Northern Lights and Swallows and Amazons Essay

Northern Lights and Swallows and Amazons Essay

Length: 1983 words (5.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Rudd’s (2009) essay evaluates Enid Blyton’s work offering a different perspective to account for the appeal and popularity of the author. This essay looks at the aspects raised by Rudd. How Blyton, Pullman and Ransom illustrate the different aspects of a good or a bad book. The way critics confer prestige on a book or author and the arising criticism. How the agenda of the committees affects the selection of prize-winners. Finally, looking at the factors involved in success.
The set books used in his essay are Pullman (1995) Northern Lights and Ransom (2001) Swallows and Amazons.
Critics view the books by Pullman and Ransom as examples of literary excellence. In order to evaluate this opinion it is necessary to discuss what aspects critics consider contribute to a good book and how these books illustrate them. The American Library Associate (ALA) uses the term ‘edubrow’ (Kidd, (2009) p158) to mean the middle ground of literature with an educational emphasis. This emphasis is at the centre of the criteria for a good book by increasing the experiences of the reader through varied language, dynamic themes, rounded characterisation with comprehensive plots. The critics favour works that involve the reader in a non-passive manner to gain insights into universal aspects of human existence like love, identity, revenge, sexuality and betrayal.
Pullman has written a basic adventure story laced with multiple themes, metaphors and ideas. He uses intertextuality to enrich his text and enhance his ideas and arguments (Squires, 2009). His novel is mainly a critique of the theology surrounding the Judaeo-Christian myth of the Fall where the gaining of experience replaces the loss of innocence. He compares this idea with the journey of his m...

... middle of paper ... created controversy where his books are studied and dissected by academics. He is outspoken and interacts with critics about the themes in his book, which are the antithesis of C.S Lewis Narnia series. Controversy and debate are forms of creating interest in a book that send sales soaring. Everyone wants to read the book that is creating such a furore.
In conclusion, critical evaluation of what makes a book good or bad depends on the selection criteria and agenda of those making the evaluation. The prizes have been criticised through the years and the selection committees have risen to this by changing the selection process, even if this change has been slow. Children’s Literature is in flux due to the ever-changing ideas and perceptions of childhood. Children’s books seen as prestigious today may become, like Blyton, unpalatable to the critics of tomorrow.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Themes of Philip Pullman's Northern Lights Essay

- “Northern Lights deals with large themes; love, betrayal, religion and science” Discuss Northern Lights deals with the forces of love, betrayal, religion and science; all of these themes spur from one source, power. Each character in the novel experiences these topics, because each character is powerful. Northern Lights shows us that all individuals must either choose to use or be overcome these forces. Ever since the dawn of time, love has been a fundamental part of every human’s lives. Northern Lights demonstrates to us that the love of a friend or the love of spouse can create either great power or bring misery and unhappiness....   [tags: Northern Lights Essays]

Free Essays
812 words (2.3 pages)

The Dancing Lights in the Northern Hemisphere Essay

- The Dancing Lights Auroras have been emitting in our, and other planets’ skies as long as the Solar System has been in motion. In 1619 A.D., Galileo Galilei coined the term "aurora borealis" after Aurora, the Roman goddess of morning. He had the misconception that the auroras he saw were due to sunlight reflecting from the atmosphere. (Angelopoulos, 2008). In 1741, Hiorter and Celsius noted that the polar aurora is accompanied by a disturbance of the magnetic needle. In 1820, Hans Christian Oersted discovered electromagnetism....   [tags: the aurora borealis]

Strong Essays
530 words (1.5 pages)

The Northern Lights Essay

- The Northern lights are poetry, they are nature's light show, and they are quantum leaps in the oxygen atom. They are elementary particle physics, superstition, mythology and fairy tales. The northern lights have filled people with wonder and inspired artists; they have frightened people to think that the end is at hand. More exact explanations of the phenomenon could not be given until modern particle physics were developed, and knowledge about details in the earth’s magneto sphere has been based on measurements from satellites....   [tags: essays research papers fc]

Strong Essays
2024 words (5.8 pages)

