Judith Butler 's The Political System Essay

Judith Butler 's The Political System Essay

Length: 888 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

Judith Butler describes the political reasons behind many feminists’ insistence on defining ‘woman. ' The political system we have had in the West needs representation of women to spread visibility and legitimize women’s issues in politics (I, 2). To achieve this representation, feminists had to create a language that defines ‘woman. ' Conversely, as Butler discusses, trying to define ‘woman’ poses problems of misrepresentation (I, 2). Some feminists’ assert that they are defining women merely as a political strategy; however, Butler says, even for strategic reasons, there are consequences to defining ‘woman’ (I, 6). Western feminists relied on universalizing not just the word ‘woman, ' but the patriarchy as well; women in countries where they suffer many oppressions gave Western feminists a legitimacy in politics to act urgently against misogyny (I, 5). Butler states that representation should not be the only method to political action; “identity of the feminist subject ought not to be the foundation of feminist politics” (I, 8). She calls feminists to break away from identity politics; to break free from attempting to define ‘woman’ (1, 7).
Feminists wanted to avoid the problem of ‘biology is destiny, ' so they separated gender from sex; gender being cultural and sex being biological (II,9). However, since feminists have been defining gender as a social construct, as cultural, we face the problem of contradiction; “gender becomes a free-floating artifact” (II, 9). Separating sex from gender says that gender is inherent. Judith explains that gender, as a social construct, is restricted by sex (II, 9). Meaning gender does not exist without sex; “sex itself is a gendered category’ (II, 10). Gender does not exist without cultural c...

... middle of paper ...

...ple whether there are thirty-seven gender options or a thousand gender options. Gender is restrictive because the binaries it relies on, including genders like “gender fluid” which is defined as “A gender-fluid person, may at any time identify as male, female, either, or some combination of identities. Their gender can also vary at random or vary in response to different circumstances” (Clarke-Billings 2016). The definition is affirming that these “genders” are personalities. Gender is what is forced on to us because of our sex, they are roles to play, roles that no one fulfills because no one can become a gender, gender will always be a continues set of actions and behaviors, what we call a personality. Gender is a way for people to enforce actions and behavior of others because they are enforcing the personality of people. Gender cannot be non-restrictive.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on Judith Butler and Postmodern Feminism

- Judith Butler and Postmodern Feminism What necessary tasks does Judith Butler identify for feminist criticism. How is her articulation of and response to these tasks characteristically "postmodern". "She has no identity except as a wife and mother. She does not know who she is herself. She waits all day for her husband to come home at night to make her feel alive." This sentiment "lay buried, unspoken, for many years, in the minds of American women", until "In 1960, the problem that has no name bust like a boil through the image of the happy American housewife." Betty Friedan coined the phrase `the problem that has no name' during the second wave of feminism in the 1960's....   [tags: Gender Studies]

Better Essays
2625 words (7.5 pages)

Essay on Butler and Foucault: A Revision of Power

- ... If individuals are simply compliant bodies shaped by power, then it becomes difficult to imagine resistance to power. Foucault believed that from the 17th century on, the growth and care of the populace became the chief concern of the state. As this happened new mechanisms of power emerged which focused on the administration and management of living. Foucault spells out the genesis of this political technology and its use for social control: "One of the great innovations in the techniques of power in the eighteenth century was the emergence of “population” as an economic and political problem: population as wealth, population as manpower or labour capacity, population balanced between i...   [tags: biopower, society, mechanism]

Better Essays
1258 words (3.6 pages)

`` Undoing Gender `` By Judith Butler Essay

- When it comes to the idea of sex and gender, and how with the age of modern medicine, people around the world may change their own lives for the better as they change their sex to the gender they associate with. Finally feeling the freedom of being in the body that they wished for, yet this a decision that should be taken by the participating, rather than the doctor making the procedure. Judith Butler’s writing, “Undoing Gender”, there is a story of a person whom goes through their life trying to figure out what they have become....   [tags: Gender, Female, Judith Butler, Male]

Better Essays
1141 words (3.3 pages)

