The Movie ' The Trouble With Dying ' Essay

The Movie ' The Trouble With Dying ' Essay

Length: 1281 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Art of Dying

“Whether he is 19, 5 or 92, you can assume every dying person knows what is best.”-Joy Ufema Registered Nurse and Thanatologist.
Suicide, assisted suicide, passive euthanasia, physician-assisted suicide, assisted-dying there are a plethora of terms used to describe essentially the same event. The death of a person is a cultural rite of passage, passage literally out of this realm and depending on your beliefs, into another realm or nothingness. But in the case of assisted suicide or euthanasia it is regarded as a cultural taboo which has and continues to morph based on how a culture views the act of suicide, is it an act of killing or of dying. The documentary film The Trouble with Dying, directed by Ken Simpson depicts two women who are dying and asking for the right to assisted suicide in Canada. The film is discussing not only assisted-suicide in regard to the Canadian Legal system, but it is much more than a legal issue for many people in the world, it is about the freedom to choose the right to die with dignity. An analysis of this documentary, as well as other films and media, helps to clarify the arguments both for and against the cultural taboo known as assisted suicide, yet the essential question is, is assisted suicide killing or dying?
In order to discuss the current view of assisted suicide one must be familiar with the history and definition of suicide as a taboo. The cultural taboo known as suicide has morphed over the last 5 millennia. For the majority of Western history suicide was actually accepted, for example in ancient Greece, it was described as “to grasp death,” “to die voluntarily,” or “to die by one’s own hand” whereas in later Roman culture suicide resided in a “grey area” because the...


... middle of paper ...


... “Who was it for you?” This is a correct assumption on Good’s part knowing that most people ignore the issue of assisted suicide or continue to view it as taboo if they have not been directly affected by it.
In this analysis of the use of visuals and text to interpret the taboo of suicide and the current debate over assisted suicide, there are many examples to support the idea that if one can humanize death by suicide or assisted suicide this could create the avenue to change public perception. The perception of suicide being a mode of reaching death by killing or a mode of death used to end the suffering of another person as a mode of dying. The artistic value of the films and documentaries discussed go beyond the political, medical and social debate to reveal the so-called taboo of assisted suicide as part of the overall human condition.
























Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

A Lesson before Dying by Ernest J. Gaines Essay

- A Lesson before Dying, one of Ernest J. Gaines later works, was written in 1993. Some of his earlier works include A Gathering of Old Men and In My Father’s House. The novel covers a time period when blacks were still treated unfairly and looked down upon. Jefferson, a main character, has been wrongly accused of a crime and awaits his execution in jail. Grant, the story’s main protagonist must find it within himself to help Jefferson see that he is a man, which will allow him to walk bravely to his fate that lies in the execution chair....   [tags: A Lesson before Dying Ernest J. Gaines Essays]

Better Essays
1988 words (5.7 pages)

Comparsion of Book and Movie of Hound of the Baskervilles by Arthur Doyle

- Between the book and the movie I prefer the movie. My reasoning for this is that the movie seemed much more interesting to me. It made much more sense. I also love who they chose to play the characters in the movie. Seemed much more interesting than the ones that were in the book. I must admit that the book was pretty good, though some of it I found rather boring. One thing I did not like about the movie is that they changed or added some details into the movie that the book did not have. The ending of the movie was much better then the ending in the book....   [tags: setting, book, movie, character]

Better Essays
564 words (1.6 pages)

Movie Analysis : Tokyo Godfather Essay

- Humans of every gender, sexual orientation, and age have struggles through their life. Some humans prefer to avoid the struggles and the mistakes they have committed through their life’s which involve their love ones, to the extent they prefer leaving their home and becoming homeless. This is the case in the movie Tokyo Godfather where three individuals are homeless one being a middle age man by the name of Gin, another a middle age man who is a drag queen and likes to be refer as Hana, and a runaway teenager by the name of Miyuki....   [tags: Family, Mother, Father, Want]

Better Essays
1086 words (3.1 pages)

