Essay on Law and Morality in Literature

Essay on Law and Morality in Literature

Length: 2069 words (5.9 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Behavioral conduct is regulated through two different avenues: law and morality. Morality is defined as the “rules of behavior an individual or a group may follow out of personal conscience and that are not necessarily part of legislated law” (Encyclopedia of American Law). Morality channels our behavior through a system of incentives; bad acts produce “… guilt and disapprobation, and good acts result in virtuous feelings and praise” (Shavell 228). Law, on the other hand, is concerned with justice and is upheld through “… the threat of sanctions if we disobey legal rules” (Shavell 227). The point of contention occurs when individuals incorrectly assume that a just decision necessitates morality. These individuals dispute the scope of authority that either morality or law should encompass. Morality and law do not operate in different spheres; instead, the laws are created with a primary focus towards persuading individuals to make moral decisions. In both A Man for All Seasons by Robert Bolt and the Greek play Antigone by Sophocles, difficulty ensues not because law and morality are actually conflicting, but because the individuals interpreting law and morality have varying interpretations.
The authors present the dichotomy between law and morality through a system of contrasts. Sir Thomas More and Antigone both place their faith in a higher power while King Henry VIII and Creon trust in their own man-made laws. Because their views conflict with those in power, Antigone and Sir Thomas More are both sentenced to death. Although their punishments may seem unfair, in both pieces of literature the characters are opposing the law. Creon and King Henry VIII are thereby acting in accordance with their laws and, although their ...

... middle of paper ... it is primarily their failure as rulers that is highlighted.
The incongruity between law and morality is fostered by an individual’s interpretation of the law and its purpose. The conflict in both A Man for All Seasons and Antigone is not a conflict between morality and law, but in the characters’ use of morality and law. Because of this, the decisions that both Creon and King Henry VIII make to sentence Antigone and Thomas More are justified. Each protagonist was making decisions that were in conflict, but were still moral. In writing the plays, they authors implied that one version of morality, that of Antigone and Sir Thomas More, was more acceptable than the other. However, this is not the case since the decisions of King Henry and Creon were also couched in morality and were being made with regards to the good of the individuals under their command.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Realism and Naturalism in American Literature Stories

- There are two dominate aspects of Realism (Social Rules & Morality), and two dominate laws of Naturalism (Environment & Determinism), that comes into play in the American Literature stories of Daisy Miller ,Frank James, and Jack London. According to one authoritative source (Britannica), realism in its basic form in Literature is a literary style in which the author describes the reality of persons (people) in detail to resemble their actions, emotions, and environment. The strengths and weaknesses are blended in with the characteristics of their flawed personalities by not being completely good or evil, weak or strong....   [tags: American Literature]

Better Essays
1479 words (4.2 pages)

Essay on The Importance Of Evaluating The Norm By Law Professionals

- The hermeneutic perspective corroborates to the study, discussing the importance of assessing the norm by law professionals by producting and reproducting scientific and academic thoughts about the contribution of constitutionality controls to legal systems. In one small aspect, Gilmar Mendes teaches, that the work of interpreting the Constitution begins when it frustrates the direct communication with your text and it no longer responds to questions from your readers. It is the readiness that integrates to fix the meaning of the Constitution rules of law (MENDES, GILMAR....   [tags: Law, United States Constitution, Constitution]

Better Essays
1609 words (4.6 pages)

Morality And Perception Of Good And Evil Essay

- There are many moral behaviors that have happened over time between now and back in the Victorian era. There were a different set of morals over time based on religion and other perceptions of good and evil in literature and different forms media going back from the Victorian era till now. The books The Strange Cases of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde, The Hunger Games, Dracula, and Beowulf are some of the literature that support the morals changing through time, how good and evil was perceived, and how actions were justified as good or evil....   [tags: Morality, Religion, Robert Louis Stevenson]

Better Essays
2207 words (6.3 pages)

