Essay about A Comparative Study Of Texts And The Composer 's Contexts

Essay about A Comparative Study Of Texts And The Composer 's Contexts

Length: 1087 words (3.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

A comparative study of texts and the composer’s contexts demonstrates similar intertextual perspectives of universal issues regardless of the time written. Both Fritz Lang and George Orwell lived in times of wars that were a result of extreme political regimes. Lang specifically created his silent film Metropolis in 1927 in response to German expressionism values including art, architecture and emotion, in post-World War One Germany. Orwell wrote his dystopic 1948 novel Nineteen Eighty-Four (1984) after he was horrified by the control the government had over society in World War Two and Stalin’s communist Russia. Both composers have a similar purpose in forewarning society about the consequences of extreme governments; however their representation of these similar perspectives differs due to context. Their reflection on these extreme political ideologies is seen through their exploration of the nature of power and its consequences on the individual and on society as a whole.
Lang condemns the negative implications for society and individuals which may arise from hierarchical structures and the polarisation of classes. He illustrates this in Metropolis, highlighting the inequitable social divide between the underclass workers and the upper class through satirical juxtaposition. The setting in “The Depths,” is dark and full of machines, contrasting to the city and the “Eternal Gardens,” which are full of pillars and expressive architecture. The “workers’ city” is significantly less stylised and simplistic with little aesthetic design, demonstrating the difference in class due to the Industrial Revolution. In wide camera shots, the workers are dwarfed or in the background signifying the idolisation of technology. Workers are positio...


... middle of paper ...


...ngth,” enforcing a contradictory belief on the population that restricts freedom of thought. Therefore, unlike Lang, Orwell goes further and creates a dystopia, condemning society.
Through the exploration of power and its consequences, differing perspectives are seen on extreme political ideologies. Both texts, Metropolis by Fritz Lang and 1984 by George Orwell are reflections of the contextual influences of the time, Lang’s main influence being Germany’s power struggles post World War One, and Orwell’s being Stalinism and communist regimes. Their difference in context portrays a change in the way this affected society and individuals, but overall exposes the negative consequences of a dystopian future. Through a comparative study of the texts and their contexts, it can be seen that although context may change, the intertextual perspectives on similar issues do not.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Comparative Commentary on Two Texts

- Comparative Commentary on Two Texts Text ‘A’ was published in “August 12 1995” and was probably written the same day or the day before, as it is an article of the “Daily mirror.” Yet, its reliability cannot be trustful, as the newspaper is considered to be a tabloid. Hence, it is assumed that it would publish articles or chronicles for a lowbrow audience, just to rise their selling and increase their profits. On the other hand, text ‘B’ was written in “1966” and published twenty years after; in ”1986”....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
643 words (1.8 pages)

Essay on Biography of Composer John Dowland

- John Dowland (1563-1626) was a composer of Renaissance England and considered one of the most prolific and well-known composers of English lute song. A composer and accomplished lutenist, he is probably the most well traveled English composer of his time. Through his travels he was exposed to the musical elements of his Italian, French and German contemporaries. He developed his own musical language, in which he created a unique style for the lute song. As a composer, he focused on the development of melodic material and was able to elegantly blend words and music with a wide range of emotion and technique....   [tags: lute, composer, music]

Strong Essays
809 words (2.3 pages)

Significant Connections In Contemporary Texts Essay

- A world in anarchy, a country with no stable power or government, a city in ruin, a family in mourning, a man or woman going through hell and back. In the world of an apocalypse, society takes on new morales, and people change their beliefs on whether they belong. Danger and terror ensues. Death will arrive one way or another, whether the people know or not. But, through it all, there are a select few who relish this opportunity of havoc. Being able to break their barriers and help those who need something....   [tags: anarchy, value of death, apocalyptic texts]

Strong Essays
1506 words (4.3 pages)

