Thomas Carlyle 's Social And Political Criticism Of England 's Condition During The 1840s

Thomas Carlyle 's Social And Political Criticism Of England 's Condition During The 1840s

Length: 992 words (2.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

There is no denying that Thomas Carlyle’s social and political criticism of England’s condition during the 1840s was among the most influential writing of that time. In his essay “Past and Present,” Carlyle acknowledges the fact that poor working conditions is a big problem in society. He states in the text, “And yet I will venture to believe that in no time, since the beginning of Society, was the lot of those same dumb millions of toilers so entirely unbearable as it is even in the days now passing over us.” (Carlyle, 29). This quote demonstrates so much about Carlyle’s attitude toward the working class. For instance, he reveals that he is very concerned about their predicament. Moreover, he understands that they have been overloaded with more work that they should, they have not been earning enough money for the work that they do, and they have been discriminated against because of their social class. Carlyle also realizes that it is very unfair that the working class has to experience these types of situations, especially when there are wealthy people witnessing the discrimination who can clearly do something about it. Furthermore, in the text, clearly wanting the inequality to end, Carlyle provides the reader with a solution to these injustices. He claims that labor needs to be organized and a better style of leadership will the best thing for society. Additionally, he states, “The main substance of this immense Problem of Organising Labour, and first of all of Managing the Working Classes, will, it is very clear, have to be solved by those who stand practically in the middle of it, by those who themselves work and preside over work.” (Carlyle, 36). Clearly, Carlyle believes that inequality and discrimination will someday end...


... middle of paper ...


...be right in that some people may need guidance when it comes to making decisions in the lives. It is possible that there would not be any poverty if this were the case. However, people will always take into consideration what is best for them and their family no matter what anyone else tries to tell them. Additionally, it is possible that this is why Carlyle’s ideas did not become more popular among people. Everyone like democracy and the ability to vote for things that will help improve their lives.
Carlyle definitely has some interesting ideas. In an ideal world, it would be so simple to get rid of all inequality and discrimination in the world. However, it is not as simple as saying “we need better leaders.” There are so many things to consider before anything changes. Even today, these issues are still around and it seems as if it is a cycle that will never end.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Mill, Carlyle and Tennyson on “The Woman Question” Essay

- Married women during Victorian times were considered to have the legal rights similar to children. They were not able to vote, hold bank accounts, sign contracts, or hold a professional position except that of a teacher. Husbands owned all money and property a woman brought to a marriage even if they divorced; and held sole custody of their children. Domestically and socially they were expected to act as “The Household General”, a term coined in 1861 by Isabella Beeton in her manual, Mrs. Beeton’s Book of Household Management....   [tags: Gender Issues]

Better Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Tennyson, Browning, Arnold and Carlyle

- Tennyson, Browning, Arnold and Carlyle Thomas Carlyle writes in Characteristics that, "The healthy know not of their health, but only the sick"(923). He extends this medical/biological aphorism to the social and ideological world of Victorian England. Carlyle thoroughly goes over the question, What is the state of England. He finds that England is in a state of transition, and while the old is no longer useful to the society, the new has not yet been clearly defined. This void contributes to problems of poverty, social graces, and spiritual/social direction in 19th C....   [tags: Biography Biographies Essays]

Better Essays
2076 words (5.9 pages)

Industrialization in England Essays

- The world has changed in many ways throughout history. Industrialization has changed England in many ways. The Industrial Revolution was too hard on the men, women, and children in England. The changes that occurred in the economy and society in Britain during the late 18th and 19th century is known as the Industrial Revolution (McCloskey Int.). The Industrial Revolution was a drawn-out process that transformed Britain’s economy from the production of goods by hand to the production of goods by machine (Thackerary 1)....   [tags: England]

Better Essays
1831 words (5.2 pages)