Essay about The Acquisition of Morality

- ... Although the case for neutral human morality is pretty straightforward there are two other views on the topic. The case that humans are innately good and the case that we are innately evil and must be taught better by religious or spiritual influences. This sentiment that people are sinful and need to be “saved” is common view shared by Christianity and other major religions. There are several parts of the bible that can be used to look at this assertion, in particular we will turn to the writings of St....   [tags: Steinbeck, Plato, St. Matthew]

Better Essays
1019 words (2.9 pages)

Crime, Revenge and Morality in "Killings" Essay

- The story of “Killings” by Andre Dubus looked into the themes of crime, revenge and morality. The crime committed in the story depicted the father’s love for his son and the desire to avenge his son’s death. However, his own crime led to his own destruction as he was faced with questions of morality. The character found himself in a difficult position after taking his revenge. He failed to anticipate the guilt associated with the crime he committed. Feelings of anger and righteousness are illustrated by the character throughout the story....   [tags: Literature Review]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

Nietzsche And Immanuel Kant 's Philosophy Of Moral Law Essay

- Between philosophers Nietzsche and Immanuel Kant, we can conclude that Nietzsche has different views in which a man lives his life. According to Kant, we as human beings must act and live according the moral law. However, in regards to Nietzsche, he rejects the notion that there is a moral code for everyone and insists that each individual is able to see that there is no objective morality. Nietzsche’s greatest criticism of Kant’s philosophy of moral law, stems from his emphasis and use of the idea of the “overman”, which forms his opinion on liberal democracy (Hamilton-Bleakley)....   [tags: Immanuel Kant, Morality, Friedrich Nietzsche]

Better Essays
1212 words (3.5 pages)

Essay on Conceptions of Biblical Morality

- Conceptions of Biblical Morality Over the course of the first two books of the Old Testament, Genesis and Exodus, a noticeable evolution of the relationship between humankind and God takes center-stage. From the initial creation of Adam to the Ten Commandments delivered from Mount Sinai, God’s covenant with the Israelites is fulfilled through different means and varying modes of communication. The manner in which God interacts with his subjects over the early history of the biblical world helps to understand his motivation as a creator, and the moral reasoning behind the actions of his people....   [tags: Bible Christianity Religion Literature Essays]

Better Essays
2381 words (6.8 pages)

The Literature of Romanticism versus the Victorian Essays

- In the Victorian era poets are inspired to debate among each other in the heat of enlightenment. The literature of Romanticism versus the Victorian era initially becomes a problematic subject to accept. As a Victorian poet, Gerard Manley Hopkins attacks the conception of religion by questioning the existence of God. Hopkins’ sonnets reflect this issue of an oppress religion and educates people towards the conspiracy of a change era through his magnificent poems. Hopkins stands true to the new and improve era of Victorian by conciliating the absences of divinity....   [tags: Romanticism Essays]

Better Essays
1555 words (4.4 pages)

Essay on No Country For Old Men : Morality, Principle, And Fate

- Cormac McCarthy’s No Country for Old Men: Morality, Principle, and Fate in Literature Cormac McCarthy’s critically acclaimed 2005 novel No Country for Old Men, centers around three major characters (Llewellyn Moss, Anton Chigurh, and Ed Tom Bell) whose lives intertwine after a chain reaction occurs related to a drug deal gone bad near the Mexican-American border in 1980. While hunting antelope to bring home for dinner, protagonist Llewellyn Moss stumbles upon the bloody aftermath of a messy drug deal....   [tags: No Country for Old Men, Cormac McCarthy]

Better Essays
1155 words (3.3 pages)

The Rule of Law Essay

- The Rule of Law The rule of law maybe defined in brief as a doctrine that no individual, however powerful is above the law. In principle Rule of Law had a significant influence on attempts to restrain the arbitrary use of power by rulers and the growth of legally enforced Human Rights in many western countries. It is often used as a justification for separately legislative from judicial power, this can be clearly seen within the government structure of the UK....   [tags: Papers]

Better Essays
451 words (1.3 pages)