A Comparative Study Of Jane Austen 's Pride And Prejudice Essay

- Connections between texts of different eras illuminate the dynamic nature of those central values that have continued to resonate within different contexts. A comparative study of Jane Austen’s 1813 novel Pride and Prejudice and Fay Weldon’s 1984 epistolary Letters to Alice highlights the evolution of autonomy within marriage, shifting away from traditional Regency values of marriage to become more liberal in Weldon’s society, while also exploring the value of self-reflection through the reconsidering of past superficial values of their respective Regency and Post-Modern milieus....   [tags: Sociology, Social stratification, British Regency]

Strong Essays
900 words (2.6 pages)

Music oo4 Composer Report on Carlo Gesualdo Essay

- I would like to start my report by saying that this is not the composer I was originally going to write about. I started out by looking up all the composers, and choosing Johannes Brahms because he looked like Santa Claus. I also liked him after reading more about him and then listening to one of his works called A German Requiem. However, I was not fully satisfied and began reading about other composers when I came upon Carlo Gesualdo. His story has the most drama and shock factor that I have read so far and thus caught my attention and provoked me to write my report on him....   [tags: composer, music, events]

Strong Essays
603 words (1.7 pages)

The Darkness Out There - The Signal Man - A comparetive study Essay

- The Darkness Out There - The Signal Man - A comparetive study The mood at the beginning of both stories could not contrast any more than it does. 'The Darkness Out There' has a beginning that is summery and fresh. Whereas 'The Signal Man' has a start that is very eerie and creates a sense of fear. A factor that runs all the way through the story. The effect that the beginning of 'The Darkness Out There' has is that Mrs Rutter's story hits the reader when they are not expecting it making it a lot more shocking....   [tags: English Literature]

Free Essays
1032 words (2.9 pages)

Conflicting Perspective Julius Caesar And The Pianist Essay

- The composers of texts, Julius Caesar and The Pianist, use acts of representations to construct credible viewpoints that are conveyed to the audience in a certain event displayed in the texts. This is seen in the text, Julius Caesar, by the portrayal of events including the Oration and Calpurnia’s Dream. This notion is made evident to the Elizabethan audience in the Representation process and these devices are utilized to show the viewpoints based primarily on actions vs. intentions and the nature of manipulation....   [tags: composers of texts]

Strong Essays
854 words (2.4 pages)

A comparative study of the ways in which Richard Cameron and Thomas Essay

- A comparative study of the ways in which Richard Cameron and Thomas Hardy apportion justice and sympathy towards the male characters. In 'Can't stand up for falling down' Cameron is looking at the boundaries of drama and braking them, most of the play consists of monologues, we are told of events by the female characters rather then, as is traditional in theatre, being shown them. Cameron uses this to form an intimacy between the audience and the female characters, allowing the audience to empathise with them, justify their actions and isolate the male characters....   [tags: English Literature]

Free Essays
2575 words (7.4 pages)

Moral and Ethical Issues, A Comparative Study Essay

- Control. Power. Decisions, who has the right to make them. Does the Government or a group have that right or does the individual have the right. Throughout history from our first book, the Bible, to our modern novels, literature has impacted our society in a great many ways; it reveals of our faults, and our triumphs, assist society in defining our moral values and ethical views. This paper will explore some moral and ethical issues about choice through several short stories: "Sonny Blue's," "Cathedral," and "The Lottery," and there will be two novels explored primarily; Fahrenheit 451 and George Orwell's 1984....   [tags: Comparative Literature]

Strong Essays
2296 words (6.6 pages)

A Great Composer Essays

- Inspiration may be a form of super-consciousness, or perhaps of subconsciousness—I wouldn’t know. But I am sure it is the antithesis of self-consciousness. Only one man could claim the title as probably the greatest composer in American history for writing so many unforgettable works: Aaron Copland. He lived a life inspired by many things as well as inspiring people all across the nation, and it really led to the opposite of being drawn into himself, as he described in the quote above. He was born in Brooklyn, New York on November 14 in 1900....   [tags: essays research papers]

Strong Essays
1190 words (3.4 pages)