According to Kant, our duty as moral beings is not flexible. We are not to make an exception of ourselves. If we expect people to act in a certain way, in this case as responsible upstanding citizens, we are to act in that manner as well. While it is disappointing that Rhonda will lose all of her Ph.D. support at this moment and possibly postpone her life saving research discovery, this is a consequence that she should have considered earlier when she did NOT do her moral duty and accepted the liability of driving home after partaking in illegal substances. Clearly the right and moral duty in this case, by Kant’s principle is for Rhonda to accept the consequences that are in store for her poor choice of driving under the influence.
By accepting fault in the accident, Rhonda will lose her Ph.D. financing, however, if she is indeed on a path to discovering a way of alleviating disease and starvation globally, there are other financial backers that will find and help her to complete thi...
... middle of paper ...
...she understands cause and effect. She also knows how to solve a problem. The new problem for her to solve is how to continue with her research once she has sorted out the legality of her situation; a moral compromise Rhonda must make for doing the right thing and taking personal responsibility. Rhonda had a lapse in judgment that ended very badly. While morally, she should be the one to confess to driving, she morally should not have to suffer the greatest consequences. I believe that by choosing to “do right thing” her ultimate outcome will produce the same effects, finding a means to relieve global suffering, will still come to fruition.
By Kant’s definition of Categorical Imperative, and supported by various aspects of Moral Pluralism the choice that results in the minimal acceptable moral outcome is for Rhonda to take responsibility for driving the car.
Need Writing Help?
Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.Check your paper »
- Marx and Engels, and Kant share a fundamental commonality in the conception of human history in that they both acknowledge history as a rational process whose movement follows a progressive future outline. Their concept of process, a central theme to their conception of human history, gives meaning to individual human actions which appears as simple, haphazard event, with purposive shape and rational meaning. In Kant, progress assumes the form of realizing the human potential of reason; in Marx, it is the abolishment of class differences in the revolutionary transition to communism.... [tags: humans, history, kantian philosophy]
897 words (2.6 pages)
- Lyotard on the Kantian Sublime ABSTRACT: In this essay I explicate J.F. Lyotard's reading of the Kantian sublime as presented in Lessons on the Analytic of the Sublime (1994) and in "Answering the Question: What is Postmodernism" (1984). Lessons articulates the context in which critical thought situates itself as a zone of virtually infinite creative capacity, undetermined by principles but in search of them; "Answering the Question" explores how the virtually infinite creative capacity of thought manifests in the avant-gardes.... [tags: Sublime Philosophy Philosophical Papers]
3544 words (10.1 pages)
- The philosophical theories of Utilitarian and Kantian Ethics propose opposing theories on the moral worth of an action. Early utilitarians’ proposed that human beings seek pleasure and that pleasure is the only intrinsic good and since they seek pleasure, they also made a claim that humans tend to avoid pain. Therefore as humans, we tend to follow through on the actions that maximize pleasure; this theory had been simplified into the idea that actions should bring about “the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number”.... [tags: Philosophy]
1273 words (3.6 pages)
- Extending a Kantian Dichotomy to a Poincaréan Trichotomy ABSTRACT: I argue for the possibility of knowledge by invention which is neither á priori nor á posteriori. My conception of knowledge by invention evolves from Poincaré’s conventionalism, but unlike Poincaré’s conventions, propositions known by invention have a truth value. An individuating criteria for this type of knowledge is conjectured. The proposition known through invention is: gounded historically in the discipline to which it belongs; a result of the careful, sincere and objective quest and effort of the knower; chosen freely by the inventer or knower; and, private in its invention but public once invented.... [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Papers]
2976 words (8.5 pages)
- ... A maxim is a statement about how one should behave, such as “I should not steal.” Kant’s theory rejects any exceptions to a rule. A maxim must propose a rule to live by without reservation. Kant also provides a method for one to determine whether one should act in accordance with a certain maxim; one must test it using the categorical imperative. The categorical imperative requires that one consider a world where every decision ever made was based on that maxim. If the maxim produces a world that a rational being could conceive of and choose to live in, it is one’s duty to abide by that maxim in all situations, and vice versa.... [tags: Immanuel Kant, Philosophy, Ethics]
952 words (2.7 pages)
- In this essay I will use ethical framework such as Kantian deontology and Kantian ethical theory along with key principles to argue the reason for my decision whilst justifying my decision. As the manager, I will consider using Kant’s ethical principles to decide if I should accept the deal by the Thailand suppliers and if the decision is ethical taking into account the 3 maxims set by Kant. I will be taking the categorical imperative and Kant’s 3 principle formulations into account whilst making my decision.... [tags: Immanuel Kant, Ethics, Philosophy]
1002 words (2.9 pages)
- ... Kant has a method to see if your will align with your duty. Think of Kant’s method like a three-part test, if all three parts of the test pass then your will and duty align. The first part of the test is whether you have a sense of duty, as Kant believed we can act with a sense of duty alone. The second part of the test is the Maxim. The Maxim is a subjective principle that governs your actions, or a personal unbreakable law; for example “I will not lie” is a Maxim. The final and arguably most important part of the test is the Categorical Imperative.... [tags: Immanuel Kant, Categorical imperative, Philosophy]
909 words (2.6 pages)
- A Kantian Interpretation of Demonstrative Reference ABSTRACT: According to Kant, we refer to what is out there in the world by performing a demonstrative act, like pointing at an object with a finger. A Kantian mode of demonstrative reference is characterized by the existence of a real, 2-placed affective relation between an intuiting subject and the referent. Parsons suggests that Kantian intuition is both singular and immediate, and immediacy demands an object of intuition to be present, a condition clearly satisfied by objects within our immediate perceptual field.... [tags: Philosophy Philosophical Kant Essays]
3142 words (9 pages)
- Aristotle's and Kant's ideas of the means and ends of moral ethics are in sharp contrast. Both have strengths and weaknesses in their arguments, but Aristotle's is superior to Kant's because it is more realistic. I will first give the basis of both philosophies, Aristotle first, Kant second. Next, I will expand and question points of both philosophies, Aristotle's end, and Kant's means. Lastly, I will explain the reasoning behind why I favor Aristotle's ethics over Kant's. Both philosophies appeals to reason, but they come to different conclusions.... [tags: Aristotle, Immanuel Kant, morals, philosophy]
1474 words (4.2 pages)
- Utilitarianism and Kantian Ethics Ethics is one part of philosophy that will always be studied, and like most subjects in philosophy, will never be viewed the same by everyone. There are so many cultures that have so many different beliefs about the way a person's life should be lived out. Things like religion, poverty, and mental health all contribute to our beliefs in ethics. Some people believe that the mental state of a person or the motive for that person committing a crime should be factors when sentencing time comes.... [tags: essays research papers fc]
1184 words (3.4 pages)