The Platonic and Aristotelian Views on the Role and Status of Women in Society

The Platonic and Aristotelian Views on the Role and Status of Women in Society

Length: 3397 words (9.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Research Papers

Open Document

Essay Preview

Introduction
Women’s rights and societal roles have varied throughout history. Yet, a common theme that is notable across many times and cultures is the notion that women are inferior to men. In ancient Greece, the opinion toward women followed this trend, and women were often overlooked in how they could contribute to society. It was rarely considered that the traits women share could be of use beyond their household duties. In this essay I will analyze the Platonic and Aristotelian views on the role and status of women. Although Plato and Aristotle had distinct beliefs on what women could contribute to the collective well being of society, they shared similar opinions about the genuine status that women had in comparison to men. The Platonic view advanced the idea that secluding women to the home was counter-productive to the community as a whole. As such, women should be afforded roles that stretched beyond the boundaries of the home for the benefit of the community. The Aristotelian view, contrastingly, believed that the natural characteristics of women, which deemed them physically and intellectually inferior to men, made the home their proper place within society. In this essay I will advance the view that through the logic constructed by both Plato and Aristotle it follows deductively that women not only have a place outside of the home but their distinctive nature can add something of value to many areas of society.

A Platonic View Toward Women: A Community of Women and Children
It is sometimes contended that Plato was a feminist, but his concern for women did not stem from an interest in women’s rights, but rather the usefulness women could contribute to the benefit of the community. Meaning, society would receive...


... middle of paper ...


...oes not follow logically that women are intellectually inferior. The nature of women that emanates from their traditional role as mothers and caregivers can in fact not only be sufficient but necessary for the optimal functioning polis. The compassion and consideration that emanates from the nature of women could be the true keystone in wholesome state, and the highest form of collective well being that Plato and Aristotle searched for.



Works Cited


Aristotle. The Politics. Trans. T.A. Sinclair. Rev. ed. Trevor J. Saunders. New York:
Penguin classics, 1957. Print.

Bloom, Allan (1968, revised 1991). The Republic of Plato. Translated, with notes and an
interpretive essay. New York: Basic Books.

Magnusson, Warren. “Ancient and Medieval Political Thought.” Political Science 300A.
University of Victoria. British Columbia, 4 Jan. 2012 – 21 Mar. 2012.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The American Republic Government versus the Platonic or Aristotelian Government

- Governing a society of people and achieving a justice presents a challenge regardless of the form. While the American Republic government has leant itself to many flaws when it comes to justice, it still embodies a stronger checks and balances to achieve justice that are limited in Platonic or Aristotelian government forms. We have a strong belief and precedent in achieving justice by way of our people from protests, boycotts to our election process. The activity level is important in combatting challenges in the justice system....   [tags: checks, balance, justice, challenges]

Research Papers
518 words (1.5 pages)

Essay on Platonic And Aristotelian Epistemology : Comparison And Contrast

- ... In the Socratic dialogue found in Theaetetus, Plato elaborates on what he believes knowledge is not. Socrates criticizes and refutes three definitions of knowledge: knowledge cannot be perception, true opinion, or true opinion combined with explanation (Theaetetus, 61-68). In the Divided Line and Myth of the Cave, Plato touches upon what he believes knowledge is. The “divided line” corresponds to the two main divisions of worlds: the visible world and the intelligible world, each with their own subdivisions....   [tags: Plato, Aristotle, Logic, Epistemology]

Research Papers
1213 words (3.5 pages)

A Platonic View Of An Idealistic Society Essay

- ... To do this Plato proposes that no one in the city will be aware of their biological parents. Thus after birth, the children will be taken away to a rearing pen to be taken care of by nurses and the parents will not be allowed to know who their children are. Plato details his system, “They’ll take the children of good parents to the nurses in charge of the rearing pen situated in a separate part of the city, but the children of inferior parents, or any child of the others that is born defective, they’ll hid in a secret and unknown place, as is appropriate […] they must deal with it in the knowledge that no nature is available for it” (460c-d, 461c)....   [tags: Philosophy, Plato, Epistemology, Belief]

