Internal Disunity Theory Of War Essay

Internal Disunity Theory Of War Essay

Length: 1133 words (3.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The next theory, while still relying on the realist principles of power maximization, turns it on the Power Transition Theory on its head. Instead of two exceptionally strong states competing for domination, it focuses on weak states struggling to appear strong, so they will not be dominated. This theory is the most original of those included in this document, it combines elements of the internal disunity theory of war with the need of states to project power in an anarchic international system. In a predictive context, it can be referred to as the Theory of Overcompensation. In the specific application to the First World War it could be aptly referred to as “The Weak East Theory” because its base assertion is that in 1914, the traditional European powers in the East, the Romanov Russian and Hapsburg Austrian Empires were in their last throes, struggling to stay relevant.
By 1900, the Habsburg dual monarchy of Austria-Hungary was a shadow of its former grandeur. Meanwhile it struggled with the growth of nationalism among the dozens of ethnic groups within its borders. Both desire for independence and Pan-Slavic sentiment was growing among its significant Czech, Slovak, Polish, and Serbian populations. It was no small wonder how the empire was holding together, but we do know it had little to do with strong leadership. In Why Nations Go to War, John Stoessinger describes Franz Ferdinand, the reigning Hapsburg monarch, quite dismissively as “an exhausted old man” (Stoessinger, 7).
According to Blackbourn on the eve of war “the mood of Vienna was one of frustration and fatalism quickened by bellicosity” (Blackbourn, 345) This Vienna could not afford to let the assassination of its crown prince occur without a strong response. It had ...

... middle of paper ...

...ories discussed in the essay serve to completely explain the First World War. Each paints part of the picture, providing a necessary cause for the conflict while failing to provide a sufficient cause for the entirety of the conflict. The Power Transition Theory’s reliance on an often-dismissed assertion of British hegemony and glossing over of the July Crisis leaves it the weakest of the three theories discussed. The Nationalism Theory’s broad strokes explanation for the conflict may be well suited to the works of historians, but fails to encompass the predictive value pursued by political scientists. The Overcompensation Theory, while the least definitive of the three theories, overcomes the greatest deficits of the other theories through its focus upon the Eastern European political landscape where the war actually began and its ability to predict future conflict.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Cold War : The Ideological Theory

- Searching for the cause of the Cold War is a difficult task for anyone. The task becomes infinitely more challenging when you incorporate why it stayed cold and how it eventually ended. With so many theories behind these three topics it is ignorant to say, for example, that it simply started in 1947 and ended in 1991. There are many variable prior to 1947 that makes the origin difficult to pinpoint. In this essay, I will be focusing on multiple theories, illustrated by Professor Datta, professors speaking at the Council on Foreign Relations (CFR) event, and Leon Aron....   [tags: Cold War, World War II, Communism, Soviet Union]

Strong Essays
819 words (2.3 pages)

The Just War Theory Essay example

- MEDIA AND WAR The Just War theory has some moral contents, but it is significantly pragmatic in its character and application. Both sides of a war want to claim that their causes are just. They frame the war aims as ‘just’ to achieve support of the public and the international community. Even Generals project the justness of the war which tends the soldiers to fight longer and fiercer against the enemy. Hence, ‘justness’ or ‘rightness’ of a war are important for any military intervention....   [tags: war. media, rightness]

Strong Essays
1750 words (5 pages)

Understanding the Theory of Cognitive Dissonance Essays

- The human psyche frequently experiences the phenomena of internal contradiction, followed by an internal struggle for some semblance of balance or consistency (Hall, 1998). Cognitive dissonance acts as motivation for people to behave in a manner that effectively reduces said dissonance and restores balance. Leon Festinger’s theory of cognitive dissonance explores this occurrence and the subsequent actions that people take in order to create a balance between their ideals. Cognitive dissonance looks at the way people combat contradictions within their minds by actively seeking consistency....   [tags: Internal Contradiction, Internal Struggle]

Strong Essays
1415 words (4 pages)