Industrial Revolution in England and Working Conditions Essay

- The industrial revolution began in England during the late 1700’s and early 1800’s. There were several factors that played a role in why the industrial revolution began in England. One of the most important factors that played a role was the rich land. The land at this point in time had numerous different natural resources that could be used to benefit the country. The land had an enormous amount of different resources such as coal, iron, wool, cotton, and lead. Another major benefit of the geography of the land was how the furthest point in the country from sea was only seventy miles away....   [tags: Industrial Revolution, England, history, ]

Better Essays
491 words (1.4 pages)

Essay about The New England And Chesapeake Region

- Throughout the 1600s and 1700s, the English nation began colonizing a large part of the American East Coast. Even though the New England and Chesapeake regions were both settled by the English, the two regions developed differently due to the contrasting reasons for settlement. The settlers in the New England region sought out religious freedom opposed to pursuit for economic liberty in the Chesapeake region. The different reasons for settlement caused the two regions to have many unique variances and similarities in their religious beliefs, financial goals, and toleration....   [tags: Puritan, Massachusetts Bay Colony, England]

Better Essays
1047 words (3 pages)

Social Inequality : A Social Condition Essay

- a. Social inequality/pg.79: A social condition in which privileges and obligations are given to some but denied to others. MS13 is the largely growing gang who seeks power mostly through the drug trafficking privileges. Power is also granted by “owning” certain territory around the city, and claiming the area as your own. Once the area is claimed, they strictly force all business to give them somewhat of a profit for having money come in on their territory. This gang recruits all of their members who volunteer and by the completion of their jobs given to them....   [tags: Gang, Illegal drug trade, Sociology]

Better Essays
1973 words (5.6 pages)

Essay about The Major Works of Thomas Carlyle

- The Victorian Age which extended from 1837 to 1901 was an era of great social change and intellectual advancement. "The steady advance of democratic ideals" and "the progress of scientific thought" (Compton-Rickett, page 405) were the chief factors influencing the life of the times. The age was marked by "conflicting explanations and theories, of scientific and economic confidence and of social and spiritual pessimism, of a sharpened awareness of the inevitability of progress and of deep disquiet as to the nature of the present" (Sanders, page 399)....   [tags: Poetry]

Better Essays
1581 words (4.5 pages)

Essay about The Theme of Social Responsibility in Victorian England

- How does dickens explore the theme of social responsibility in Victorian England. Charles dickens wrote ‘A Christmas Carol’ for a certain reason, and that reason was that he wanted to make people aware of the terrible situation the children of the poor were in. He visited a school in 1843 and was appalled by what he saw there. It was a school for the poorest children to teach them basic reading and writing skills. The children’s employment commission had also shocked him. At first dickens had the idea of writing a pamphlet called ‘an appeal to the people of England on behalf of the poor mans child’ but soon realised that seen as he was the most popular novelist of the time people would take...   [tags: Social Responsibility Essays]

Better Essays
720 words (2.1 pages)

Essay about The Human Condition: Contemplation Key to Understanding

- The Human Condition: Contemplation Key to Understanding Ask the average American what the problems facing his country are, and you will get a battery of standard responses. Some people will say health care, others violent crime, and still others will say drugs. There will probably be some who complain of high taxes or express a need for gun control. Certainly, there is evidence to support the fact that these are all issues of great importance. However, these are only superficial, and there is a deeper problem that will not have a simple legislative solution....   [tags: Hannah Arendt Human Condition Essays]

Better Essays
572 words (1.6 pages)

America’s Mergence of Personal and Public Realms in Arendt’s The Human Condition

- America’s Mergence of Personal and Public Realms in Arendt’s The Human Condition America is a superpower, irrefutably the most dominant nation in the world. Underlining this supremacy, however, is the fact that America's society is facing several problems. Among these problems is what Hannah Arendt calls the emergence of society through the mergence of both the personal and public realms. This major problem has spawned numerous other problems, so has been chosen as the underlying cause for the tribulations of modern American society....   [tags: Human Condition]

Better Essays
644 words (1.8 pages)