Essay on Research Study And Do A Brief Critique

Essay on Research Study And Do A Brief Critique

Length: 1436 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Identify the parts of the research study and do a brief critique using the questions below. You are carefully examining all aspects of a study to judge its merits, limitations, meaning, and significance, in other words you have to know enough to know: Do I have a gem or a piece of junk? (Read: Grove, et al., 2013, pp. 454-462)

Yes or No answer is not sufficient. You have to justify or explain your answers.
Grade will be based on accuracy and clarity of your answers to the questions.

A. Introduction/PROBLEM identification, statement of PURPOSE and specific
aims (WHY was this study done?) (35%)
1. Was the problem clearly identified with sufficient background to understand
why the research was worth doing?

The problem is that although the nursing profession exists to improve health, nurses have failed the adoption of healthy lifestyles in the United States. Part of the problem is that nurses fail to personally value healthy behaviors. The author emphasizes that nurses have a significant role in promoting heath, but when they fail to live healthy life styles, they may also fail to teach those practices to their patients. Furthermore, nurse’s health and health behaviors have been linked to job performance and retention.

2. Did the investigator clearly state the purpose (or aims, goals, research questions, or
Hypotheses) of the project?

The purpose of this quantitative study was to investigate relationships among health
status, healthy lifestyles, and six dimensions of nurse self-concept of professional nurses.

3. Did the author indicate what knowledge will be generated by the project and
why it is relevant to nursing?

Knew knowledge will be generated about nurses’ (both those who integrate healthy behaviors into the...


... middle of paper ...


...procedures adequately described so that a replication
study could be conducted? Who collected the data?

Data collection was adequately described and a replication study could be conducted. Participants were asked to return the questionnaires directly to the researcher, so the article implies that the researcher himself collected the data.

7. Were the data analysis methods (statistical tests) consistent with the research
Questions, aims, hypotheses and study design?

Yes, data analysis methods (statistical tests) were consistent with the research aims and questions. Only questionnaires that were at least 90% complete were included in the analysis. Data was analyzed using SPSS, version 16, for Windows. Bivariate correlations were used to answer the research questions. Significant relationships were classified as strong (r ≥ .5), medium (r ≥ .3), or weak (r ≥ .1).

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Quantitative Study Article Critique Essay

- Quantitative Study Article Critique This paper is a critique of an article written by McKinney and Jones (1993) entitled: “Effects of a Children’s Book and a Traditional Textbook on Fifth-grade Students’ Achievement and Attitudes toward Social Studies”. In their research the authors examined the effects of a children’s book and a traditional social studies textbook on knowledge acquisition and attitudes toward social studies and the textbook in a sample of 57 fifth-graders. It is the intention of the present paper to develop analytical discussion and the holistic interpretation of the McKinney and Jones’s quantitative study (1993)....   [tags: Children's Books, Text Books, Education]

Better Essays
1238 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on A Perception and Motivation Study Among Married Adults

- Research Article Critique: Forgiveness: A perception and motivation study among married adults Abstract The article is endeavors to observe the possible correlation between general forgiveness (actually forgiving) and perceptions of forgiveness (a belief in the concept). This is a summary analyzing the credibility of the article. The summary includes a brief overview and critique of the title, abstract, literature review, methodology, a review of results and discussion, and possible improvements to the study....   [tags: Research Article Critique]

Better Essays
1631 words (4.7 pages)

Critique of Johnson’s Quantitative Research Article Essay

- An article called “The Use of Music to Promote Sleep in Older Women” was published in the twentieth volume of the Journal of Community Health Nursing in 2003. It was written by Julie E. Johnson, who is the dean and a professor for the College of Nursing at Kent State University in Ohio. She is a registered nurse who holds a PhD and is a member of the FAAN. Being a member of the FAAN suggests that she has contributed to the field of nursing in a positive way. Johnson’s article attempts to find out whether listening to music at bedtime positively affects the sleeping habits of older women suffering from insomnia....   [tags: The Use of Music to Promote Sleep in Older Women]

Better Essays
3451 words (9.9 pages)

