Essay about Motives Behind the Moors' Murders Ian Brady and Myra Hindley

Essay about Motives Behind the Moors' Murders Ian Brady and Myra Hindley

Length: 1714 words (4.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

What conclusions do these arguments lead to?
Was Brady’s childhood an adequate factor?
I found that Garavelli and Stanford’s investigation were the best sources. I based this judgement on reliability and the context of these sources. Although, Harrison provides a non-judgemental approach; his investigation was relatively new. His investigation does not have the benefit of hindsight, therefore he was not able to use a greater range of evidence to strengthen his argument. Whereas, Garavelli and Stanford had decades to improve their analyses with new evidence that came to light. Brady was brought to trial once again during the time that Garavelli and Stanford’s investigations were produced. How is this relevant to his childhood? It is relevant because the knowledge of psychology have advanced that enabled Garavelli and Stanford to judge properly, whether Brady’s isolated childhood was a prominent factor. Whilst, Harrison did not have that luxury. His work was produced when knowledge of psychology were limited, something he had admitted. There was an “inadequate state of psychiatric knowledge” .
Was Brady always psychopathic?
It was more difficult to evaluate the sources that judged whether Ian Brady was schizophrenic because all sources appear that this may be the case.
Nevertheless, I was impressed by Harrison’s in-depth detail. It is often that a criminal may suffer from a mental health illness; it explains their behavioural patterns. Harrison does not assume that Brady was schizophrenic immediately, instead he leads into this by exploring aspects of life that may have been the slow progression into schizophrenia. Although, Harrison provided incredible detail; he is not a psychologist. Therefore, his analysis lacks specialis...

... middle of paper ... impact on his motivations?
Myra Hindley was a complicated person to evaluate, as there is little explicit evidence to presuppose that this transformation was inevitable. However, Harrison’s “Folie a Deux” argument is the strongest. I cannot deny that the introduction to destructive interests, such as “Anti-Semitic literature” will have played a powerful part. Nevertheless, it seems that all this may have been elements of “Folie a Deux”. Though, this section has been focused on Hindley, it exhibits how vital Hindley’s transformation had been for Brady’s nature. Previously, I had claimed that Stanford’s conclusion about their “us-against-the-world paranoia” was too simplistic…the “Folie a Deux” argument gives good grounds why this paranoia may have developed. The psychiatric syndrome “Folie a Deux” may have been a fundamental fragment in Brady’s criminal nature

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Essay

- Ian Buruma's Behind the Mask Ian Buruma was born in the Netherlands in 1951. He went to school in both Holland and Japan, and he has spent a great deal of time in Japan. Ian Buruma is an author, journalist and a professor at Bard College in New York. He sometimes writes for the New York Review of Books, the New York Times Magazine, the New Republic, the New Yorker, and the Guardian. The book, Behind the Mask, was a very interesting one. This book is filled with lots of Japans history that most people know nothing about....   [tags: Ian Buruma Behind the Mask]

Free Essays
468 words (1.3 pages)

The Motives Behind Binge Drinking Essay

- Introduction: One of the most widely used depressants, or drug as some may consider it, is alcohol. Alcohol is a part of many, if not most, of all our lives, and can be seen advertised on almost every street corner. In fact, in 2013, 56.4 percent of people, age 18 and older, reported they have consumed alcohol within the past month, and more importantly, 24.6 percent disclosed they binge drank within the past month as well (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 2015). However, alcohol related deaths account for nearly 88,000 people annually, making it the third leading preventable cause of death within the United States (National Institute on Alcohol Abuse and Alcoholism, 2015)...   [tags: Alcoholism, Alcohol abuse, Binge drinking]

Better Essays
1097 words (3.1 pages)

The Motives Behind The Crusades Essay

- 1) What were the motives behind the Crusades. Evaluate their outcomes. The most notable motives behind the Crusades include religious zeal, Europe’s large population augmenting, and a staggering number of knights eager to fight in battle. Of these motives, religious zeal was the greatest. The crusaders were already more than willing to fight against the Muslims before Alexius Comnenus asked Pope Urban II to supply him with Norman mercenaries in 1095. Western Europeans loathed Muslims ruling the Holy Land, particularly of the holy places of Palestine....   [tags: Middle Ages, Crusades, Ottoman Empire]

