Analysis of Adam's Argument To Eve Essay

Analysis of Adam's Argument To Eve Essay

Length: 1152 words (3.3 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Book IV of Milton’s Paradise Lost, Eve recounts her memory of her first living moments to Adam. Eve relates that upon seeing Adam, she turned around and began walking in the opposite direction. Eve then quotes the exact words Adam used to convince her to stay: “Return fair Eve! …my other half” (page 91, lines 481-488). Upon examining Adam’s words, I discovered that Adam takes advantage of Eve’s lack of knowledge when reasoning with her. He doesn’t tell her everything. He keeps a few pieces of important information to himself. Assuming all Adam’s logic is truthful and based on facts, then he has a very valid argument as to why she should stay with him. But since it is not based on substantial evidence, rather assumptions, as I will soon prove, his argument to Eve will be shown to be invalid and should be disregarded. Yet, since Eve is unaware of all the facts and has only Adam’s words to believe, Adam prevails and his reasoning wins Eve’s heart, “I yielded, and from that time see how beauty is excelled by manly grace and wisdom which alone is truly fair.” (lines 489-491)

I will begin my proof by analyzing Adam’s use of the word “lent” in “To give thee being I lent out of my side to thee.” (lines 483- 484) According to The Free Dictionary, “lent” is the past tense form of the word “lend” which means “to permit the use of (something) with the expectation of return of the same or an equivalent.” Firstly, how does Adam know that an act of loaning took place? We turn to book VIII where Adam relates his vision of Eve's creation to Raphael. He says “Mine eyes he closed… abstract as in a trance methought I saw (though sleeping where I lay),” (page 190, lines 460-463) showing that at the time, he was neither conscious nor...

... middle of paper ...

...ts Adam’s truth distortions have on Eve are quite simple. Saying he consented to the loan tells Eve that Adam did something nice for Eve that he didn’t have to do, and that without him, she would not exist. Thus, gaining her compassion and giving her an extremely strong feeling of indebtedness. Adding that what he loaned her was “substantial” life implies that she owes him something of a similar degree of importance in return, which he claims to be her. Obviously wanting to fulfill her obligation, she “reimburses” her creditor, “I yielded” (line 489).

Now it is clear that from the outset, Adam exploits Eve’s lack of knowledge in order to “Have thee by my side” (line 485). Was this the only way to accomplish his goal? Probably not. But was it the safest way (the most likely to work)? I think so, and apparently, so does Adam.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Reflection about Eve and Adam Essay

- A significant issue put forward in this contention is a re-examination of the significance of the name Adam, (“Adham” in Hebrew). Although some use “Adham” as a correct name for the male creation of God, Dr. Trible informs us that the phrase “Adham” can be utilised as a generic term for humankind – “adham is an androgynous term; one creature incorporating two sexes.” Secondly, the scribe points out that the creation of woman was a divine proceed rather than a demand by Adam. She extracts Genesis 2:18, in which God concludes that Adam needs a “helper fit for him.” The focus being on the phrase “helper” (“ezer” in Hebrew)....   [tags: god creation, adam, eve, genesis]

Strong Essays
529 words (1.5 pages)

Milton’s Hero: A Feminist Eve Essay

- Gender equality, a relatively recent development, did not exist socially in John Milton’s time. Women in the 17th century were regarded and treated as second-rate, as men’s enjoyable, beautiful, yet rather inconsequential, subordinates. A cursory reading of Paradise Lost may suggest that Milton shares the idea of the male sex’s supremacy; he preserves the Biblical construction of the Garden of Eden as a decidedly chauvinistic stage and instills in his characters a collective assessment that manhood surpasses womanhood by way of strength, virtue, and intellect....   [tags: Literature Analysis]

Strong Essays
2054 words (5.9 pages)

Adam and Eve Rhetorical Strategies Essays

- In “The Diary of Adam” and “The Diary of Eve,” Mark Twain writes of the lives of Adam and Eve from The Book of Genesis in a comical manner. Adam and Eve are newly conceived and are incipient to the world. Eve chases Adam in a vivacious manner while Adam continuously tries to elude her. Then, Eve makes the critical mistake of eating the forbidden fruit, and both Adam and Eve are expelled from the Garden of Eden. The couple then discovers what they think is a fish but in reality is a human baby. In both of these short stories, Twain uses humor, imagery, and stereotypes to portray a central message....   [tags: The Diary of Adam, The Diary of eve, mark twain]