The Ground-breaking Movie, Philadelphia Essay

- The movie Philadelphia portrays the struggles and eventual passing of Tom Hanks’ character Andrew Beckett as he battles AIDS. According to the textbook, “Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome is caused by the human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), which destroys the body’s immune system” (Santrock, 2009). Andrew faces problems not only with his contraction of AIDS, but also with society’s ignorance of the disability. Throughout the movie, instances of prejudice and discrimination can be seen but are ultimately overcome....   [tags: Film Analysis]

Better Essays
1626 words (4.6 pages)

Essay on Movie Review: What Rambo Means

- Movie Review: What Rambo Means In his modern installment of the Rambo series, Sylvester Stallone brings a new twist on a familiar story. John Rambo is caught up in a struggle between both an easily identifiable enemy and himself. The Burmese military proves easy to vanquish while the battle with his own morals seem far more formidable. His prior experiences have led him to believe that war will always cause trouble and that trying to eradicate it is futile. When he observes the efforts of the American missionaries, Rambo eventually realizes that one should never give in and always continue the fight....   [tags: Film Review ]

Better Essays
930 words (2.7 pages)

Is the Book Always Better than the Movie? Essay

- A Patch of Gray There is an adage that is frequently referred to which states a picture is worth a thousand words. Often people do not consider the converse: if a thousand words are worth a picture. In another manner of speaking, is it possible for an author to be capable of producing a work that is effective in immersing a person in a complicated and detailed world. Unless it is a nonfictional account, it takes great writing skills to transport the reader into a setting while also providing clear aspects that strike out and provide a lasting impact....   [tags: John Howard Griffin, Elizabeth Kata]

Better Essays
1762 words (5 pages)

Many Leaders Around Us: Whale Rider Essay

- A young girl named Paikea once said, “In the old days, the land felt a great emptiness. It was waiting. Waiting to be filled. Waiting for someone to love it. Waiting for a leader” (Whale Rider). As seen in the eyes of Paikea, a leader is a guide, someone who guides his or her people in the right directions, someone who does all he or she can do to improve his or her land. In the eyes of Antigone, princess of Thebes, the rules of the leader only seem right when she feels they don’t contradict with the rules of the gods....   [tags: Paikea, movie character analysis]

Better Essays
948 words (2.7 pages)

How The Movie A Few Good Men And The Play Antigone Found Honor In What Essay

- It is not uncommon for the Civil Law to conflict with Honor. This means that the laws of people, jobs, countries, and duties usually establish a problem with the glory, or respect of people and their self-will, because there are different views of something on each side. This statement is true because many aspects of life involve standing up for what you believe in, while going against the laws of what you have to follow, even though the civil people don’t have any patience for any excuses. In the play Antigone by Sophicles, and the movie A Few Good Men, by Aaron Sorkin, Antigone, Dawson and Downy stand up for what they think is right at that moment, and go against the laws they were to fol...   [tags: essays research papers]

Better Essays
1071 words (3.1 pages)

Why Doctors Have Trouble Communicating With Dying Patients Essay example

- Communication and Death There is one word that most doctors hate: death. Many doctors will even go great lengths to avoid it. While no one likes delivering bad news, many would think that physicians have mastered it. Yet, in a recent study of doctors whose patients were dying, only 11% said they personally spoke with their patients about the possibility of death. (Patrick). In her book, Final Exam Pauline Chen, a surgeon specializing in liver transplants, shares some of her experiences focusing on the troubled relationship between modern medical practice and death....   [tags: Medicine, Physician, Medical school, Death]

Better Essays
812 words (2.3 pages)

Essay on John Q, Directed by Nick Cassavettes

- John Q, Directed by Nick Cassavettes Question: Feature films can reinforce and/or question what is important to society at particular times. Discuss how John Q performs one or both of these social functions. Society is constantly changing to make the world a better place to live in. This is why we need to be informed regularly of the issues we have in the world. A lot of issues are not really being discussed in print media therefore these issues are presented to the society through other mediums such as films, documentaries and even television series....   [tags: John Q. Films Movies Film Movie]

Better Essays
1615 words (4.6 pages)