The Partition Plan For Palestine Essay

The Partition Plan For Palestine Essay

Length: 1316 words (3.8 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The partition plan for Palestine that was adopted by the UN in 1947 was disastrous; rather than solving the conflict, it exacerbated the problem. This partition plan created a massive refugee crisis, the loss of Palestinian Arab identity, ongoing war between Israel and the Arab states, and tremendous political instability in the Middle East. Essentially, the partition plan should have never been enacted. Instead, a plan which joined both sides in a common goal and allowed all parties to maintain political power should have been implemented. A modified version of the 1947 proposal for a federal solution would have decreased the future violence in the conflict because it would have balanced the power dynamics by giving both Palestinian Arabs and the Jewish population agency, and it would have forced the two groups to cooperate in order to help their shared nation succeed.
By enacting the federal solution, there would have been less fighting because the Jews and the Palestinian Arabs would have been forced to work together to establish a functioning government. The minority plan that was proposed in 1947 suggested the creation of an Arab state and a Jewish state, and an overall federal government in charge of “‘national defense, foreign relations, and immigration’” (Ginat 204). In a modified version of this plan, there would be multiple states for each group in order to ensure that the power would not culminate in only one state, or with only one group. The federal system of government would guarantee local autonomy for the states, so that their respective populations could have political power over their own lives with regards to domestic affairs. Foreign policy and national defense should be shared between the Jews and the Arabs, ...

... middle of paper ...

...d have the ability to self-govern their local affairs in a federal system. On the international level, they would be forced to work together in order to establish a successful nation. There would undoubtedly be conflict, but it could probably be solved in a more diplomatic manner. Yet, the federal solution was never enacted, and now it is too late. After years of ongoing conflict between Israel and other Arab nations (and later Palestine), there is little hope for the unification of Jews and Arabs in Palestine. The partition plan created disparities and divisions between the Jews and the Arabs, and these walls solidified as the conflict continued. Currently, it would be difficult to integrate Palestine and Israel, so there needs to be a new solution to the conflict. A solution that will respect the rights of everyone involved, and that will finally end the violence.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about Conflict for a Religious Homeland: The Partition of Israel/ Palestine

- The conflict between Jews and Arabs in Palestine was a significant problem for Britain because of the agreement made to both peoples before 1920. Britain assured both groups that the territory of Jerusalem would be given to them and that they would have a choice in their government. The promises conflicted with each other so Britain decided on enabling the United Nations to determine the territorial future of the two ethnicities, thus creating the UN Partition Plan. The UN Partition Plan would ultimately cause more conflict than intended; this can be exemplified by the immediate choice for the Arabs to initiate a jihad and the population resettlement of the Palestinians....   [tags: jews, arabs, jerusalem]

Better Essays
897 words (2.6 pages)

The Conflict Of The Israeli Palestine Conflict Essay

- The Israeli-Palestine conflict is an event that has been well documented throughout the course of Middle-Eastern history. The conflict dates back as far as the nineteenth century where Palestine and Zionist, will later be known as Israel, are two communities each with different ideologies had the same overwhelming desire to acquire land. However, what makes this clash what it is, is the fact that both of these up and coming communities are after the same piece of land. The lengths that both sides went to in order obtain they believed was theirs has shaped the current relationship between the two nations today....   [tags: Israel, Zionism, Six-Day War, Syria]

Better Essays
737 words (2.1 pages)

The Israel and Palestine Conflict Essay

- The Israel and Palestinian conflict has been going on for over a century now; it consisted of five wars since 1948. That isn’t counting the dozen of battles, raids, and skirmishes that also have taken place, all this for a piece of land. The Israel and Palestinians conflict was a fight over territory, and believed they had claim of the territory for an extremely long time. The territory is in Western Asia between both the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea, and is surrounded by Arabia, Syria, and Egypt....   [tags: land, religion, conflict, culture]

Better Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)

