Roger Scruton on Photography Essay

Roger Scruton on Photography Essay

Length: 2314 words (6.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In Roger Scruton's Photography and Representation the author establishes the idea that ideal photography is not art. In the same breath he says that ideal photography is not necessarily an idea which photographers should strive, nor does it necessarily exist. Yet, he bases his argument upon the ideal. In reviewing his paper, I’ll take a look at why he painstakingly tries to make this distinction between ideal painting and ideal photography. His argument is based upon the proposition that photographs can only represent in a causal fashion, whereas painters create representational artwork via intentional relations. Scruton manages to create a solid argument, but in the end I’ll decide it is not a fair assumption to say that photographs cannot provide meaning or aesthetic value.
Scruton wants to look at photography as an ideal, but he quickly states that ideal photography is a logical fiction. Why does it matter then? Obviously photography is a complex form of expression and the goal seems to be to derive the basic properties of photography in the simplest terms possible. However, he states that it should be clear to the reader that the concept need not actually exist and that if he makes claims that seem “exaggerated or false” we should not be put-off. To me this feels like a cop out. It is not made clear, to me at least, where exactly the connection between a fictional concept and reality occurs.
Scruton argues that when we take an interest in photographs, is actually an interest in the actual objects that were photographed rather than the photographs themselves. He claims this because he says there is no such thing as photographic representation. He says the photograph relates to the subject in that it is a phot...


... middle of paper ...


... believe makes photography an art, the individual photo may still be considered close to an ideal photograph in the sense that it is a causal relationship. However the medium as a whole is capable of much more than Scruton is willing to allow. I believe that the clear distinction lays in the fact that Scruton's argument that photography's causal relationship is equivalent to perceiving the object without the photograph. This is not true, because we have found distinctions where photographs and reality can never be the same. There is no doubt that you cannot see some of the intricacies of a fast moving object with the naked eye. This brings the eye new information. It may be a mechanical depiction of how the object actually looks, but it is a unique observation of it complete with its own aesthetic interest. Therefore we must say that photography may be art.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Why Photography is Not Art

- In Roger Scruton's essay, "Why Photography Is Not Art", an effort is made to question photography as a genuine art form. Roger spends much of his essay arguing that photography is merely a weak imitation of an object, rather than a carefully crafted depiction of a subject with its own aesthetic properties. Due to the rapid rise of photography all around the globe, his viewpoints are highly controversial. It is important for us to study both sides of the argument, because photography is so important in capturing world history....   [tags: photos, aesthetic properties, roger srcuton]

Powerful Essays
1113 words (3.2 pages)

Scruton 's Equivalency Thesis : Photography And Representation Essay

- Scruton’s Equivalency Thesis In Photography and Representation, Scruton advances the view that photography cannot be described as a representational art form in the same sense as painting, and that the photograph is unworthy of aesthetic appreciation in and of itself. Indeed, Scruton suggests that it is not even possible to have an aesthetic interest in the photograph, as such interest is necessarily directed towards its subject. In this sense, photography is merely a facilitator of seeing. It is no more a representational art form than viewing a scene through a pair of spectacles, or observing an object through a magnifying glass....   [tags: Photography, Art, Aesthetics, Immanuel Kant]

Powerful Essays
1309 words (3.7 pages)

Representation in Music by Roger Scruton and Sound and Semblance by Peter Kivy

- "Representation in Music" by Roger Scruton and "Sound and Semblance" by Peter Kivy Can music represent. Does it matter if it can. Roger Scruton and Peter Kivy tackle these two questions in two articles concerning music’s representational powers: Representation in Music (Scruton) and Sound and Semblance (Kivy). Scruton takes a two-pronged approach to the question of musical representation arguing that 1) music cannot represent things and 2) even if it could, such representation is irrelevant to the appreciation of the music....   [tags: Music Semblance Scruton Kivy Essays]

Powerful Essays
3630 words (10.4 pages)

