New York Times Co V. United States Essay

New York Times Co V. United States Essay

Length: 1614 words (4.6 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

On 30 June, 1971 it was decided by the Supreme Court to rule against the President of the United States and the Executive government in the infamous case, New York Times Co. v United States. This six to three ruling by the Supreme Court justices was one of the few times in history when the court ruled against the government of the United States in favor of a major corporation. Because of this, to this day, New York Times Co v United States remains one of the most influential and controversial cases that the Supreme Court has ever seen. Although this case did not cause a shift in power from the federal to state governments, it did cause a flow away from the Executive Branch. The ruling in favor of the New York Times proved that the Executive government and specifically the President of the United States could not simply call for a retrieval of information just because they did not like what was becoming public. Along with this, because of the public being able to read the Pentagon Papers and understand the political-military activities that the government condoned during the Vietnam War, the two administrations, both during the war and in 1971, took a significant amount of criticism from the public.
Officially titled “United States – Vietnam Relations, 1945-1967: A study prepared by the Department of Defense,” the Pentagon Papers are a history of the Department of Defense’s political-military activity and involvement in Vietnam throughout the war (2). Specifically, the 2.5 million word document revealed the public that the United States covertly enlarged the actual scale of the Vietnam War by bombing Cambodia and Laos and raiding North Vietnam with Marines. None of these military operations were reported to the media, which...

... middle of paper ...

...r of the Times and the Post, it showed the American public that even the Executive Branch and specifically the President of the United States could not simply retrieve information from an individual or corporation because they did not agree with the publication of it. Even the most powerful man in the free world could not call for an executive order and overrule an average citizen. Because Ellsberg was found not guilty under Espionage Act of 1917, the entire American public realized that their First Amendment rights truly were protected under the Constitution and no one could take that away from them, not even their own government. The ruling in favor of the Times and the Post cleared the path for other newspapers and websites to release the study, without the fear of having the government try to take control of companies and deny them their freedom of the press.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay about New York Times Co. versus United States: The Security of Secrets

- In the Supreme Court case of the New York Times Co. vs. United States there is a power struggle. This struggle includes the entities of the individual freedoms against the interests of federal government. It is well known that the first amendment protects the freedom of speech, but to what extent does this freedom exist. There have been instances in which speech has been limited; Schenck vs. United States(1919) was the landmark case which instituted such limitations due to circumstances of “clear and present danger”....   [tags: freedom, federal government, Supreme Court]

Strong Essays
1965 words (5.6 pages)

Recruitment And The Draft During The Vietnam War Essay

- Recruitment and the draft during the Vietnam War was a topic few Americans knew a lot about but was a specialty of Hanson W. Baldwin, a military writer for The New York Times. “U.S. combat forces spread thin” was an article Baldwin wrote on February 21, 1966 and it describes the issues of sparse supplies during the Vietnam War. Baldwin’s niche was to write about challenges faced for military personnel and two other articles further educated Americans on dire supplies during the Vietnam War. These two articles, “Military Personnel Problems Growing as U.S....   [tags: United States, Vietnam War, The New York Times]

Strong Essays
2167 words (6.2 pages)

The New York Times And The Civil Rights Movement Essay

- Background In 1960, the New York Times(Defendant) ran a full-page advertisement paid for by civil right activists. The ad openly criticized the police department in the city of Montgomery, Alabama for its treatment of civil rights protestors. The Plaintiff ( Sullivan) was one of three Commissioners of Montgomery, Alabama, who claimed that he was defamed in a full-page ad taken out in the New York Times. The advertisement was entitled, “Heed Their Rising Voices” and it charged in part that an unprecedented wave of terror had been directed against those who participated in the civil rights movement in the South (Jones, 2016)....   [tags: Newspaper, The New York Times, Advertising]

Strong Essays
2264 words (6.5 pages)

Analysis Of Carl Schurz 's ' The New York Times ' Essay

- In 1863, the New York Times published an article discussing the similarity and dissimilarity between the United States of America and the Confederate States of Germany. It states that Germans are warlike people and “fully appreciate the blessings of freedom and equality enjoyed here, where labor does not degrade one to white Slavery. They found here what they sought for in vain in Europe – freedom.”10 One of the most famous Germans in the Civil War was Carl Schurz. He was involved in the German revolutionary movement of 1848 and migrated to America for freedom....   [tags: United States, American Civil War]

