Essay The Disabled Athlete “Does” have an Unfair Advantage

Essay The Disabled Athlete “Does” have an Unfair Advantage

Length: 1185 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The article, "The Disabled Athlete has an Unfair Advantage," by Amby Burfoot, is a poorly written, research deficient article, in need of accurate, unbiased supporting facts. The article is written about Oscar Pistorius a double below knee amputee that competed but failed to qualify for the Beijing Olympics, after a lengthy court case. (Robinson) This unsatisfactorily written article has merit to the opinion, however, the author sounded as if he was a first time writer for a school newspaper. The facts used in the paper seem as if they were researched by asking someone who knows, someone who knows someone who is an amputee. Writing with this apparent ignorance, and recklessness can only lead to a larger divide between the two sides of the argument. The author Amby Burfoot is an editor-at large, and the winner of the 1968 Boston Marathon; states his argument the same as an elderly person afraid of change. The facts are not supported, ignorant selection of words, and at times out of touch tone is the wrong way to try to argue for what could be considered by some a sensitive subject. The fact that women and men are already placed into separate categories for events, and that there are Paralympics for amputees to compete in, completely passes the author by and he spends the article poorly stating that stumps with springs are cheating because "Pistorius does not need to train harder in order to qualify for the Beijing Olympics, he just needs a better set of equipment."(Burfoot)
All Athletes use equipment of some sort to give them some sort of advantage or to become even with the rest of the field. Mr. Burfoot states that, "Pistorius does not need to train harder in order to qualify for the Beijing Olympics, he just needs a be...

... middle of paper ...

...on to the track are unfortunate. Being a former Boston Marathon winner Mr. Burfoot must be an expert on running, that being said, having a sister with an amputation and winning a marathon does not make you an expert on amputation running.

Works Cited

Burfoot, Amby. "The Disabled Athlete Has an Unfair Advantage." Footloose: Amby Burfoot's Notes from the Road (24 June 2007). Rpt. in The Olympics. Ed. Tamara L. Roleff. Detroit: Greenhaven Press, 2009. General Onefile. Web.
"Can Prosthetics Give Double-amputee’s Advantage Over Able-bodied Runners?" Newsday [Melville, NY] 15 July 2007. General OneFile. Web.
"Long jump." Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online. Encyclopædia Britannica, 2011. Web.
Robinson, Joshua. "Prosthetics Gave Runner Unfair Edge, Report Says." New York Times 19 Nov. 2009: B13(L). Gale Opposing Viewpoints In Context. Web.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Rights of Disabled Individuals in Sporting Competitions Essay examples

- An ethical issue that has been on the rise in recent years is the rights of disabled individuals in sports competition. Much controversy has surrounded Paralympic champion sprinter Oscar Pistorius over whether or not he should have been allowed to participate in the London Olympics or not. The fight between him and the International Olympic Committee was ultimately over the IOC believing that his running blades gave him an unfair advantage over Olympians. On the other hand, Pistorius and supporters argued that his blades did not give him and advantage over the competition....   [tags: olympics, blades, advantage, athletes]

Better Essays
965 words (2.8 pages)

Unfair Advantages: The Loss of Lowering College Acceptance for Athletes Essay

- College bound students around the world are in search of an easier route to be accepted into college. What about college athletes. These students are those who stand out. Many college athletes feel as though they deserve a “reward” for enhancing the school’s program. Though they may deserve acknowledgement of their participation, lowering admission standards will lower their effort in school as well. Intercollegiate athletic programs corrupt their educational institutions by advertising a double standard and devaluing scholarships in favor of athletic competition....   [tags: college, accept, athletes]

Better Essays
807 words (2.3 pages)

Drugs in Sports Gives an Unfair Advantage Essay

- My topic is drugs in sports. My opinion on Drug in Sports is that is wrong and it gives an unfair advantage to the users. Doping ( taking banned drugs to improve one’s performance ) in professional sports is illegal. Many people dope because it makes them better at their sports. For some athletes, along with doping comes the ability of sporting, personal and financial reward. To many people, the difference between failure and victory may appear to be as small as a pill in the palm of someone’s hand....   [tags: doping, blood, cheating]