Strong Essays
974 words (2.8 pages)

Gender and Adam and Eve Essay

- Throughout modern society nothing symbolizes the fall of humankind more than a woman with feminine flowing hair and luscious lips biting into a large apple. While the biblical account evoking such imagery remains the primary authority, John Milton in Paradise Lost enlightens beyond the allegorical, offering a complexity of character and purpose. In this epic, readers are guided along humanity’s fall from grace, contrasting the ideal union of man and wife alongside harsh consequences that emerge from dangerous engendered perspectives....   [tags: grace, Eden, Adam, Eve, Wadlock, Milton]

Strong Essays
2340 words (6.7 pages)

Symbolism for Adam and Eve in Nathanial Hawthorne's "Scarlet Letter" Essay

- Through the use of numerous symbols, Nathanial Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter serves as an allegory for the story of Adam and Eve and its relation to sin, knowledge, and the human condition that is present in human society. Curious for the knowledge of good and evil, Adam and Eve sinned in the Garden of Eden, which resulted in the revelation of their “humanness” and expulsion from the “divine garden” as they then suffered the pain and joy of being humans. Just as Adam and Eve were expelled from their society and suffered in their own being, so were Hester Prynne and Arthur Dimmesdale in The Scarlet Letter....   [tags: Adam and Eve, Nathanial Hawthorne, Scarlet Letter,]

Strong Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

Eve And The Apple Essay

- Eve and the Apple      No one completely understands the ways of God. Many of us can come up with our own opinions, and justify his ways in our own minds, just as Milton did in Paradise Lost. Just as Adam and Eve, we all are gifted with free will and the responsibility of making important decisions and choices in our life, which will determine our future. But we may well ask ourselves today, of what use would this free will be to us if we did not know good from evil. When Eve ate the apple in the Garden of Eden she had two different voices telling her what to do....   [tags: God Religion Religious Eve Adam Essays]

Free Essays
781 words (2.2 pages)

Punishment and Self-Persuasion in Adam and Eve Essay

- Using Punishment and Self-Persuasion to Explain Adam and Eve The Book of Genesis tells the story of how God created man and woman. He permitted Adam and Eve to eat from any tree in his garden except the Tree of Knowledge, and they faced death if they did. They were handed out a severe threat; that of death. As we all know, Adam and Eve did eat from the tree of knowledge and were banished from the Garden of Eden. Looking at the situation from a social psychology perspective, I will examine why that was the case, and what God could have theoretically done to be obeyed....   [tags: Scripture Analysis]

Strong Essays
1119 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on East of Eden, by John Steinbeck: The Events After the Fall of Adam

- “I believe there are monsters born in the world . . . misshapen and horrible . . . accidents and no one’s fault . . . punishments for concealed sins . . . [their] face and body may be perfect . . . ” but they are the product of “a twisted gene or a malformed egg . . . ” (71). Literature, throughout history, has conveyed a plethora of themes, ranging from the struggle to understand divine intervention, to adversity, to the dramatization of life and death. One of the most prestigious and conventional of these themes is the conflict betwixt good and evil....   [tags: Cain and Abel, Adam and Eve]

Strong Essays
1225 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Adam and Eve

- Qualities of women were assessed and defined on the subservient and passiveness scale. The character of women is in direct effect of specific attributes like modesty, humility, chastity, temperance, and patience to name a few. These distinctive quality traits provide a description of someone who’s powerless on decisions with compliance at all times. Women from the Renaissance era must docile when speaking, and never speak out of anger or argue, nor must she be clever and witty. The detracted value of women was established long after Adam and Eve sinned together....   [tags: Social Issues, Informative]

Strong Essays
1783 words (5.1 pages)

Adam & Eve Essay

- It is impossible to taste the sweet without having first tasted the sour. This is one of the many lessons found within Genesis 2.0 and more specifically the story of Adam and Eve. It is also from this twisted tale of betrayal and deceit that we gain our knowledge of mankind?s free will, and God?s intentions regarding this human capacity. There is one school of thought which believes that life is mapped out with no regard for individual choice while contrary belief tells us that mankind is capable of free will and therefore has control over hisown life and the consequences of his actions....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1108 words (3.2 pages)