The animal rights group PETA has over five million members, making it the largest of it’s kind (About PETA). The goal of this group and others like it, is to give animals rights on the basis that they are equal to humans. They do this because they believe that we are currently manipulating animals and not treating them properly. This is the basis for the animal rights movement.
Animal Rights has been a topic of discussion within the United States for decades, however, with the recent rise of the internet and social media, the size of the groups advocating for animal rights has increased dramatically, the same can be said for the demands of these groups. The current animal rights movement is a flawed philosophy with groups with a level of extremism that can is comparable to radicalized Islam. This paper will first analyze the radicalized views in the current animal rights movement, it will then examine the flaws in the policies of the animal rights movement, and finally this paper will examine the flaws with the philosophy of animal rights.
When compared to the animal welfare movement, it becomes apparent how extreme the views of animal rights are. The animal welfare movement believes that animals should be treated humanely and that humans should be responsible for the care of animals. This approach is mainly opposed to animal cruelty and advocates for ethical standards of living for animals, and does not oppose using animals as a food source. Animal rights advocates for more radical changes like the complete elimination of animals as a food source and the phasing out of pets. This is justified by saying that all animals are equivalent to humans and thus, should be given rights equivalent to those given to hum...
... middle of paper ...
... of animals that reported to be at the shelter. Groups like PETA continue to patronize the meat-industry for using animals for food, while at the same time killing thousands of pets because they do not believe in having pets. This seems to illustrate the fact that only some animals get rights. The hypocrisy shown by the animal rights movement is a flaw that cannot be overlooked when examining this group.
The animal rights movement is a very large and very influential group, however, many aspects of this group are flawed. The flaws present in this group include their extreme views, their policies including the eradication of pets and the elimination of animals as a food source, and their flawed philosophy and finally, their hypocrisy. It is important to understand the flaws in this movement because of how powerful it has become and how much influence it has gained.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- With few exceptions, the history of the modern animal rights movement has been dominated by non-Christian philosophers, writers, and activists. Despite sympathy for prominent Christian figures like St. Francis of Assisi and Pope Francis, animal rights philosophy remains a thoroughly secular enterprise. Asserting that the difference between humans and animals is “a matter of degree and not of kind”, the animal rights movement often rests on a fundamentally anti-Christian anthropology in which the human person is regarded as the product of physical and biological processes, merely an advanced primate.... [tags: Animal rights, Ethics, Morality, Utilitarianism]
1776 words (5.1 pages)
- Analyzing human obligation pertaining to all that is not man made, apart from humans, we discover an assortment of concerns, some of which have been voiced by philosophers such as Tom Regan, Peter Singer and Aldo Leopold. Environmentally ethical ideals hold a broad spectrum of perspectives that, not only attempt to identify a problem, but also focus on how that problem is addressed through determining what is right and wrong. As an advocate of animal rights, Tom Regan presents us with the idea that animals deserve to be treated with equal respect to humans.... [tags: Animal rights, Tom Regan, Peter Singer]
1133 words (3.2 pages)
- As of today PETA is one group that is helping animals in barbaric situation like that of professional research laboratories. In these laboratories, the staff treats animals inhumanly where chemicals are poured onto the animal causing burns and sores. According to answers.com, animal rights are the rights to humane treatment claimed on behalf of animals, especially the right not to be exploited for human purposes. This movement in America traces its roots to the settlers. According to the US History Encyclopedia in 1641, Body of Liberties laws, Massachusetts Bay Colony Puritans came up with the first animal protection laws when they included two provisions prohibiting cruelty to animals.... [tags: Animal Rights]
937 words (2.7 pages)
- A major ethical concern that has been under speculation for many of years is focused around animal ethics, and whether or not certain animal practices are just or inhuman. There are many questions that focus around fundamental issues concerning the moral status of animals. It is critical to understand the difference between a concern for animal welfare and a concern for animal rights. A current issue that is important to understand and analyze is animal experimentation, and although many consider it to be an unethical practice, there are many pros and cons to the controversial topic.... [tags: Animal rights]
737 words (2.1 pages)
- What should govern our eating habits. Should base our consumption choices on foods that do not degrade the environment. Is it necessary to consider human rights, fair trade and food worker injustices. Should we base the foundation of our eating habits on animal welfare. The meaning of eating ethically is a multifaceted subject. There are so many varying issues when it comes to how humans have influenced the treatment and the development of animals throughout the evolution of man, from the carnivorous Neanderthal to the present day omnivorous Homosapien.... [tags: Agriculture, Livestock, Animal rights]
1105 words (3.2 pages)
- Animal Experimentation The use of animals in laboratory experimentation is unethical and strongly against animal rights. The abuse that animals are forced through cannot be justified when an animal is unable to sign it’s life away for testing. Millions of animals are murdered or left debilitated because of something against their own will. The experiments are severely graphic and painful, even for the smallest of tests. “Huntingdon Life Sciences is one of Europe 's biggest testers of animals. They kill approximately 75,000 animals each year, with 87 percent of these animals being rodents” (Murnaghan 1).... [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]
1468 words (4.2 pages)
- Animal rights are defined in the Merriam-Webster Dictionary as “rights (as to fair and humane treatment) regarded as belonging fundamentally to all animals.” But what do they mean by “all animals”. Is there a different protocol for every specie. Is there an invisible line drawn to state what rights animals have. You have to decide. Animals have played a role in society since evolution began. First, animals were used for food, their skins were used for clothing and shelter, and their bones for tools.... [tags: Animal rights, Animal welfare]
1667 words (4.8 pages)
- About 20 million animals are experimented on and killed annually, three-fourths for medical purposes and the rest to test various products. An estimated eight million are used in painful experiments. Reports show that at least 10 percent of these animals do not receive painkillers. The struggle against this cruelty is a struggle as important as any of the moral and social issues that have been fought over in recent years. Although researchers have depended on animal test data to achieve medical advances, there should be other means of research because testing on animals is cruel, inhumane, and often unnecessary.... [tags: Animal testing, Animal rights]
1778 words (5.1 pages)
- Our world today is becoming less and less conscious of the pain and suffering being inflicted on animals. As the outcome, animals are becoming even further tarred in society. Humans have and are continuing to handle animals as if they are some kind of material goods. This is considered as being immoral, as animals have their own lives, and they think, have feelings, can feel pain, require love, happiness, and everything else that humans have. As for human rights, it’s always uncertain. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights in 1948 was adopted by the General Assembly of the United Nations.... [tags: Animal Rights, animals,]
1920 words (5.5 pages)
- Animal’s and The Exemption of Their Rights Do all animals have the same rights as humans. Some animals do but not all. Humans use and exploit animals in every way as if people are entitled. Animal rights activist believe animals have legal and moral rights the same way humans do. On the other hand there are several cooperations and scientist who disagree and want to use these animals for different purposes. The idea of whether animals are entitled to rights and the involvement of those rights is not as debatable as the aspect of animals having their rights and the consequences what are involves.... [tags: Animal rights, Animal testing, Tom Regan]
1329 words (3.8 pages)