Essay about Semantic Phenomena versus Pragmatic Phenomena

Essay about Semantic Phenomena versus Pragmatic Phenomena

Length: 1290 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


It seems unlikely that there will ever be consensus about the extent to which we can reliably distinguish semantic phenomena from pragmatic phenomena. But there is now broad agreement that a sentence's meaning can be given in full only when it is studied in its natural habitat: as part of an utterance by an agent who intends it to communicate a message. Here, we document some of the interactions that such study has uncovered. In every case, to achieve even a basic description, it is necessary to pool semantic information, contextual information, speaker intentions, and general pragmatic pressures.

Space limitations preclude discussion of PRESUPPOSITIONS and SPEECH-ACTS, two important classes of phenomena for which semantics and pragmatics are so thoroughly intertwined that analyses of them invariably draw information from both domains.

In a broad range of cases, pragmatic information is required just to obtain complete and accurate meanings for the words and phrases involved. Indexical expressions (see INDEXICALS) are clear examples (Kaplan 1971). In order to determine what proposition is expressed by an utterance of (1), we must look to the context to fix the speaker.

(1) I am here.

We must also appeal to the context to obtain the intended meaning of here (in this room, in this city, ...). Which meaning we select will be shaped by considerations of informativity and relevance (see PRAGMATICS). (For example, (1) is likely to be trivially true if here is construed as picking out planet earth, and speakers will therefore avoid that interpretation until interplanetary travel becomes routine.)

Similar factors influence anaphora resolution. If a speaker utters (2), his addressees will ...

... middle of paper ...

...rttunen, Lauri. 1976. Discourse referents. In James D. McCawley, ed., Syntax and Semantics, Volume 7: Notes from the Linguistic Underground, 363–385. New York: Academic Press.

Kratzer, Angelika. 1989. An investigation of the lumps of thought. Linguistics and Philosophy 12(6):607–653.

Levinson, Stephen C. 2000. Presumptive Meanings: The Theory of Generalized Conversational Implicature. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Partee, Barbara H. 2004. Compositionality in Formal Semantics: Selected Papers of Barbara H. Partee, Volume 1 of Explorations in Semantics. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing.

Russell, Benjamin. 2006. Against grammatical computation of scalar implicatures. Journal of Semantics 23(4):361–382.

Sadock, Jerrold M. 1978. On testing for conversational implicature. In Peter Cole, ed., Syntax and Semantics, Vol. 9: Pragmatics, 281–297. New York: Academic Press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Lexical Pragmatic Analysis of Proverbs in Femi Osofisan’s Midnight Hotel.

- ... For instance, he describes the low class hotel situated in Lagos as a metaphor for Nigeria (132). The question therefore is, how does Ojo work this out. He probably relies on his knowledge of the Nigerian situation which shares some similarities with the hotel (Midnight Hotel,1). Nonetheless, this essay illuminates the comprehension procedure by doing a semantic modulation of pertinent lexical items in the proverbs deployed in the text, to show their correlation with contextual features. For instance, the ‘labour room’ (Midnight Hotel, 27) can be semantically expanded to mean the hotel, and further to mean Nigeria....   [tags: pragmatic reading, moral, socio-politics]

Better Essays
1499 words (4.3 pages)

Knowledge Representation Using Semantic Web Techniques Essay

- The emergence of the World Wide Web (WWW) has brought exciting new possibilities in information access and electronic business. The WWW has grown to be the largest distributed repository of information ever created. Current estimates reveal that the Web currently contains about 3 billion static documents and being accessed by over 500 million users from around the world [6]. Web content consists largely of distributed hypertext and hypermedia, accessible via keyword-based search and link navigation....   [tags: Semantic Web]

Better Essays
567 words (1.6 pages)

Semantic And Structural Information On The Human Memory Essay

- There are lot of research conducted about how semantic and structural information affecting to the human memory. Psychologist Craik has defined that meaningful information has better chance to stay in human memory longer than the numeric information (1973). Endel and Tulving (1985) proposed episodic and semantic memories process different information. The independent variable is the structural information. Dependant variable is the participants’ test scores. Participants are volunteers of the New College psychology access students 2016....   [tags: Memory, Hippocampus, Semantic memory]