The Israeli Palestinian Conflict Of Palestine Essay

- Palestine is an area in the Middle East bounded to the west by the Mediterranean, to the north by Lebanon, to the south by the Sinai Desert, and to the east by the Jordan River (Israeli-Palestinian). It is occupied at present by two peoples or national groups, Israelis and Palestinians. Israel is a democratic republic that identifies itself as a Jewish state. Israel was founded in 1948. The term, Palestinians, denotes people whose place of recent-ancestral origin is Palestine before it was occupied by Israel in 1967....   [tags: Israel, West Bank, Second Intifada]

Better Essays
1482 words (4.2 pages)

Arab Refugee Crisis : Palestine Essay

- Arab Refugee Crisis During the Israeli War of Independence in 1948 an Arab refugee crisis began, and there is still not a clear answer of what caused it. As inhabitants of Israel Arabs were greatly affected by the establishment of a Jewish State, because their home was governed by others. Nonetheless, the Palestinian Arabs contributed in the making of the refugee crisis. The Arabs were given the choice of becoming equal citizens of Israel and refused. The United Nations came up with Partition Plan for Palestine, but it was rejected....   [tags: Israel, Jordan, Egypt, Gaza Strip]

Better Essays
1486 words (4.2 pages)

Essay about Israeli Palestinian Conflict

- The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict is a never ending fight over land in which both sides believe is theirs. Because of past historical events, there is a lot of confusion about whose land it really is. There have been thousands of lives both soldiers and civilians on both sides lost in the continuous fighting over this land. The Israelis and Palestinians have been fighting since around 1880 for the land which was formerly known as Palestine(jewish). After the Balfour Declaration the Jewish people started migrating into Palestine and the Arabs currently living in Palestine were extremely against the Jewish immigration....   [tags: historical events, partition plan]

Better Essays
1022 words (2.9 pages)

The Israel-Palestine Conflict Essay

- Why can’t there be peace. What prevents humans from having a lasting, worldwide peace. The answer can be found in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Jews in Europe sought a piece of land where they would be safe from persecution, and they desired it to be in Palestine, to the distaste of the Palestinians who had already been living there. The chance for unwavering peace between the Israel and Palestine has diminished since the start of the struggle between them, and at this point in time peace is only a dream that will never become a reality....   [tags: Peace, States, War]

Better Essays
1076 words (3.1 pages)

The Palestine Refugee Problem Essay example

- The Palestine refugee problem was created in the course of the 1948 Israeli War of Independence. When the UN voted to partition Palestine into Jewish and Arab states in 1947, Palestinian Arabs and Jews opposed the plan. The war that ensued was won by Israel, creating a large number of Arab refugees. Estimates account for more than 700,000 Palestinian Arabs who fled or were forced out of their homes during the fighting. These refugees often fled to surrounding Arab countries such as Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Egypt....   [tags: War Refugees Essays]

Free Essays
1810 words (5.2 pages)

Partition Literature of India Essays

- The Partition of India "A moment comes, which comes but rarely in history, when we step out from the old to the new, when an age ends, and when the soul of a nation, long suppressed, finds utterance." -Jawarhalal Nehru 14 August, 1947, saw the birth of the new Islamic Republic of Pakistan. At midnight the next day India won its freedom from colonial rule, ending nearly 350 years of British presence in India. During the struggle for freedom, Gandhi had written an appeal "To Every Briton" to free their possessions in Asia and Africa, especially India (Philips and Wainwright, 567)....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
2069 words (5.9 pages)

Palestine and Israel Essays

- Background The issue of Palestine and Israel is one that has been hotly contested for over a thousand years. The last fifty years have been especially important in the history of the Jewish people and Palestinians. Since the death of Yasser Arafat on the 11th of November 2004 , and the election of Mahmoud Abbas as his successor as leader of the Palestinian Authority, significant steps have been taken towards a lasting peace. This will hopefully lead to a conclusion of the second Palestinian intifada, which began in late September 2000, and to an end of the oppression of the Palestinian people by the Israeli Defense Forces....   [tags: Threats to World Peace]

Better Essays
3682 words (10.5 pages)