The Land Bridge Theory And The Problems Of Mythic Symbolism Essay

The Land Bridge Theory And The Problems Of Mythic Symbolism Essay

Length: 1107 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The Land Bridge Theory and the Problems of Mythic Symbolism
In the Native American, religious community there is skepticism regarding the Land Bridge Theory , which hypothesizes that the native populace migrated into America via a land bridge in the Beringia region. Some of the skepticism, and rejection of the Land Bridge Theory, is a result of a strong claim that science has created a largely fictional scenario for Native Americans in prehistoric America. The Native Americans who reject the Land Bridge Theory have an alternative view of history as seen through the myths of their people. There are several Native American religious traditions whose myths of creation hold that they were born out of the earth in their traditional homeland. In this essay, it is my intention to assess this claim from the perspective of mythic symbolism as explained by Paul Tillich in Dynamics of Faith.
In Dynamics and Faith, Tillich describes three forms of mythic consciousness viz, the broken myth, and the naturally literal and reactively literal unbroken myth (Tillich 386-390). Tillich explains that the broken myth is “[a] myth which is understood as a myth, but not removed or replaced” (Tillich 388). Using this definition of a broken myth that Tillich provides, the argument is that the Native American understanding of being born out of the earth in their traditional homeland may be tacitly accepted as a myth however, it has not been substituted or eradicated from awareness. This is because broken myths are the symbolic “language of faith”, and science cannot substitute for faith (Tillich 388). As Tillich explains, when the myth is broken, so too is the feeling of certainty and security that comes with the belief in the myth. Introducing...


... middle of paper ...


...fic hypothesis is possible. In this sense, it would point more toward Tillich’s interpretation as the myth being understood as a broken myth in that it is understood as a myth, but still retained as an awareness of traditional concern for the “ultimate” that the myth points towards (Tillich 389).
In conclusion, it seems fair to characterize Tillich as presenting myths involving some aspects of the truth without fully embracing the falsity associated with the common interpretation of myth. The assessment of these claims from the perspective of mythic symbolism does point towards an agreement within the way that Native Americans view the Land Bridge Theory. In addition, Tillich’s explanations of how myths are broken or unbroken can be assessed to show their usability in explaining the problems of mythic symbolism from both a scientific, and a skeptical viewpoint.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

How does symbolism enhance the drama in A View From The Bridge? Essay

- How does symbolism enhance the drama in A View From The Bridge. Symbolism is a physical object or reference used to provide meaning to a piece of writing. Symbolism enhances the drama in A View From The Bridge because it increases the tension between the characters, as well as highlights key themes. Symbolism is a very important element as it enhances the plot. There are a large amount of symbols that create tension such as: high heels, the chair, the knife, the cigar, the paper doll and homosexuality....   [tags: symbolism, sexuality, power]

Strong Essays
637 words (1.8 pages)

The Design Of The Bridge Essay

- A bridge is a structure ,built by many different materials, to travel over physical objects. For example, bridges were made over bodies of water, roads or intersections, and valleys. The first welded road bridge was designed by Polish engineer Stefan Bryla in 1927.There is an average of about 607,380 bridges throughout the Unites States. There are many different bridges throughout the world and there is also different causes for bridges. There are also many different designs that all have different purposes and apply to different situations....   [tags: Bridge, Bridges, Box girder bridge]

Strong Essays
1023 words (2.9 pages)

Analysis of An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge by Ambrose Bierce Essay

- Numerous American authors have written stories about the Confederate Civil War. Ambrose Bierce has been one of the most popular authors whose writings have withheld the ticking test-of-time. His own distinction within the Union Confederate Army provides a parallel within his own writings. In the justly famous short story, “An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge” (Bierce 551), Ambrose Bierce, creates a fascinating tale of reality that infuses a bridge into ostensible spirituality through his effective use of characters, settings, and symbolisms....   [tags: characters, settings, symbolisms]

Strong Essays
611 words (1.7 pages)

