The Legend of Hua Mulan Essay example

The Legend of Hua Mulan Essay example

Length: 748 words (2.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The legend states that Hua Mulan lived during the Northern Wei dynasty. She is a mythical figure from ancient China portrayed in the Chinese poem, Ballad of Mulan. Though both princess warrior show and movie, The Legend of Hua Mulan and Disney’s Mulan have different character personalities and reasons of going to war. The Legend of Hua Mulan is straightforward and seeks to depict Mulan as a warrior. Disney’s Mulan, however, depicts Mulan as trying to prove her parents wrong and bring home a man as in all Disney movies. This shows that Hua Mulan is a better role to girls that Disney’s Mulan.
As The Legend of Hua Mulan depicts a girl going to war in place of her father, the Disney Mulan introduces Mulan as a disappointment to the parents, and she therefore tries to prove herself; this makes Disney’s Mulan slightly weaker in her personality. As seen in the Disney’s Mulan, the character of Mulan is shown as one who is outspoken and forward thinking. The viewers are therefore able to tell she does not have a clue of how to present herself in medieval Chinese society. On the contrary, The Legend of Hua Mulan is skilled at martial arts and sword fighting; she has a manlier character. Since Mulan is seen as a disappointment to her parents, she tries to redeem herself by taking part in the war. Having never left the village before, Mulan has no idea of combat and how weapons work. This means that Mulan has less knowledge of fighting, and she is not going to war to help her society. Wei Mulan has the “smarts” and skills to fight in combat. All of her training in martial arts, sword fighting, and archery give her the skills she needs to do well in combat. She is going to war as a “filial duty.” In addition, as both texts have to present Mula...

... middle of paper ...

...fights to redeem herself and to bring back a prince. Wei Mulan is comfortable as a person and the role she plays in society. This shows that she has a genuine reason for taking the place her father in fighting for her country. Instead, Disney’s Mulan is restrained by her confining society. This shows that both Mulans have a different role in society. Also, Wei’s play portrays Mulan to express that everyone has a duty to serve within a particular family or country. This means Wei Mulan knows what is important to her; she knows her values. Finally, Wei Mulan represents a hero who knows that doing what is right for the family is important. Wei Mulan knew her father would be unable to fight, and she took the responsibility upon herself to keep her family in suitable conditions. This means that Disney Mulan was going to war just to show her parents that she is capable.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Gender Roles : Mulan 's Mulan

- The Different Gender Roles in the Film Mulan Mulan is a film that illustrates the Chinese legend “Hua Mulan” which tales the story of a legendary women warrior. This legend is based in China’s traditional culture values. The alternation of gender roles was considerate a violation of those values; thus, whoever presents that behavior would be killed as a punishment. The main character, Mulan, represents women with a modern personality that shows masculinity. The fact that Mulan tried to perform a male’s actions is very significant due to the historical context, which illustrates the different roles between men and women....   [tags: Gender role, Gender, Man, Gender identity]

Better Essays
1008 words (2.9 pages)

Mulan vs. Kung Fu Panda: The Battle for Accurate Portrayal of Chinese Culture

- Ever since the establishment of cinema in the early 1900s, Hollywood has continuously recreated elements of history to reenact for its future generations. In order to clearly broadcast a specific theme or message to relay to viewers around the world, Hollywood executives tend to embellish real life events, in order to provide a “fairytale” aspect to a seemingly not so “happily- ever-after” story from history. As part of this “fairytale” aspect, Hollywood tends to delegitimize as well as provide a more disrespectful and more comical version of societies and cultures in the specific time frame that the film is being set....   [tags: Hollywood, Film Analysis]

Better Essays
1201 words (3.4 pages)

Film Reproduction: Cultural Reconstruction or Deterioration? Essay

- Mulan, an American animated musical action-comedy-drama film released in 1998, has been well received by critics and the public with grossing $304 million, earning Academy Award nominations and winning several Annie Awards including Best Animated Feature. Adapted from an ancient Chinese story on a legendary girl Mulan who volunteers to join the army by masquerading as a man in order to replace her aged father, the film integrates non-Chinese value, ideology and expectation into the original narrative....   [tags: Mulan, Disney, authentic]

Better Essays
2626 words (7.5 pages)

