Essay on American Relations : An Indian 's Journey Through Reservation Life

Essay on American Relations : An Indian 's Journey Through Reservation Life

Length: 864 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Ethnicity has long been a cultural separator and gap closer for many generations. From the civil rights and black movements of the past and currently today, to the American Indians reservations and concentration camps of Japanese Americans during World War II. The American people and government are consistently fighting back and forth to try and right some sort of wrong that each party is consistently doing. George M. Fredrickson’s essay, Models of American Relations: A Historical Perspective (Fredrickson), talks about and explains how ethnic groups have been defining themselves for years or how the governments that they live under have been defining them as well. Ethnic groups have been defined and re-defined many different times throughout history this is apparent, but in what ways per Fredrickson’s models are they being defined or re-defined the most? In the movie, “Crash”, by writer and director Paul Haggis, as well as the essay “From Rez Life: An Indian’s Journey Through Reservation Life” by David Treuer, the most commonly used methods used one way assimilation and group separatism.
One way assimilation can be defined as the moment minorities give up their cultural identities for acceptance of a more elite or over powering culture already in place. In the movie “Crash” this is clearly seen when the movie director and his wife are fighting at home after the police stopped them. The wife tells the husband “The closest you ever came to being black, Cameron, was watching The Cosby Show”. (Crash) This shows that the husband has chosen to one way assimilate into the white community because of his chosen profession and how hard it might be for an African-American man to be a movie producer in Los Angeles. Similarly, in the essay b...


... middle of paper ...


... and talking about if most American Indians were to assimilate then their culture would die alongside them and they would cease to be American Indians and simply just be Americans; this provides a raw and unfiltered glimpse into why assimilation and group separatism are used to overcome such obstacles. There are many more examples throughout both works of each of Fredrickson’s models but these have given a glimpse into these works and what they were aimed to prove. They were targeted to show others that the only way to coexist with one another is by embracing each other’s differences and trying to help promote cultural diversity. Instead of a “Melting Pot” which promotes everyone to be the same in America, the “Salad Bowl” would be much better to help promote being different and being who you were meant to be. This is what America is about, not the other way around.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Movie Crash And From Rez Life : An Indian 's Journey Through Reservation Life

- The rich diversity in the United States has led itself into battles and ruins. Cultures fight against being assimilated so that they can save their culture, yet are praised for being different. This happens every day and will continue to happen so long as these different and mixed ethnicities continue to be diverse. In the movie Crash and “From Rez Life: An Indian’s Journey Through Reservation Life,” these different ethnicities can be seen both getting along and crashing, simply because there is a preference to Whites and ethnicities are encouraged to be assimilated despite being celebrated for their differences....   [tags: Race, United States]

Better Essays
934 words (2.7 pages)

Analysis Of Crash And From Rez Life : An Indian 's Journey Through Reservation Life

- The United States of America is anything but united. People from all corners of the globe immigrate here for the opportunities and freedoms that come with American citizenship. However cultural differences are causing the citizens of the United States to lock horns and focus on what separates them instead of the similar qualities that united them like the country’s name suggests. A film from 2004 and an essay from 2012 touch on the topic of how ethnic and cultural minorities face major problems in America today....   [tags: United States, Culture]

Better Essays
835 words (2.4 pages)

America 's Founding Fathers : An Indian 's Journey Through Reservation Life

- From big, overwhelming institutions setting regulations for a large amount of people to a small “everyday” family of 4, governments are almost always to blame for any and all outcomes. So many of America’s founding fathers had bad ideas and moral compasses pointed in the wrong direction, and now we as a people have to speak out on the injustices done to all of our people. Whether it’s in unpopular books and poems or in “cult-classic” films, many Americans have tried to speak out or bring the truth to light, the truth being how racist, sexist and unfair leaders and protectors have been to minorities....   [tags: United States]

Better Essays
717 words (2 pages)

Frederick Law Olmsted : The Father Of American Landscape Architecture Essay

- Frederick Law Olmsted (1822-1903) was considered the father of American Landscape Architecture. He is known throughout history for his landscape creations such as Central Park in New York City and Niagara Reservation in New York. Olmsted was an avid travel and had a keen eye for understanding the environment around him. He did not only evaluate the environment, but he also took interest in the people around the world as well. In Journey to the Southern Seaboard States, Frederick Olmsted travel to the southern states of the United States (we focused on Washington D.C., Virginia, South Carolina and Georgia)....   [tags: Southern United States, American Civil War]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Tayo and His Journey to Entirety Essay

- Cowardice, shell shock, battle fatigue, combat stress reaction (CSR), war neurosis, acute stress reaction, and posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) are merely a few titles describing the extreme psychological changes occurring in battle veterans enduring long periods of service as combat line troops since the advent of long-range artillery and rifle-fire. Native Americans were used and cast aside by a government responsible for taking their tribal lands and requesting of them to serve during World War II by means of the draft....   [tags: evil destruction, white men, native americans]

Better Essays
1024 words (2.9 pages)

Native American Reservation System Was A Complete Failure Essay

- The Native American Reservation system was a complete failure. This paper focuses on the topics of relocation, Native American boarding schools, current conditions on today’s reservations, and what effects these have had on the Native American way of life. The first failure in the Native American reservation system was in relocation. Native Americans were forced to move to locations that were very different from their traditional homelands. Many times, these reservations were hundreds, if not thousands of miles away which resulted in the deaths of many Native Americans in transit....   [tags: Indian reservation]

Better Essays
1272 words (3.6 pages)

Native American Education Essay

- Native American Education Through the years minority groups have long endured repression, poverty, and discrimination. A prime example of such a group is the Native Americans. They had their own land and fundamental way of life stripped from them almost unceasingly for decades. Although they were the real “natives” of the land, they were driven off by the government and coerced to assimilate to the white man’s way. Unfortunately, the persecution of the Natives was primarily based on the prevalent greed for money and power....   [tags: Native Americans]

Better Essays
1534 words (4.4 pages)

Native American Education Essay

- Through the years minority groups have long endured repression, poverty, and discrimination. A prime example of such a group is the Native Americans. They had their own land and basic way of life stripped from them almost constantly for decades. Although they were the actual “natives” of the land, they were forced by the government to give it up and compelled to assimilate to the white man’s way. This past scarred the Native American’s preservation of culture as many were discouraged to speak the native language and dress in traditional clothing....   [tags: Native Americans]

Better Essays
1361 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Assimilating into American Culture

- Immigration and assimilation is a divisive topic that has been heavily debated in America ever since we became a country. There are two stories that explore the assimilation issue from different viewpoints’; in Mary Pipher’s story; “The Beautiful Laughing Sisters – An Arrival Story”; provides the viewpoint of immigrants leaving a hostile home for America. Elizabeth Wong details her journey to break with her culture and become Americanized in, “The Struggle to be an all American girl.” and (McWhorter, 2010 pp522-529)....   [tags: Culture ]

Better Essays
1202 words (3.4 pages)

Rez Life Essay

- The author, David Treure, Ojibwe from Leech Lack Reservation in northern Minnesota, grew up on the reservation. He describes the Rez Life by using people’s stories and somehow connects these stories with historic evens. There are over three hundreds Indian reservations in the United States according to the Bureau of Indian Affairs. When you go to one of these, you will see the sign of welcome. The Rez is not much different from others. The landscape is the same. The fields, lacks, pines, swamps are the same....   [tags: Native-American culture, reservations]

Better Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)