Strong Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Immigration Of The Medi The New York Times Essay

- Immigration in the Media The New York Times - Immigrants Eager to Vote Obeyed All the Rules. It Didn’t Pay. On September 30, 2016, a New York Times article titled, “Immigrants Eager to Vote Obeyed All the Rules. It Didn’t Pay,” provides a narrative of immigrants who are striving to become a recognized member of the society by becoming legal citizens (Preston, 2016). Their aspiration to become legal citizens is motivated by the upcoming election and their desire to vote (Preston, 2016). Unfortunately the legalization process is experiencing a backlog and is taking longer than the typical seven months to complete (Preston, 2016)....   [tags: United States, President of the United States]

Strong Essays
1120 words (3.2 pages)

Essay about The New York Times Dialect Survey

- After taking the New York Times Dialect Survey, my results showed my dialect was most similar in the western area of the United States, partly similar for the central, and least similar in the southern regions of the U.S. My map indicated the three most similar cities compared to my language are all closely located in Las Vegas/North Las Vegas, Sunrise Manor, and Henderson, Nevada. Although, my least similar cities were from the southern states of America in Jackson, Little Rock and Shreveport. When the map was compared to my most similar dialect and the United States as a whole, it showed my dialect was heavily used in the Pacific region states....   [tags: United States, Southern United States]

Strong Essays
901 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Analysis Of The New York Times Magazine

- Appiah, Kwame. “Is It O.K. to Get a Dog From a Breeder, Not a Shelter?” The New York Times Magazine (15 May 2016): 28. Literature Resource Center. EBSCO. Web. Accessed 12 Oct. 2016 This source features a report about the authors opinion on if it’s okay to get a dog from a breeder or a shelter. Appiah feels that breeders and shelters should benefit from the selling of dogs by following the laws and policies that are in place and that when you adopt a shelter dog it died or runs away it should be replaced with another, which would make the shelter emptier....   [tags: Dog, Pet, Dogs, United States]

Strong Essays
765 words (2.2 pages)

The New York Times By Damien Cave And Julie Hirschfeld Essay

- Globalization includes the concept of how countries interact and form relationships. The better the relationship, the more likely they are to share ideas and cultural beliefs. The New York Times published an article on March 21, 2016 titled, “As Obama Arrives, Cuba Tightens Grip on Dissent” by Damien Cave and Julie Hirschfeld. This article speaks about President Obama’s trip to Cuba where he met and spoke with the people of Cuba in hopes of building a relationship between their nation and the United States in hopes of eliminating hostility that was built up over the course of many years....   [tags: President of the United States, United States]

Strong Essays
798 words (2.3 pages)

Analysis Of The New York Times By John Harwood Essay

- This analysis is about an article in The New York Times “For Solution to Income Stagnation, Republicans and Democrats Revise Their Playbooks” by John Harwood. Harwood is an American journalist who is chief of Washington Correspondent for CNBC. In his article, Harwood argues that in order to solve the “Income Stagnation,” both Left and Right parties have to come up with new strategies. Harwood starts his article by making a very “hardwood” remark: “the United States economy is like a football team that cannot move the ball, and has not been able to for 30 years.” Now that is a really nice hook to the article because America is known for its military power around the globe, but few people kno...   [tags: United States, Economy of the United States]

Strong Essays
1105 words (3.2 pages)

Hitler Riding A Lightning Bolt With The Description Of The New York Times

- “GERMAN ARMY ATTACKS POLAND!” This was the top headline of The New York Times on September 1st, 1939. A week later, cartoonist Daniel Robert Fitzpatrick published a cartoon of Hitler riding a lightning bolt with the description of “lightning war.” By September 25th, TIME magazine released an article called Blitzkrieger, which reflected on the success of Generaloberst Walther von Brauchitsch’s invasion of Poland and his “Blitzkrieg” tactics. Americans in 1939 were not immune to the fallout of geopolitical events happening on the other side of the globe....   [tags: World War II, Nazi Germany, United States]

Strong Essays
745 words (2.1 pages)