Better Essays
591 words (1.7 pages)

Essay on Performance Enhancing Drugs: Steroids

- Steroids: No Pain No Gain. The problems with performance enhancing drugs are that they give the user unfair advantages over other athletes and come with many health risks such as baldness. Steroid use can result in very substantial legal consequences and can ruin the user’s reputation. There are many alternatives to steroids but not all of them are safe. Different organizations have different rules on steroids, but in most cases, the user can get suspended, fined, or even both. Various types of steroids can have various short-term or long-term side effects....   [tags: athletes, sports, unfair advantage]

Better Essays
1672 words (4.8 pages)

Sports and Performance Drugs Essay

- ... Women may get: deeper voice, cessation of breast development, growth of hair on face, stomach, and upper back, and abnormal menstrual cycles. Have you wondered why athletes are better now than in the past. Some say it’s because performance enhancement drugs. In the last few years a lot of athletes have been caught using performance enhancing drugs. Usually they have been famous people who have a lot of expectations on them and they need it so they can play better. They think that if they play better they’ll be the best there ever was....   [tags: cheating, unfair advantage]

Better Essays
780 words (2.2 pages)

How Do You Determine Gender? Essay

- Opinion Paper: How Do You Determine Gender. Within our day and age, many scientific practices such as abortion have been contested due to social and ethical morals. A controversial topic which emerged in the mid-1960s was the gender-verification of female athletes competing internationally. The International Olympic Committee alongside the International Amateur Athletics Federation established a mandatory test for females to ensure their “femininity”. Athletes with an unfair “male advantage” were disqualified....   [tags: athlete, genes, advantage]

Better Essays
681 words (1.9 pages)

Essay about Religion: Islam and Unfair Criticism

- Islam is a religion that creates many different thoughts when it is mentioned, especially in America. Unfortunately it is subject to many unfair stereotypes, stemming from the attacks on September 11, 2001. The attacks were committed by Muslims, albeit radical Muslims, so many people associate the Islamic Religion with terrorism. Since it was founded, Islam has been the fasted growing religion in the world, becoming the second most populous Religion in the world (Van Voorst 292). Over the years Islam has faced an uphill battle, in terms of public opinion, because of its association with Terrorism....   [tags: unfair stereotypes, september 11th]

Better Essays
1623 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Housman's To An Athlete Dying Young

- Housman's "To An Athlete Dying Young" A. E. Housman's "To an Athlete Dying Young," also known as Lyric XIX in A Shropshire Lad, holds as its main theme the premature death of a young athlete as told from the point of view of a friend serving as pall bearer. The poem reveals the concept that those dying at the peak of their glory or youth are really quite lucky. The first few readings of "To an Athlete Dying Young" provides the reader with an understanding of Housman's view of death. Additional readings reveal Housman's attempt to convey the classical idea that youth, beauty, and glory can be preserved only in death....   [tags: Poem Housman Athlete Dying Essays]

Free Essays
1640 words (4.7 pages)

Essay on Disabled Sports

- When one looks at the word “disability”, it immediately conjures up an idea of what someone cannot do, or something physically wrong with an individual, that prevents them from doing something as the majority of society can do. When society looks at a person with a disability, society relates or compares them to what is considered “normal”. It is that comparison to the majority, or normality which causes society to view a disability as a negative. Disabilities can limit someone or on the other hand, they can give an advantage....   [tags: Talcott Parson, Michel Foucault]

Better Essays
2568 words (7.3 pages)

The Elements of a Real Athlete Essay example

- The Elements of a Real Athlete      When you think of an athlete, what comes to mind. The first things that probably come to mind are sports, entertainment, and physical abilities. If these are the first things you think of, then how would athletes significant. If you look at athletes from a different perspective, their significance can be seen. From this point of view one can see that athletes are significant because they provide role models, contribute to our business world, bring countries or groups of people together, and they provide sources of inspriration....   [tags: Sports Athletics Sport Athletes Essays]

Better Essays
820 words (2.3 pages)