The History of the Golden Gate Bridge Essay

- Stretching across the San Francisco Bay stands the world famous Golden Gate Bridge. The bridge is located in one of nature’s most beautiful settings, spanning the mile-wide bay from Fort Point in San Francisco to the Marin County Shore. Joseph Strauss, specializing in bridge building, was the leader of the construction of the Golden Gate Bridge. The start of construction began on January 5, 1993 and, after four years, was completed on April 27, 1997. The bridge was needed to be built because of the growing population after the California Gold Rush....   [tags: Golden Gate Bridge, San Francisco, ]

Strong Essays
1431 words (4.1 pages)

Essay on Design A Bridge And Its Effect On The Bridge

- Introduction A bridge is required to span a gorge in New Guinea. The goal of this project is to design a bridge that meets the requirements for that bridge and then construct and test that bridge on a 1:20 scale. The requirements for the bridge are that it has to span across the 600mm (12m to scale) wide gorge which has two square flat areas on either side of the bridge which are 100mm (2m to scale) wide. The bridge must be able to hold the maximum possible weight while remaining as light as possible....   [tags: Bridge, Truss, Truss bridge, Covered bridge]

Strong Essays
1773 words (5.1 pages)

The Land Of The Bible: The Sacred Bridge Essay

- First Reading Critique: The Sacred Bridge Anson Rainey and R. Steven Notley are the authors of The Sacred Land Bridge, which is an Atlas of the biblical world and includes maps, pictures, and historical cementation as to the significance of this region. The biblical world that this atlas focuses on is defined as the eastern Mediterranean littoral, or more commonly called the Levant in modern archeological discussions. In my critique of this book I will be focusing on pages 30-34 which will define the boundaries and explain the importance of the Levant....   [tags: Theological Book Review Critique]

Free Essays
1189 words (3.4 pages)

Myth and Violence in The Waste Land Essay

-          As evidenced by his writings, T.S. Eliot has a profound appreciation for the use of myth as a point of departure for maintaining a cultural or historical perspective. In "The Waste Land," his employment of myth is not simply an allusive and metaphorical tactic, but rather an attempt at relating his own ideas and tropes to universals in order to establish some external order for the chaos he is presenting: "The element of myth in his art is not so much a creative method, a resumption of the role of mythic poet, as it is an intellectual strategy, a device for gaining perspective on himself and on his myth-forsaken time" (Ellmann, 621)....   [tags: T.S. Eliot Waste Land Essays]

Strong Essays
2653 words (7.6 pages)

Essay on Mythic Heros: Sinbad The Sailor

- Mythic Heros: Sinbad the Sailor When I think about mythic heroes, for many years the first name that came to mind was Sinbad: Sinbad the sailor. In his days as an adventurer, he went on seven fantastic voyages which earned him fame for the rest of his life. Yet, now in retrospect, I no longer consider him to be the great adventurer that I saw him as in my childhood. On his seven voyages, Sinbad encountered every obstacle one could possibly think of. He and his crew met up with: a fish so large, many mistook it for an island, an island where rocs (enormous birds (their eggs were often mistaken for buildings)) still lived, cannibals, giants, and even herds of angry elephants....   [tags: essays research papers]

Free Essays
517 words (1.5 pages)

Katherine Patterson’s Bridge to Terabithia Essay

- Katherine Patterson’s Bridge to Terabithia All children can relate in someway to Katherine Patterson’s Newberry Medal-winning children’s novel, Bridge to Terabithia. The characters are realistic people who could be one’s next door neighbors. From the shy and demure Jess to the vivacious and carefree Leslie, every kid can relate to one of the characters in this novel. The themes in this novel vary as much as the characters. Bridge to Terabithia is a good coming-of-age book that captures our imaginations and our hearts....   [tags: Bridge Terabithia Patterson Essays]

Strong Essays
1101 words (3.1 pages)

Clifton Suspension Bridge Essay

- Clifton Suspension Bridge The Clifton Suspension Bridge is located in Bristol England, and spans the beautiful Avon gorge. This bridge has become the symbol of Bristol much like the Eiffel tower has of Paris, and the Opera house has of Sydney. The story of the Clifton Suspension Bridge began in 1754 with the dream of a Bristol wine merchant who donated his life savings to build a bridge over the gorge. To decide on a suitable design for the bridge a competition was held. Thomas Telford, the leading civil architect of the time was the judge....   [tags: History Historical Bridge Architecture Essays]

Strong Essays
1045 words (3 pages)