Better Essays
1679 words (4.8 pages)

Essay about Methods and Motives Behind Terrorist Attacks

- The FBI defines terrorism as “the unlawful use of force or violence against persons or property to intimidate or coerce a government, the civilian population, or any segment thereof in furtherance of political or social objectives (” By this definition, terrorism can be classified as internal or international based on the overall intent of the attack. Terrorism has been around since the beginning of time, but it’s only since 2011 that the world has come to fully understand the meaning of terrorism....   [tags: FBI, terrorism, violence, property, people]

Better Essays
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Biography of Myra Belle Starr Essay

- Biography of Myra Belle Starr Myra Belle Starr was born in 1848 in the little town of Carthage, Missouri. Myra Belle Shirley later became Belle Starr. She was also one of the three children. When Belle Starr’s older brother died her family moved right outside of Dallas to a little town known as Scyene, Texas. Years later on the 1860’s Belle became involved with a bank robber Cole Younger; he robbed several banks and was hiding from the law. Cole stayed with Belle for a few months until the coast was clear....   [tags: Myra Belle Starr Biographies Essays]

Free Essays
409 words (1.2 pages)

Ulterior Motives of Mass Media behind their Production Essay

- We live in a world of mass media in these modern days. We often believe that mass media functions mostly to make our life better than before, yet, mass media have ulterior motives. Among other elements within mass media, aspect entertainment grows to illustrate the ulterior motives behind mass media industries. Entertainment used to indicate any action that supplies a recreation or offers people to have well being of their leisure time. On the other hand, as many other authors have noted, entertainment is often also simply understood as something which causes the decline of moral principles (Habermas, 93)....   [tags: Media]

Better Essays
1169 words (3.3 pages)

J.B. Priestley's Motives Behind An Inspector Calls Essays

- J.B. Priestley's Motives Behind An Inspector Calls J.B. Priestley was born in Bradford, Yorkshire in 1894. His mother sadly died later that year but then his father remarried four years later. He had worked as a schoolmaster. At sixteen Priestley left school wanting to write and he said, “I believed that the world outside classrooms and labs would help me to become a writer.” But instead of working for the local newspaper he worked as a ‘very junior clerk’ in Helm and Company, the local wool firm....   [tags: Papers]

Free Essays
1268 words (3.6 pages)

History of Ian Fleming Essay

- History of Ian Fleming Ian Fleming not just created the character of James Bond; he personified him by living an exciting life. With his suave style and long history of lavished background he was almost born into the part of his later creation. Ian Fleming was born on May 8th, 1908 to his father, Valentine Fleming, and his mother, Beatrice Fleming (Lycett 12). He was the grandson of the famous Scottish banking pioneer, Robert Fleming (Rosenberg 5). Ian also had three brothers named Peter, Richard, and Michael....   [tags: Ian Fleming James Bond Essays]

Better Essays
1402 words (4 pages)

Ian McEwan's Enduring Love Essay

- Ian McEwan's Enduring Love Evident throughout the entire plot of ‘Enduring Love’, Ian McEwan fuses three different genres: love story, detective story and thriller. Each genre I believe has a set of expectations that captures the reader urging them to read on, for example a thriller genre would stereotypically be led by a fast, tense pace with characters easily identifiable as ‘goodies’ and ‘baddies’. Different, fresh and ‘novel’ McEwan establishes his break up of typical genres as he mixes the elements of the three main genres and purposely doesn’t stick to their rigid framework that many authors swear by....   [tags: Ian McEwan Enduring Love Essays]

Better Essays
1205 words (3.4 pages)

Myra Hindley Essays

- A sadistic temptress, the aid and probable prompt of an evil and cold blooded killer. Or a 'political prisoner being used as a scapegoat by politicians and the media'. This is a very sensitive subject and people often respond with fear and anxiety when we decide to examine things like the Moors murders. We are told that our curiosity is 'unhealthy', and that wanting to know,or openly debate about a matter which is 'naturally' closed, can only be the desire of a sick mind. We are encouraged to turn a blind eye and leave well alone....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
774 words (2.2 pages)