Pros and Cons of Using L1 in the Classroom Essay

Pros and Cons of Using L1 in the Classroom Essay

Length: 1173 words (3.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The idea to include L1 as part of the language teaching system has been debated upon in recent years. The strong anti-L1 suggest on a complete prohibition of L1 in classrooms, while many others see L1 as a tool to better students’ learning of the TL. This section will highlight the pros and cons arguments for using the L1 in classrooms, along with further evidence supporting the advantages mother tongue bring to the language learning, and teaching process.

In the twentieth century, the avoidance of the using L1 in classrooms dominated teachers’ minds; as well it was implemented in many policies and guidelines of language teaching (Cook, 2001). Thornbury (2010) listed a set of arguments against using L1 in L2 classrooms mainly for that the translation of L2 into another language will play negative effects on students’ learning process. He pointed out that the use of L1 will result learners to have a cognitive dependence on their mother tongue at the expense of developing independence TL learning. Although the two language systems are not equivalent in many aspects, students may have an awareness of the notion of equivalence of the two languages if translation serves to convey meanings. Some argue that the use of translation to convey the meaning of the TL is more efficient and more memorable. However, Thornbury (2010) sees the opposite. He stated that the simple and direct way of translation will make L2 knowledge less memorable since the process lacks mental efforts in working out meanings.

Many researchers like Krashen (1985), Harmer (2007), and Turnbull (2001) emphasise that in most EFL (English as a foreign language) environment, a teacher’s English proficiency ...

... middle of paper ...

...L1 for instructions and assessments to avoid confusion.

On the other hand, teachers prefer using L1 for a more effective approach to teaching grammar and checking students’ understanding. Macaro (1997) commented that teachers often lack enthusiasm in using the target language for grammar explanation. Many students have difficulty in learning grammar, especially for those whose L1 system is entirely different from the TL. L1 can be more efficient, particularly when a teacher wants to discuss the learning contract with students, or tries to explore the needs of his/her students, especially those in the lower level (Harmer, 2007). Evidence provided by Harmer (2007) also indicates that the classroom environment can be enhanced through the use of L1 to establish a positive social relationship with students, which ultimately leads to a more effective teaching process.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Pros and Cons of Using Social Media Tools in Schools

- Social media has transformed the world. No longer is communication the same. This is evident in the social media by businesses and individuals alike. Businesses build communities, and raise awareness, through the use of social media sites such as Twitter and Facebook. Education system has also adopted social media tools in the classroom and is now playing a significant role in many schools and universities. However, proper planning has to take place to ensure that these tools are managed effectively in the classroom....   [tags: generation z, facebook]

Strong Essays
961 words (2.7 pages)

Pros and Cons of Differentiated Instruction Essay

- Pros of Differentiated Instruction      Differentiated instruction is a way of thinking about teaching and learning. It means using a variety of instructional strategies that address diverse student learning needs. It places students at the center of teaching and learning and student needs drive instructional planning. Differentiated learning is a way to enhance learning for all students by engaging them in activities that respond to particular learning needs, strengths and preferences (Wikipedia, 2002)....   [tags: Education Educational Diversity Essays]

Strong Essays
990 words (2.8 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Teenage Video Game Playing Essay

- (Intro Paragraph) Many people do not believe there are benefits to playing video games. The majority of them are parents of disgruntled teenagers. These kids meet a wall of parental resistance each time they make an effort to get the ban against video gaming lifted in their homes. They have used every typical persuasive technique available to them; including a promise to keep their room clean and free of clutter for the remainder of their life. Kids learn best in the company of trusted adults....   [tags: children, parents, violence]

Strong Essays
1168 words (3.3 pages)

Pros and Cons of Technology in Classrooms Essay

- For years, new technologies have been arising and improving drastically. To some generations technology is nothing but foreign to them. Children these days are so familiar with how to use technology; they almost start to learn after they start walking. So many people are abusing technology by overusing it and even some, becoming addicted. If technology is going to be used, it should have a positive purpose behind it. Throughout the past five years technology has become a main focus in the classroom and schools....   [tags: Teaching, Education, Learning]

Strong Essays
1492 words (4.3 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Using Information Technology in Teaching Essay example

- The Advantages and Disadvantages of Using Information Technology in Teaching The most obvious advantage of using information technology in teaching and learning is the flexibility for learners to get access to computers. Now that computers have become common, learners can get access to the Internet and engage in study at any time, any place and at their own pace. This is the reason why distance learning has become so common nowadays. Another advantage of information technology is its versatility....   [tags: Economics]

Strong Essays
575 words (1.6 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Childcare Essay example

- Childcare has become an essential tool in an ever-changing and growing society. The cost of living in Canada has increased, and society has adapted; women have joined the work-force, and dual income families are necessary to retain a decent standard of living. Hence, there is a demand for adequate childcare. By enrolling a child into a childcare program, there are many benefits, such as allowing parents, single or not, to continue their careers and/or attend school, as well as provide children with a developmental and educational foundation that will benefit them later on in life....   [tags: Child Development ]

Strong Essays
2106 words (6 pages)

Pros And Cons Of Standardized Testing Essays

- The United States recognizes that standardized testing is a central part of the educational system in our country. What many people do not know though is the history of where it came from. Beginning in the mid-1800’s prestigious universities decided they wanted to give more students across the country a better chance at going into higher education, but at the time there was not a way to measure the capabilities of students in both high class and low class families. This is how standardized testing came into play....   [tags: Standardized Testing Essays]

Strong Essays
1925 words (5.5 pages)

Integrating Technology in the classroom Essay

- Technology has exploded and it has landed everywhere. Daily computers help to accomplish job-related task more efficiently (Shelly, 2010). It has even affected the method in which lessons are being translated in the classroom. This writer will take a vivid look at ways in which technology can be used to facilitate and enhance instructions in the classroom. A glimpse will be taken upon the differences between wired and unwired classrooms. Lastly, the pros and cons of using technology will also be taken into consideration....   [tags: Technology, Email, Class]

Strong Essays
678 words (1.9 pages)

The Pros and Cons of Homeschooling Essay

- All children in America have the right to a quality education. Most students receive that education through conventional means, going to a public or private school. There is another option for today's children, home schooling. Home schooling is a controversial issue. While it does have its benefits, some people believe it has too many downfalls to be an effective method of education. In this paper, topics such as academic impact, social impact, and parental opinions of home schooling will be discussed....   [tags: Pro Con Essays]

Strong Essays
2520 words (7.2 pages)

Essay on We Need Calculators in the Classroom

- We Need Calculators in the Classroom Technology has become a huge part of our lives and our society. Almost everything we use involves the use of computers. In the past few years, technology has been improved and updated which has made our lives easier and more efficient making us more advanced than the rest of the world. I strongly believe in having calculators in the classroom because it teaches children to expand their knowledge of math and science at a very young age. It can give students a variety of ways to look at problems and at the same time expand their knowledge in the subject....   [tags: Teaching Education]

Strong Essays
1276 words (3.6 pages)