Gender Trouble by Judith Butler Essay

- Gender Stephen Morton in his Gayatri Spivak promotes Simone de Beauvoir’s saying, therefore he point outs, The category of gender identity was not determined by one’s biological sex; rather gender is a social construct, which can be resisted through social and political struggle.(73) The traditional of universal humanist thought had further defined the difference between men and women as natural fact, grounded in a biological foundation that is prior to social and cultural influence. Simone de Beauvoir had discredited this view with the assertion that ‘One is not born a women,one became a women’....   [tags: social and cultural influence]

Better Essays
1724 words (4.9 pages)

Feminist Theorist Judith Butler and Gender Transformation Essay

- Introduction – The Transformation The presence of gender through this the twenty-first century is no longer black and white (nor was it ever explicitly male or female at anytime). In a time of push towards acceptance of all people, no matter their social standpoint, the time of questionnaires and government documents asking whether one is male or female, has become extremely complex. “Gender” as a concept represented through the body is not simply a configuration of how the body formed. Rather, gender is performed and represented through and using the body – hence referring to Waskul and Vannini’s theory of the body being embodied when they state in their piece Body/ Embodiment: Social Inte...   [tags: social interaction, emotional transition]

Better Essays
2388 words (6.8 pages)

A Feminist Methodology By Judith Baxter Essay

- Positioning Gender in Discourse: A Feminist Methodology by Judith Baxter This book by Judith Baxter makes a valuable contribution to the debate surrounding theoretical and methodological approaches to the study of gender and language in the newly emerging field of feminist post-structural discourse analysis (FDPA). She uses her book both to show that FDPA has both “theoretical virtues as well as fundamental, practical value for empirical research” (Baxter, 1). Baxter, in particular wants to explore the way FDPA analyzes the ways in which “speakers negotiate their identities, relationships, and positions in their world according to the ways in which they are located by competing yet interwov...   [tags: Feminism, Gender, Judith Butler, Gender studies]

Better Essays
735 words (2.1 pages)

Beside Oneself By Judith Butler Summary Essay

- Judith Butler, in her essay entitled “Beside Oneself: On the Limits of Sexual Autonomy” from Undoing Gender, explains how there are restrictive norms regarding gender and sexuality. She speaks about how society creates norms that people should follow. If one does not follow these norms, they are like the outcasts of society, the people who do not fit in. Butler is not the only person who has knowledge regarding social norms, but various other people, like authors, psychologists, and teachers, also have a clear understanding of social norms and the effects of social norms....   [tags: Sociology, Social psychology, Norm]

Better Essays
1674 words (4.8 pages)

Mass Media and Democratization in Indonesian Political System Essay

- This paper is going to talk about mass media and democratization in Indonesian political system. What kind of democratization it is. What are the influences of mass media in our society. In this paper, we are going to discuss it further. Since this issue is a reality which happened in our country. Moreover, it also has an impact towards the result of general election. This result will lead Indonesia to a better way or the opposite of it, which is the worst. Mass media, now, became one of the tools that are used by most of the political actors....   [tags: indonesia, democratization, political system]

Better Essays
1839 words (5.3 pages)

Essay about A Political System

- Similar to a well oiled machine, a political system is concerned with processing the demands of a society to then provide the goods and services demanded while ensuring its own establishment (Berg 1). However, considering that the idea of a political system is a social construct, its form is subject to a myriad of complex and conflicting forces. The most palpable force is that of a city’s financial needs. Any locale has the burden of satisfying the demands of its constituents with limited resources....   [tags: New York City, Chicago, Political corruption]

Better Essays
878 words (2.5 pages)

The Political System in India and America Essays

- Man, being a social animal, has to live in harmony with fellow human beings. Human society has created the unique institution of organized state in order to maintain public order, defend frontiers, and ensure harmony among individuals and groups. After centuries of struggle, only in the modern era has it generally come to be accepted that the state cannot be controlled by divine right or power. Neither hereditary succession nor favors are acceptable as arbiters of political power in a civilized society....   [tags: Comparing Political Systems]

Free Essays
969 words (2.8 pages)