The Argument Of Ancient Greek Historians Essays

The Argument Of Ancient Greek Historians Essays

Length: 1132 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

We do not know who ruled Crete. This is due to the fact that a lot of the archaeological evidence on Crete has been destroyed. While some historians believe that Crete was ruled by a king, others believe that it was ruled by a group of priestesses.
The Argument of Ancient greek Historians
The ancient historians all suggests that there was a monarchy on Crete. Specifically, they argue that there was a king, named Minos, who ruled Crete.

However, archaeologists have not yet uncovered any evidence which proves that Minos existed. Rather, modern historians tend to believe that the accounts of Ovid, Homer, Thucydides and Aristotle are wrong. The following table summaries the problems associated with the accounts of these four historians:

The Argument of Arthur Evans
Arthur Evans was a British subject and was familiar with the male dominated political structures in ancient Egypt. Additionally, he was inspired by the myth of Minos before excavating Crete. As such, Evans automatically assumed that there was a male king on Crete name Minos. Later in life, however, Evans expanded his argument and stated that Minos could be a title, like pharaoh, rather than a name.
To help prove his argument, Evans produced two pieces of archaeological evidence. However, there are problems associated with these sources.


Other Evidence to suggest a male ruled Greece
As shown, there are a number of issues associated with the arguments of Arthur Evans and the Greek historians. However, archaeologists have uncovered other sources which suggest that a King ruled Crete. For instance:
The Master’s Impression Seal depicts a man standing over a shrine or palace. He appears to be holding a staff. Some archaeologists believe that this may be the king.
Historian...


... middle of paper ...


...oints.
Firstly, we do not know much about the women who were not priestesses. This is due to the fact that they are not depicted in the pictorial records. However, we have found votive offerings in peak sanctuaries that depict vulva and children. This suggests that they were expected to bear children and become mothers. Additionally, some historians believe that the presence of milk jugs that have female forms supports this idea. This is due to the fact that they argue that they symbolise a mother breast feeding.
Finally, we know from Linear B tablets that some Minoans worked in the textile industry. For instance, we have found textile workshops at Knossos. This is made evident by the presence of loom weights and spindle-whorls. Some archaeologists assume that the textile industry was dominated by females. However, we don’t have any really evidence that proves this.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Women Of Ancient Greek History Essay

- “But how can women achieve anything so grand or noble?” Ancient Greek history was often written by the men that had claimed victory in battle. The women, slaves, and foreigners of Ancient Greece often get forgotten in all the blood, glory, and fame. The legacy of the women, slaves, and foreigners can be seen through the eyes of Greek society by looking closely at some of the materials from Ancient Greece. The role of women in Ancient Greece is different than what we think of today in America. Women in Ancient Greece were thought of as second class citizens....   [tags: Ancient Greece, Sparta, Peloponnesian War]

Strong Essays
1428 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Animals in Ancient Egypt

- In ancient Egypt there was no unified belief system, instead a wide variety of different belief systems and practices which varied widely depending on location, time period and social class. Throughout the chaos of different religions in ancient Egypt one factor remained the same, animals. Animals of all kinds were significant to the Ancient Egyptians. The Egyptians understanding of specific animal’s characteristics was broad and extensive, but often was limited to animals that had powers that humans lacked....   [tags: Ancient Egypt, Religion, Beliefs]

Strong Essays
940 words (2.7 pages)

Light Infantry of Ancient Greece Essay

- Light Infantry of Ancient Greece For a long time peace was understood in negative fashion, simply as the absence of war. -Yvon Garlan Kendrick Pritchett in the introduction to the book "The Greek State at War" points out that in order to write history of Greek Warfare one "…would require a knowledge of many aspects of Greek life. The would-be investigator would have to be familiar with terrain in the case of any given battle, have an acquaintance with the archaeological artifacts of various types, close familiarity with the written sources, and most important, an understanding of the general economic picture....   [tags: Ancient Greece Essays]

Strong Essays
1291 words (3.7 pages)