Music And Morality : An Expository Article That Was Written By Roger Scruton

- Controlled by Music Music and Morality is an expository article that was written by Roger Scruton in 2010. Scruton is a moral philosophy professor at St. Andrews University and has written other works about the subject of music. The purpose of Music and Morality is to inform individuals who listen to music that there are morals behind music. He encourages readers to really listen to the music, and persuades readers that if we stop submitting to the music we will actually find the moral qualities....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Moral, Dance music]

Powerful Essays
904 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on The Advancement of Photography

- People see pictures every day and everywhere. They are in the newspapers, on wall as art, on billboards too. Photographs didn’t exist not long ago but when they were developed they took the world by storm. Nearly 200 years later people have cameras in their phones and can print pictures wirelessly straight from our phones or cameras. The invention of photography was an advancement that not only changed humanities but also changed the world as it evolved. Photography was developed towards the end of Industrial Revolution and the beginning of the Victorian Era....   [tags: Photography]

Powerful Essays
1111 words (3.2 pages)

Roger Ballen: Darkness in Photography Essay

- ... The grief captured within the composition is represented by the boy that seems to be trapped in the wires and the spectator does not know whether he is ultimately trapped or has a chance of escape, since his distorted limbs make it unclear whether he is still with us or not. In addition with the pair of industrial scissors in the corner of the frame, it indicates regardless of the answer to the aforementioned that the boy’s escape is out of reach. (Rafferty 2010: http://www.rochestercitynewspaper.com/rochester/profile-roger-ballen-at-the-george-eastman-house/Content?oid=2125105) Like with a lot of Roger’s work, one can identify with the agony and darkness it represents, you feel the gri...   [tags: art, interpretation, caption]

Powerful Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Photography Is An Art Of Photography Essay

- Today the internet is filled with pictures, they’re all around us. But what most of the world doesn’t realize is that there is a difference between picture-taking and photography. To take a picture, all you have to do is point and shoot. Picture taking has no artistic value. Photography is an art, and like any other kind of art, it takes meticulous practice. Just as anyone can take a picture, though, anyone can learn the art of photography. Here are a few tips and tricks that, along with a little practice, will have you on your way to becoming a master of photography....   [tags: Photography, Photograph, Rule of thirds, Camera]

Powerful Essays
1004 words (2.9 pages)

Use of Photographs in This Is a Photograph of Me and Photograph, 1958 Essay

- Use of Photographs in This Is a Photograph of Me and Photograph, 1958          At first glance, "This Is a Photograph of Me" by Margaret Atwood and "Photograph, 1958" by Patricia Young are strikingly similar works in that both poems utilize the imagery of a photograph as a communication device however, upon closer examination  they differ markedly in the approach each poet takes in utilizing this same device.  The similarities between these two poems are immediately obvious to the reader; both poems are written by female poets,  both poems have the poet as the speaker,  both poems describe how the poet feels about herself, and both poems utilize the photograph as a device to convey their...   [tags: Photograph]

Free Essays
1244 words (3.6 pages)

Essay on Photography

- The Test of Time: The Power of the Photograph What is a photograph. The simplicity of taking a photograph leads many to ponder its artistic value. Yet, it is undeniable that there are some photos that cause an emotional reaction deeper than simply observing a recorded point in time. Surely, there are photographs that cause more reaction than some modern art pieces. There seems to be two types of photographs. The first classification is the ‘time capture’ photo – an image with the sole purpose of recording a particular event or point in time....   [tags: Art Artwork Photograph]

Powerful Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

Photography Essays

- Missing Images Photography wasn’t considered a form of art in the United States until the turn of the century when a man named Alfred Steiglitz fought throughout his lifetime to make sure we recognized it as an art form. It was only used as a form of science up until then. There is a lot of chemistry when it comes to photography; mixing different chemicals for film and paper as well as the four or five different “baths” for each the film and paper. And to know what film to use, which paper and what chemicals will form the best possible images....   [tags: photo picture photograph]

Free Essays
905 words (2.6 pages)