The Northern Lights Essay

- The Northern Lights I hardly see how one can begin to consider Shakespeare without finding some way to account for his pervasive presence in the most unlikely contexts: here, there, and everywhere at once. He is a system of northern lights, an aurora borealis visible where most of us will never go. Libraries and playhouses (and cinemas) cannot contain him; he has become a spirit or "spell of light," almost too vast to apprehend. Harold Bloom, Shakespeare: The Invention of the Human I don’t expect this short paper to reach the northern lights....   [tags: Plays Literature Shakespeare Papers]

Strong Essays
2807 words (8 pages)

A Book Review on Northern Lights Essay

- A Book Review on Northern Lights Northern Lights is an adventure and a fantasy story written by Phillip Pullman in the third person. The story takes place in Jordan College, which is in Oxford. The Master rules Jordan College and the other place is in the North. In the North, armoured bears rule the ice and witches fly in the skies. These places are in another world than that we live in. In this world, people have daemons, a sort of pet, which is attached to them by an invisible force. Daemons can also change into different animals....   [tags: English Literature]

Free Essays
681 words (1.9 pages)

Descriptive Essay : ' Enchanted Northern Lights Of Iceland '

- The world is a huge 510 Million Km² adventure land, with fountains higher than the tallest skyscrapers and caves darker than darkness as we know it. There are 196 countries in the world, with cultures, ethnicities and terrestrial characteristics so diverse within each one of them that it’s almost impossible to comprehend all of it. It’s heart quenching that there is so much to experience in the world in just one life. If you are one of them who feels awaken by the smell of adventure and have an addiction for adrenaline, then this is the perfect list of five unquestionable experiences that will not only make your life worthy but also awaken a new of consciousness and understanding of earthly...   [tags: Ancient Egypt, Egypt, Sky, Bora Bora]

Strong Essays
795 words (2.3 pages)

Summary of "the Swallows of Kabul" Essay examples

- First of all, in chapter five, Atiq went to the mosque for the Isha Prayer. Then, he left and wandered around the city. Unknowingly, he arrived at the jailhouse. He decided to spend the night there. So, he lit up the lamp and lied down. Suddenly, he got scared to see Nazeesh behind him. As you can see, Atiq met Nazeesh a decade ago, when he was a mufti in Kabul. Then, Nazeesh told the sad story of his old father. He also told him that he wanted to die by walking into the ocean. He was describing the way of his coming death for a long time....   [tags: Swallows of Kabul, summary, summaries,]

Strong Essays
510 words (1.5 pages)

Analysis of Northern Lights by Philip Pullman Essay

- Analysis of Northern Lights by Philip Pullman Philip Pullman’s novel, Northern Lights, offers an impressive alternative reality which has similarities with the present day, and differences too. The story starts in Jordan College in Oxford but it is an Oxford unlike ours: the technology and the culture of the people give the impression that it is set in the late 19th century. It is a fundamentally different universe in several respects - most evidently, all humans have dæmons....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1411 words (4 pages)

Book Review of Northern Lights by Philip Pullman Essay example

- Book Review of Northern Lights by Philip Pullman Works Cited Missing This week I chose to read the novel "Northern Lights" by Philip Pullman. Philip Pullman was born in Norwich on 19th October 1946. The early part of his life was spent travelling all over the world, because his father and then his step father were both in the Royal Air Force. He spent part of his childhood in Australia, where he first met the wonders of comics, and grew to love Superman and Batman in particular....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
1487 words (4.2 pages)

Amazons Fulfilment Essay

- Amazons Fulfilment Is Amazon a bubble waiting to burst. The following discussions in this research paper will explore several key issues from its birth to its debatable future. Amazon is not a stranger to arguments revolving around questions of its longevity and success. When the systemic bubble of 1999 arrived Amazon’s corporate goal was to get big, to do it fast, and to establish a hold of new markets before any other competitor. During this time frame Amazon began branching out and selling anything and everything....   [tags: Jeff Bezos,, bubble]

Strong Essays
2973 words (8.5 pages)