Disney's Inaccurate Portrayal of Mulan and Pocahontas Essay

- Many times, things are not what they seem. Deception is often used to publicize things in a different light and it distorts actual historical content and facts. One example of this is when Disney inaccurately portrays the actual life of historical characters such as Mulan and Pocahontas. In the movie Mulan, based on the “Ballad of Mulan,” Disney inaccurately portrays her life causing many incongruities. In the movie, Mulan is portrayed as being weak and unskilled with weapons and horsemanship....   [tags: Mulan, Pocahontas]

Better Essays
913 words (2.6 pages)

Strong Chinese Women in Film Essay

- 1. Introduction In Confucian thought, women had their purpose beside their men or within their households as mothers. However, the legend of Hua Mulan precedes Confucius. Mulan’s story had inspired early Chinese Feminists such as Qiu Ji to go against the society built to keep her space as a woman separate from the rest of the world. In modern times, Fa Mulan (from Disney) added more diversity to the usual Disney Princesses and gave westerners an image of Chinese culture. The Disney film about Fa Mulan and the live action film about Hua Mulan by Jingle Ma ultimately chronicle the journey of Mulan and her service in the military but the films will have significant differences because of the di...   [tags: Character Analysis]

Better Essays
1841 words (5.3 pages)

Mulan: A Woman on a Mission Essay

- Mulan (Revised) Disney proclaims that the adaptations of the Chinese story of Mulan is to transform ethnic materials into a “timeless” or “universal” classic (Kurtti 1998). Peter Schneider, Disney Feature Animation President, avers that “the search for who we are, the search for self, it an ever-ongoing process and universal theme” (Kurtti 1998, 189). Guided by this principle, Disney appropriated the Mulan story into its typical formula of a hero’s journey of self-discovery. The film features Mulan as a tomboyish girl who could not fit in the traditional gender role in China....   [tags: Film Analysis ]

Better Essays
1815 words (5.2 pages)

The Legend Of Sleepy Hollow Essay

- I do not know about you, but I like my reads to have content of all things that I love. The Legend of Sleepy Hollow contains just that. The Legend of Sleepy Hollow will have you sleeping with your night light on, in awe of male ego battling for ones true love, and giving you a piece of history as well. Washington Irving being influenced by a neighborhood friend by the name of “Bugbee” of fairy tales was only the beginning of what filled his imagination. “when I was very young, I had irrepressible flow of spirits that often went beyond my strength....   [tags: The Legend of Sleepy Hollow, Ichabod Crane]

Better Essays
740 words (2.1 pages)

White Tigers vs. Mulan Essay

- William Shakespeare once said, “[My] honor is my life; both grow in one; take honor from me, and my life is done.” The idea is touched upon in both the book Woman Warrior by Maxine Hong Kingston as well as Disney’s Mulan were family honor is more important than anything else. Mulan was directed by Tony Bancroft and Barry Cook, and produced by Walt Disney Pictures. The film Mulan retold the story of a woman warrior who took her father’s place in battle and became a savior of China.The movie uses many elements from the original story told in the chapter “White Tigers,” but adds many modern twists in order to make the story more appealing for a newer generation....   [tags: Woman Warrior, Maxine Hong Kingston, Disney]

Better Essays
973 words (2.8 pages)

The Changing of The Legend of Sleepy Hollow Essay

- The Changing of The Legend of Sleepy Hollow         "Once upon a time" is the predictable beginning of a fairy tale and "happily ever after" is the ending. "The Legend of Sleepy Hollow" by Washington Irving is a classical myth that defies the conventional standards of a fairy tale. Set in a valley in New England, It's a gothic tale of mystery and suspense that bears no definite ending surrounding the myth of the "Headless Horseman of Sleepy Hollow" (Heath 1355). The original text created by Irving was intended for the mature reader, a reader who could understand a sense of irony, had knowledge of history, and taste....   [tags: Legend Sleepy Hollow]

Better Essays
2577 words (7.4 pages)

Essay on Analysis of The Legend of Big Liz

- The Legend of Big Liz During the Civil War there was a slave girl named Elizabeth...who worked on a plantation in Dorchester County. Her owner was a very wealthy man who was extremely paranoid that he would lose his assets if the war reached his home and the North won. As things began turning out poorly for the Confederates, the owner decided to hide his treasures in the Greenbriar Swamp. He took Elizabeth, who he called Liz, deep into the swamp and had her dig a hole to bury the treasure in. After the hole was dug and the treasure placed in it, the owner knocked Liz over the head and into the hole with his shovel....   [tags: Ghost Story Urban Legend]

Better Essays
1165 words (3.3 pages)