Is Abortion Morally Permissible or Not? Essay

Is Abortion Morally Permissible or Not? Essay

Length: 1311 words (3.7 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The following essay will examine the morality of abortion with specific reference to the writings of Don Marquis, Judith Jarvis Thompson, Peter Singer and Mary Anne Warren. I will begin by assessing the strength of the argument provided by Marquis which claims that abortion is impermissible because it deprives a being of a potential “future like ours,” and then go on to consider the writings of Singer, Thomson and Warren to both refute Marquis claims and support my assertion that abortion is morally permissible primarily because of the threat to the freedom and bodily autonomy of women extending the right to life to a foetus in utero would pose.
To fully understand the argument we should first define the parameters of the debate and the key ideas held by each side. Throughout this essay I will be using the terms conservative and liberal as defined by Singer (p. 125) to refer to either side of the debate. The argument usually centers on whether or not a foetus qualifies as a person-- a complex, self-aware being with future-orientated preferences (Study Guide, p. 20)-- those on the conservative side usually argue that a foetus is a person, or at least potential person, and as a result liken abortion to murder, while those on the liberal side tend to refute the proposed personhood of a foetus. Both Singer and Warren agree that human development is a gradual process and it is impossible to pin point an exact stage where personhood is attained (Singer, p. 129, Study Guide, p.187), however it is clear, at least, that this happens somewhere in early childhood, and that while in utero the foetus only qualifies as a merely conscious being (Singer, p. 136). While I personally agree that a foetus is by no means a person and possesses none o...

... middle of paper ...

...nhood and potential is too flimsy a concept to be relevant and so in this essay, however to prevent repeating the same argument, i decided to examine another aspect of the issue by taking the focus from the foetus and placing it upon the woman, whose personhood and right to life and bodily autonomy are not at all questionable or worthy of debate. In doing so it becomes clear that granting legal personhood to a foetus cannot be done without greatly infringing upon the rights of women, and so abortion is morally permissible and should be readily available for those women who do not seek to assume the responsibility of a pregnancy or fulfill the role the role of mother, because a woman’s right to her own body outweighs that of another being, and it would be immoral to disallow it because of the consequences that would emerge from treating a foetus as an equal person.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Abortion Should Be Morally Permissible Essay

- Abortion should be morally permissible, in most cases, because a woman’s right to her own body neutralizes the unfortunate circumstance of an aborted fetus. Abortion should only be impermissible if it is clear that a woman is getting multiple pregnancies and abortions without making an effort to use available contraceptives. A common argument against abortion is that killing someone is immoral. That is assuming that a fetus is a human being from the moment of conception. But can we really reach a clear consensus as to when a fetus actually becomes a person....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Human, Fetus]

Better Essays
2217 words (6.3 pages)

Abortion Is Morally Permissible? Essay

- In my previous essay, I fought that abortion is immoral, but can be countered against depending on the person and the situation given. My view has now changed to where abortion is morally permissible under circumstances. This change of views occurred after reading Warren, Thomson, and Marquis ' arguments throughout the course. Coming from a family and culture that shames a person who favors abortion, I solely believed abortion was immoral until taking this class. I wanted to clarify that my view on abortion is morally permissible if the pregnancy was affecting the mother 's wellbeing, financial stability, or if she does not feel prepared or lacks education to care for a child....   [tags: Pregnancy, Human, Abortion, Prima facie]

Better Essays
1031 words (2.9 pages)

Is Abortion Morally Wrong Or It Is Morally Permissible? Essay

- Abortion is a planned surgical means of ending the process of conception prior to the realm of a 40 week period. But conclusively we can draw the line at about 27 weeks to differentiate between the viability, or potential and current human life. Abortion is hands down one the most sought out and controversial topics in the modern day western society. The topic Starts conversations ends conversation furthermore starts arguments and so on; and it’s often looked at as a means of morality. Is abortion morally wrong or it is morally permissible....   [tags: Morality, Human, Ethics, Utilitarianism]

Better Essays
1496 words (4.3 pages)