Better Essays
1133 words (3.2 pages)

Analysis of Semantics and Pragmatics in Two Texts Essays

- Analysis of Semantics and Pragmatics in Two Texts Linguistics is the science of a language. Linguists depend on the use of certain aspects in order to analyse, describe and explain a human language; these aspects include semantics and pragmatics. Semantics can be defined as the study of "meaning" of lexical words and expressions independently of context. Where pragmatics is the process of recognising the "invisible meaning" of lexical items and expressions; taking into account the speaker's/ addressee's intention, the status of hearer/ receiver and the actual situation....   [tags: Compare Contrast Linguistics]

Free Essays
1481 words (4.2 pages)

Sociology's Role in Understanding Important Social Phenomena Essay

- According to Holmes, Hughes, and Julian (2012) “at its most ambitious, sociology attempts to understand human societies from a wholistic point of view – what they are composed of, how they are reproduced over time and how they might differ from other societies”. Viewing society in this context, allows sociologists to understand the foundation of a society; and the motivations / values that underpin its function. Social phenomena, such as ‘sex, gender, and sexuality’ and their respective dominating themes [and inequalities] shape society as a whole....   [tags: social phenomena, gender, sociology]

Better Essays
858 words (2.5 pages)

Semantic Networks And Its Effects On Lexical Selection Essay

- Previous research by Howard et al (2006) and Oppenheim et al (2006) has shown that cumulative semantic inhibition affects lexical selection. Whilst these studies show the effect is present, they do not investigate how a lexical semantic network is formed and how new vocabulary is integrated into such a network. We aim to investigate how newly learned vocabulary is affected by these previously existing lexicosemantic networks and consider how the results of this could study affect current models of lexical selection, and investigate how this affects our current understanding of language acquisition, comprehension and production....   [tags: Linguistics, Language, Learning, Semantics]

Better Essays
1898 words (5.4 pages)

Ontological Relativism and the Pragmatic Notion of Metaphysical Truth Essay

- Ontological Relativism and the Pragmatic Notion of Metaphysical Truth ABSTRACT: I. Introduction The mind body problem resembles a black hole in the universe of philosophy: It takes a lot of energy which could be spent otherwise. Therefore, it would be liberating to show that it is not a problem at all. That is exactly what I shall do in this paper. Roughly, I shall argue as follows: First, I will show that the traditional mind body problem as a logical conflict will not occur if one is more decided in dualism....   [tags: Philosophy Metaphysics Research]

Free Essays
2267 words (6.5 pages)

Social Phenomena Essay

- Over time, three main theories have developed to explain social phenomena. While each theory has significant differences, there are points of each one that can help shed light on how society works. While some theories attempt to explain our social reality based on how each part of a society works together, other theories focus on the conflicts in the society, or the interaction between individuals in a society (Kendall, 23). The three classic theories of sociology include the functionalist perspective, conflict perspective, and symbolic interactionist perspective....   [tags: Functionalist and Interactionist Perspectives]

Better Essays
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Pragmatic and You

- There has been great debate over which is the best way for second language students to learn English. English-only advocates feel that all learning materials should be taught in English, while bilingual advocates feel there should be a mixture of using the student’s native language along with English. The pragmatic approach has a viewpoint that explains it is not the language that should be the primary focus, but how the instructions and materials are delivered to ensure every student is learning....   [tags: Second Language Students, Learning English]

Better Essays
884 words (2.5 pages)

Pragmatic Justification Essay

- Bertrand Russell, one of the most influential philosophers of the modern age, argued extensively in his book, “The Problems of Philosophy”, that the belief in inductive reasoning is only rational on the grounds of its intrinsic evidence; it cannot be justified by an appeal to experience alone (Russell 1998). Inductive reasoning refers to a form of reasoning that constructs or assesses propositions that are generalizations of observations (Russell 1998). Inductive reasoning is thus, in simple terms, probabilistic....   [tags: Philosophy, Bertrand Russell]

Better Essays
1319 words (3.8 pages)