, is a confused mix of the two.

Works Cited

Cassidy, Robert M. Counterinsurgency and the Global War on Terror: Military Culture and Irregular War. Stanford: Stanford UP, 2008. Print

Record, Jeffrey. Beating Goliath: Why Insurgencies Win. Washington, D.C.: Potomac Books, Inc., 2009. Print.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

David and Goliath: creativity Essay

- 1. Summary of Article The journal article by David and Goliath inspect on the issue on merger and acquisitions of an organisation and concerned with communication between employees and top management. The article also examine on various collections of data that changes show beforehand results in reduced adverse effect of the merger. Communication is the important way to help management to reduce employee’s anxiety and doubt that follows by the cause of the merger. Foreseeable change should be conveying to employees rapidly to prevent negative feelings such as stress, job dissatisfaction and low commitment to work....   [tags: business, communication]

Term Papers
906 words (2.6 pages)

The Meaning of the Phrase, Beating the Market Essay

- The Meaning of the Phrase, Beating the Market "Beating the market" is a difficult phrase to analyze. It can be used to refer to two different situations: 1. An investor, portfolio manager, fund, or other investment specialist produces a better return than the market average. The market average can be calculated in many ways (some of which are shady and used to make it look like someone has exceeded market returns), but usually a benchmark like the S&P 500 or the Dow Jones Industrial Average index is a good representation of the market average....   [tags: Beating the Market Stock Markets Essays]

Term Papers
5157 words (14.7 pages)

The Impact of Attending Seminars to the Development of the Analytical Skill of Financial Management Students

- The study tackles about “The Impact of Attending Seminars to the Development of the Analytical Skill of the Financial Management Students”. The discussion started by introducing what is seminars and its main purpose. Seminars help a lot to spread and inform the people about new informations and ideas. It provides also opportunities to the attendees to meet and know formal persons in different industries. The importance of seminars could also enhance skills of the attendees specifically the analytical skill of a person....   [tags: finance, analytical skill, seminars]

Free Essays
1981 words (5.7 pages)

Phaedra Live Performance Analytical Critique Essay

- Phaedra Live Performance Analytical Critique Last Thursday at the State Playhouse at California State University Los Angeles, Dr. James A. Hatfield directed the play Phaedra written by Jean Racine, first performed in 1677. The leading characters are Theseus, Phaedra, Hippolytus, Aricia, Oenone, Theramenes, Ismene, and Panope. The play depicts the lust that Phaedra has toward her stepson Hippolytus and the tragedy that her desire for him causes, which is the death of Hippolytus, Oenone, and even her own life....   [tags: play, character and story analysis, review]

Term Papers
843 words (2.4 pages)

Sex and the City Review Essay

- Unlike many, many, many of you out there that completely HATED this movie, I on the other hand was appeased. Right now, I know you all (that have seen the movie) probably think I'm nuts, but before you judge me, read my review and explanations. For those who have not yet seen the movie and plan on it: DO NOT READ THIS. Now, I think a huge reason why I didn't find this movie so horrible is because I went in with hugely low expectations based on the trailer, so the few funny and likable parts of the film to me were a huge success....   [tags: Film Review ]

Term Papers
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Essay on David And Goliath

- David and Goliath The story of David and Goliath can be thought of as a timeless tale of 1) good versus evil and 2) the fact that the win does not always go to the strongest or biggest, it goes to the most determined or strong willed. David, the good spirited fighter who wanted to save the Israelites from Goliath, for example, was eager, confident, and prepared to win, as described in 1 Samuel 17:48 - "David ran quickly toward the battle line to meet the Philistine". David was a hero to the Israelites because he was able to kill Goliath, who had "come up to defy Israel" (1 Samuel 17:25)....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
432 words (1.2 pages)

Analytical Critique of The Godfather Essay

- Analytical Critique of The Godfather      I believe the reason that, 'The Godfather', is such a great film is because it lets audiences decide whether they like the characters or not. Too many movies made about organized crime begin with some seemingly random act of violence. 'The Godfather', however, lets it be known from the start to judge the characters in the film based on what type of person they are instead of the criminal activities they may engage in.      The film begins with a wedding, and this setting sets the stage for the basic theme of the movie, which is family....   [tags: Movie Film Review Godfather Essays]

Term Papers
928 words (2.7 pages)

Essay on Beetlejuice Analytical Review

- In the movie Beetlejuice, the theme is that the afterlife is not really the end for us all; we live on a multiple level world between life and death, and need to respect the dead. The theme is idealistic and not applicable in real life to all people. Throughout the movie, Burton reveals his take on the living and life after death and the delicate interaction between the two. The character Otho, played by Glenn Shadix is key to Burton’s interpretation and scrutiny of the afterlife. Throughout the film Otho makes comments about the dead and even goes as far to steal The Handbook for the Recently Deceased....   [tags: Movie Analysis]

Term Papers
1481 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Beating the Binge

- Beating the Binge Beirut, Pong, Quarters, Flip Cup, the Name Game, and 7-11 doubles are just a few of the names given to what is quickly becoming the new great American past-time for young people, drinking to excess. College-age students across the country have taken to channeling their energies into the creation of drinking games like these, without perhaps looking at the consequences of such creatively destructive behavior. In the United States, forty-four percent of persons ages eighteen to twenty-one are enrolled in colleges or universities (1)....   [tags: Biology Essays Research Papers]

Term Papers
974 words (2.8 pages)

Analytical Essay

- The construction last year of a shopping mall in downtown Oak City was a mistake. Since the mall has opened, a number of local businesses have closed, and the downtown area suffers from an acute parking shortage. Arrests for crime and vagrancy have increased in nearby Oak City Park. Elm City should pay attention to the example of the Oak City Mall and deny the application to build a shopping mall in Elm City. Analyzing this argument brings up a lot of questions to whether this is a relevant argument or not....   [tags: Analytical Essays]

Free Essays
664 words (1.9 pages)