Is Abortion Morally Permissible or Not? Essay

- ... Don Marquis spearheads the potentiality argument in his essay on the immorality of abortion (Study Guide, pp. 167-73), claiming that it is impermissible because it deprives the foetus of a “future like ours,” and is consequently morally on par with killing a healthy adult (Study Guide, p. 170). Despite Marquis’ claims that his argument combines the best aspects of the personhood and sanctity of life ideas to produce a superior ethical theory on the immorality of abortion (Study Guide, p. 170), his argument features many flaws, including seemingly ad hoc explanations to avoid speciesism (Study Guide, p....   [tags: conservative and liberal, pros and cons]

Better Essays
1311 words (3.7 pages)

Abortion Is Morally Permissible Essay

- It is almost unanimously agreed upon that the right to life is the most important and sacred right possessed by human beings. With this being said, it comes as no surprise that there are few issues that are more contentious than abortion. Some consider the process of abortion as immoral and consisting of the deprivation of one’s right to life. Others, on the opposite end of the spectrum, see abortion as a liberty and a simple exercise of the right to the freedom of choice. Those who adamantly oppose abortion are regarded as pro-life and those who are supporters of abortion are considered pro-choice by contemporary standards....   [tags: Argumentative Essay, Pro-choice]

Better Essays
2044 words (5.8 pages)

Is Abortion Morally Permissible On The Grounds That A Fetus Is Not A Person

- Mary Anne Warren contends that abortion is morally permissible on the grounds that a fetus is not a person. In her eyes, although, fetuses are genetically distinct humans they are not people because they do not have the necessary characteristics for personhood: sentience, reasoning, emotionality, the capacity to communicate, self-awareness, and moral agency. For her, the lack of these characteristics do not necessarily allude that a fetus is not a person only that it belittles the confidence that they are a person- or in other words creates doubt of their personhood....   [tags: Emotion, Feeling, Personality psychology]

Better Essays
1507 words (4.3 pages)

Should Abortion Be Morally Wrong? Essays

- Abortion In this paper I will explain Judith Thomson’s argument that abortions are not morally wrong under the condition that the fetus is considered a person. By setting this condition, Thomson advances the argument on why abortions are morally permissible by getting past the triviality of whether the fetus is a person or not. I will explain three cases she presents in which she argues that an abortion is morally justified: (1) It is not wrong to abort a pregnancy that resulted from rape (2) It is not wrong to perform an abortion in order to save the mother’s life (3) In many cases, it is not wrong to abort if the pregnancy resulted from protected, consensual sex and does not threaten the m...   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Birth control]

Better Essays
1829 words (5.2 pages)

Essay Is Abortion Morally Right?

- Abortion is the termination of human pregnancy, which usually happens in the first twenty-eight weeks of pregnancy. There are many causes of abortion. Some are spontaneous, which might because of the physical constitution of the pregnant women; some are induced by surgical or medical means. Normally, spontaneous abortion are not considered to be morally problematic. However, induced abortion is an intensely controversial issue. Is induced abortion morally right. Some people think that induced abortion for any reason is murder, while others believe that the mothers’ right carry more moral weight than the fetuses’ right....   [tags: Abortion, Pregnancy, Fetus, Human]

Better Essays
1615 words (4.6 pages)

Essay about Abortion Is Morally Wrong?

- In discussions of abortion, a controversial issue has been whether abortion is morally permissible. According to anti-abortionists, abortion is the killing of an innocent fetus and is therefore not morally permissible. According to Judith Jarvis Thomson, however, abortion is not morally wrong in most cases and she attacks the anti-abortionist argument. Therefore, they disagree on whether abortion is morally permissible or not. In this paper, I will outline the anti-abortionists argument in numbered premise-conclusion form and show which premise Thomson attacks....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Human, Trolley problem]

Better Essays
1580 words (4.5 pages)

Abortion Permissible Of Abortion Essay

- Many are inclined to believe that the fetus has become a human being even right before birth and being brought into the world. A controversial topic around that surrounds the world, is the act of abortion permissible. Philosophers have seen this idea and tried to understand when in face is abortion permissible. Philosopher, Judith Jarvis Thompson, in her piece, “A Defense Against Abortion” explores the premise is abortion permissible in all cases. Throughout Thompson’s piece she draws multiple analogies to make her argument be seen through a different perspective....   [tags: Pregnancy, Abortion, Fertility, Sexual intercourse]

Better Essays
1470 words (4.2 pages)