Research Papers
1738 words (5 pages)

Essay on Difference Between Romantic And Platonic Love

- ... It is land, solid ground in the midst of a beautiful hurricane. It’s knowing that no matter how disastrous it may get, you never fail to see his silhouette in the distance. It’s amazing when you find this one person—the one you never thought would fit quite nicely in the space of your heart as if its meant to be there. And sometimes it feels overwhelming, in a good way, because he’s making you feel all sorts of things. Unraveling all of you in order to know all of you; memorizing every nook and cranny, and loving you all the same....   [tags: Love, Interpersonal relationship, Platonic love]

Research Papers
983 words (2.8 pages)

Essay on The Truth About Platonic Friendships

- The researcher's qualitative research consisted of speaking with platonic friends of the opposite sex in casual random settings. The qualitative research was completely random using friends by chance that had no idea of the experiment. In doing so the researcher realizes that it is unethical, but figured it was the only way to find the real answers to his problem. During the conversation the researcher at one point or another came to ask the same four questions to all of the subjects involved in the experiment....   [tags: Platonic Love and Friendship]

Free Essays
976 words (2.8 pages)

My Role in Society Essay

- Life is a short journey that each and every human has to attempt. But why do people stop thinking about their importance in the society. Why do they forget that this huge world has a special space reserved for their role or thinking. As tiny drops of water make up a sea, as small components of particles come together from their unity and make up a planet, God has given us an opportunity to change this world in a small way but with our own thoughts not of others. By saying the above sentence I remember a story that my mom told me when I was in Grade 7, there was a man on the sea shore who was throwing a starfish one by one, by seeing this man a boy came and asked him what was he trying to do...   [tags: My Role in the World]

Research Papers
565 words (1.6 pages)

Essay on The Role Money Plays in Society

- Money Money is the driving force behind everything in modern day society. According to Ford, a character in Noah Hawley’s A Conspiracy of Tall Men, money is what keeps society together. “You know what keeps us from sliding back into barbarism. Money. That is the one constant.”(Hawley, 362) Linus, the main character in Hawley’s novel, does not want to be a part of this society because he is afraid of money and what it represents. “Linus is afraid of money. Not the smaller bills, the Washington’s and Lincolns, the Jackson’s and Grants, but the larger sums, the cashiers checks with multiple zeros, the stock portfolios and escrow accounts, afraid too of what they buy, the new cars with their l...   [tags: Money Society]

Research Papers
2198 words (6.3 pages)

The Role of Women in Society Essay

- The Role of Women in Society Women are important in our society. Every woman has her own job or duty in this modern society in which men are still the 'strongest gender';. We can´t forget that women´s life is a lot more complicated than a man´s life. A woman has to take care of her own personal life and if she is a mother , she has to take care also about her children´s life too. Marriaged women have lots of worries and believe it or not , they carry out a more stressfull life than marriaged men....   [tags: Women Females Society Essays]

Research Papers
502 words (1.4 pages)

Platonic Forms Essay

- One Example of a Platonic Form other than what the book suggests is the Form of a book. The idea to write this paper on the Form of book came to me while I was sitting in the library perusing the reference books, trying to decide on an answer to question 2. You could say that the answer was staring me right in the face. I believe that the Form of a book exists but I have to agree with Aristotle's idea that the Form is created when the object is created. I also think that Forms are eternal, but from the moment that they are first thought of and then brought into the physical world....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
540 words (1.5 pages)

Aristotelian Essay

- Can a Child be Virtuous. In this paper I will argue against Aristotle and his idea that children cannot be virtuous, as we discussed in class. I will do this by giving concrete examples that a certain widespread religion believes in this virtuosity of a child. I will also use a more common example that occurs all the time in America. Aristotle says that children cannot be virtuous because virtues are something that, to be acquired must be practiced over and over again. A child has not had enough practice, time or understanding of what he is doing to be considered virtuous....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
887 words (2.5 pages)