The Notion of War in the Eyes of Thucydides, Homer and Aristophanes Essay

- Greek classical literature is considered to be the canon of literary writing that pertains to the ancient history of Greece. Greek literature displays the classic lifestyle, culture and beliefs of the Greek race during the early portions of mainstream ancient and classical European history. Prominent Greek writers such as Thucydides, Homer, and Aristophanes produced pieces that are regarded, up to this day, as af conveyer of Greek life in the context of classical Europe. Looking deeper into their respective works, Thucydides’ History of the Peloponnesian War, Homer’s Iliad and Aristophanes’ Lysistrata all show a common theme in ancient Greek life –life in the context of war....   [tags: Greek Literature ]

Strong Essays
1905 words (5.4 pages)

Essay on The Heroes of the Trojan War: Hector & Achilles

- In the Greek epic, The Iliad, Homer describes the siege and capture of the ancient city of Troy by Achilles and the Achaean warriors. Achilles, being a fearless fighter, defeated many throughout his battles against the Trojan army, including the brave-hearted Hector during the invasion of Troy. Though Achilles has been given the title of the hero of the Trojan War, many historians believe that Hector was a greater hero than Achilles. When comparing the characteristics of an epic hero such as being a national hero and having supernatural abilities, Hector clearly surpasses Achilles....   [tags: Greek Literature]

Strong Essays
532 words (1.5 pages)

Ancient Greek Historians: Herodotus and Thucydides Essay

- Thesis statement: While the ancient Greek historians made great strides in perfecting the writing of history, the Roman historians (and the Greek historian writing Roman history) continued perfecting the art of writing good history. The two Greeks Herodotus and Thucydides started the practice of reporting truth and personal knowledge of historical events above prose and poetry (vis-à-vis Homer), as well as removing much of the theological-centric content. The Roman historians that came after improved on this practice, particularly Tacitus, who used the better developed record-keeping of the times to write more concise, accurate histories with personal knowledge of the movers and shakers of t...   [tags: greece, writing roman history, polybius]

Strong Essays
928 words (2.7 pages)

Aristotelian Rhetoric: Progression of Sophists' Nascent Teachings Essay

- Scholars and historians of rhetoric consider the Greek philosopher, Aristotle, one of the great contributors to our present understanding of this art which, since its early origins and until present, has been a controversial field of study because of its association with persuasion and influence. However, readings of the many ancient and contemporary texts and analyses of the origins and the developments of this ancient art marginalized the role of the Sophists, who were the first to introduce rhetoric to Greece, and usually associated them with the bad reputation rhetoric has acquired over the years....   [tags: History, Greek Philosophers]

Strong Essays
2554 words (7.3 pages)

Ancient Greece : Ancient Greek Religion Essay

- Ancient Greek Religion There are many topics to be explored in Ancient Greek mythology. This unique polytheistic religion was based upon myth about anthropomorphic gods and goddesses. It impacted every facet of Grecian life from law and ritual to culture and art. The individual as well as society both influenced the characteristics of the religion and were influenced by the religion itself. The Cambridge Illustrated History of Ancient Greece explains a variety of ways in which the Greeks were influenced by their religion....   [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Ancient Greece, Dionysus]

Strong Essays
1948 words (5.6 pages)

Ancient Greek Mythology And The Religious Rituals Essay

- My topic for this historical argumentative essay is Ancient Greek mythology and the religious rituals the Ancient Greek’s participated in and why. During their 2000-year survival in history, many religious rituals were performed, and many deities worshiped. Ancient Greek’s believed that by conducting these rituals, they would improve their relationships with the gods (Schultz 1), making their lives better; when they didn’t praise them as they should, the punishment was severe. I personally do not believe in Greek gods or the theory that they existed....   [tags: Greek mythology, Zeus, Dionysus, Ancient Greece]

Strong Essays
1660 words (4.7 pages)

Ancient Greek Influences Essay

- Historians have long considered Ancient Greece to be one of the most influential societies on modern day life. Ancient Greece has inspired the modern world in five main areas: theatre, government, philosophy, art, and architecture. Theatre flourished in Greece, particularly in Athens, between c. 550 BC and c. 220 BC. During its beginnings theatrical performances were part of Dionysia, a festival held in honour of the god Dionysus. The plot of the plays was always inspired by Greek mythology, a theme that is still common today....   [tags: Ancient Greece]

Strong Essays
888 words (2.5 pages)