Essay on The Aims of Internal Marketing

- The aims of internal marketing: Many commentators and marketing theorists have over the years been trying to provide a precise definition of the concept of internal marketing. Their efforts in doing so proved to be unsuccessful due to the development of different schools of thoughts with different opinions as to what constitutes internal marketing. Be that as it may; Wilson et al (2008, p.280); Describe internal marketing as; “A complex combination of strategies needed to ensure that service employees are willing and able to deliver quality services and that they stay motivated to perform in customer orientated, service minded ways.” They go on to suggest that; “By approaching human resourc...   [tags: Business, Employees, Internal Customers]

Strong Essays
1014 words (2.9 pages)

Theory of War Essay

- Theory of War The Theory of War is an ideology of what is acceptable in the context of war which covers aspects of war including reasonable cause, treatment of prisoners, what kind of tactics are aloud, and so. All of these are split in to two different categories; with one being the right to go to war, and the conduct of war. Many influences of the Theory of War include many Christian ideals which can reflect religions impact on the world. Some of the first known ideas that relate to the Theory of War date back to 400 BCE with the Mahabrarata, an Indian epic which doesn't directly establish war theory but lays down some of the principles of war theory in concern with how war should be co...   [tags: Treatment of Prisoners, World War II]

Strong Essays
1158 words (3.3 pages)

Ambrose Bierce on War Theory Essay

- Brother against brother, neighbor against neighbor. The Civil War set a new precedent of warfare. One of the Union solders, Ambrose Bierce, wrote a collection of short stories based on his personal experience. Do his writings reflect that the Civil War was a just war by following just war theory. Bierce’s writings help reflect that the Civil War was unjust because the war was not conducted by a legitimate authority, the war was not conducted with the right attitude, and the war was not a last resort....   [tags: The Civil War]

Strong Essays
1438 words (4.1 pages)

Fire, Furor and Internal War Essay

- Psappo’s poetry was the model from which ancient cultures defined love. Her views on love have influenced many works of literature, including The Aeneid of Virgil. Love is an uncontrollable force that strikes an individual from the outside and can occur suddenly as well as unexpectedly. Love is often depicted as a positive emotion that causes people to feel blissful, but this can easily turn into furor; furor is the aspect of love associated with violence and insanity. Dido’s love for Aeneas exemplifies the internal turmoil that afflicts individuals when they are deprived of the love that they crave so ardently....   [tags: Literary Analysis]

Strong Essays
1187 words (3.4 pages)

The Cold War Is The Domino Theory Essay

- The possibility of a nuclear war laid on the hearts and minds of American officials every day during the period known as the Cold War. With the slightest miscalculation of Soviet intentions or erred judgement in communist maneuvers America could have been thrust into a war with the Soviet Union an equally dangerous nuclear nation. In some ways the knowledge that both sides possessed enough nuclear weapons to destroy the world helped contain the situation but in other ways it only added more strain to the enormous pressure....   [tags: World War II, Cold War, Nuclear weapon]

Strong Essays
924 words (2.6 pages)

Just war theory Essay

- The idea of war and how it can be justified, is a rather trick topic to touch on, as there are diverse ethical and sociological implications that have to be weighed on every step. Mainly we could look at the “Just War Theory” and see how that could possibly apply to the real world. To be able to enter a “Just War” nations must meet six criteria in Jus ad Bellum (Going to War). The criteria is as follows: “Just Cause”, “Right Intention”, “Proper Authority and Public Declaration”, “Last Resort”, “Probability of Success”, and lastly “Proportionality”....   [tags: US, civil war, UN, UNSC]

Strong Essays
1005 words (2.9 pages)

Internal and External Violence Essay examples

- Internal and External Violence Specific time periods, such as World War II, and the Post-Civil War era bring to mind images of hate, death, and violence. Not solely external violence or violence that is carried out, such as murders, war, or blatant displays of violence such as those in Ellison’s Battle Royal, but internal violence as well. Internal violence is more about the mind, a violence of emotion, though internal violence is closely linked to external violence. They are linked not only because external violence causes internal violence, but also because of the reverse....   [tags: Violent Violence Internal External Essays]

Strong Essays
1473 words (4.2 pages)