Critique of a Study; Muscle Dysmorphia - excellent paper

- Last year a study was performed to examine a model for the development of muscle dysmorhpia among male college athletes. The model is known as the Lantz, Rhea, and Mayhew Model and it describes the relationship between pre-disposing factors for the development of muscle dysmorphia and the negative consequences paired with the disorder. The study concentrated on male college athletes falling into three different categories: weight lifters, non-contact sports athletes, and contact sport athletes....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
1079 words (3.1 pages)

Quantitative Research Report On Dietary Vitamin K Guidance Essay

- Quantitative Research Report Critical Appraisal-Dietary Vitamin K Guidance Researchers use quantitative research approach when they are interested in learning the relationships among variables. A variable is something that is various, including blood pressure, weights, and pain levels. It can be categorized in a different level of measurement: nominal, ordinal, interval, and ratio measurement (Polit & Beck, 2012). Depending on the numbers of variables and groups in a study, researchers can choose a corresponding research design and statistical tests....   [tags: Research, Scientific method, Warfarin]

Better Essays
1388 words (4 pages)

American Girl And The Brand Gestalt : Closing The Loop On Sociocultural Branding Research

- focused on the key qualitative research methods. For each article review, a brief description, guided by Myers (2013), and a critique, guided Pratt (2009), is provided. A summary of the five articles identifying the research method, data collection technique, data analysis approach and critique is provided in Table 1. The narrative review of each article coupled with figures and tables to organize and visualize thoughts (Pratt, 2009) follows the summary table. 1. Journal Article - Reference - Diamond, N., Sherry Jr, J....   [tags: Scientific method, Qualitative research]

Better Essays
1570 words (4.5 pages)

Research Article : An Essential Asset For Nurses With A Bachelor 's Education

- Having the ability to critique a research article is an essential asset for nurses with a bachelor’s education. As a professional nurse, it is vital to be able to recognize and pick apart a good research article. It is part of the nurses’ responsibility to be able to analyze research studies so they can promote new techniques with well-researched evidence. The research article that is being reviewed is explaining the research conducted when bedside nursing report is implemented during shift change....   [tags: Research, Scientific method, Nurse]

Better Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

Critical Review of a Psychology Research Article on Students Essay

- Research Issues in Psychology Critical Review of a Research Article Pupils who exhibit gifted characteristics along with another disability are referred to as ‘twice-exceptional students’ (Morrison, 2001; Nielsen 2002). This term is used in the article that I have chosen to review, which analyzes the responses and perceptions through interview, of one particular individual (Andrew) who was identified as being gifted and talented (G/T) and who had emotional and behavioral disabilities (EBD). What the researchers aimed to accomplish through this analysis was a clearer understanding of Andrew’s community and school experiences, as they stated that there was a lack of empirical data focusing up...   [tags: essays research papers Psychology]

Better Essays
1995 words (5.7 pages)

A Brief History of Aesthetics Essay

- A Brief History of Aesthetics Aesthetics is the theoretical study of the arts and related types of behavior and experience. It is traditionally regarded as a branch of philosophy, concerned with the understanding of beauty and its manifestations in art and nature. However, in the latter 20th century there developed a tendency to treat it as an independent science, concerned with investigating the phenomena of art and its place in human life. Yet, what in a field with a hazy line in between being classified as a science or study of beliefs is considered data for determining what can be studied....   [tags: essays papers]

Better Essays
1442 words (4.1 pages)

Test Critique Essay example

- The Beck Anxiety Inventory was designed by Aaron T. Beck and is self report scale that consists of 21 items. The items are short and straightforward, making it easy to read and comprehend. All items are related to anxiety and describe a symptom of anxiety that is rate on a four point likert scale according to severity. The answers range from 0-3 and the responses range from “not at all” to “severely; I could barely stand it” and all items are added for a total score. The instructions on the test ask for the respondent to “indicate how much you have been bothered by each symptom during the past week, including today, by placing an X in the corresponding space in the column next to each sympto...   [tags: Psychology ]

Better Essays
1012 words (2.9 pages)