Inmates and Organ Transplants: An Ethical Dilemma Essay

Inmates and Organ Transplants: An Ethical Dilemma Essay

Length: 860 words (2.5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In today’s medical field there is a profuse amount of room for ethical questioning concerning any procedure performed by a medical professional. According to the book Law & Ethics for Medical Careers, by Karen Judson and Carlene Harrison, ethics is defined as the standards of behavior, developed as a result of one’s concept of right and wrong (Judson, & Harrison, 2010). With that in mind, organ transplants for inmates has become a subject in which many people are asking questions as to whether it is morally right or wrong.
In the ABC News article entitled Death-Row Inmates Seeks Organ Transplant by Bryan Robinson, the issue of a death-row prisoner in Oregon, by the name of Horacio Alberto Reyes-Camarena, receiving priority over a law-abiding citizen for a kidney transplant is being addressed. The state pays for Reyes-Camarena’s medical care, so it allows him to be placed ahead of others who have not broken any laws but simply cannot afford the procedure or the medication needed after the operation due to little or no insurance coverage. “That has outraged crime victim advocates, who cannot understand how the justice system can “reward” convicted murderers at the expense of innocent patients” (Robinson).
Any given state has to provide medical care to its prisoners regardless of the reason the inmate is incarcerated. In an article by the Medical Ethics Advisor, Richard Demme, an associate professor and chair of the Ethics Committee at the University of Rochester, NY Medical Center states, “the U.S. Supreme Court has determined that withholding medical treatment from those who are incarcerated is cruel and unusual punishment, because prisoners are not allowed to seek healthcare for themselves. The court did not say which treatme...

... middle of paper ...

...her (Robinson).A person’s moral values [i.e. family, culture, society] serve as the basis for ethical conduct (Judson, & Harrison, 2010).This allows for many different issues and answers when dealing with this or any other ethical dilemma. If states continue to provide inmates with priority when it comes to organ transplants the cost of prisoner medical expenses will only increase, potentially causing serious economic problems in the future.

Works Cited

Judson, K, & Harrison, C. (2010). Law & ethics for medical careers. New York, NY: The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc.

Organ transplants for inmates. (2011). Medical Ethics Advisor, Retrieved from

Robinson, B. (n.d.). Death-row inmate seeks organ transplant. Retrieved from

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Is Organ A Ethical Dilemma? Essay

- Organ transplantation has saved countless lives throughout the world. Most donors are victims of terrible accidents who have left directives with their loved ones to harvest their organs if they are mortally injured so that someone else can live. Kidney transplants, however, can take place without the death of the donor. Consequently, an ethical dilemma occurs over the selling of healthy kidneys. Should human, transplantable organs be sold to benefit a patient’s family, or in the case of kidneys, to benefit the person who sells one of his healthy kidneys....   [tags: Kidney, Nephrology, Organ transplant]

Better Essays
1726 words (4.9 pages)

Organ Transplantation : An Ethical Or Unethical Appeal? Essay

- In each country of the world, many patients and families continue to wait for a light of hope. Whether it is a liver or kidney organ donation individuals who obtain a transplant have a new opportunity to live and enjoy life. In recent years the buying and selling of organs have formed strong controversies. Many continue to develop strong positive and negative opinions and wonder if the selling and buying of organs are strongly an ethical or unethical appeal. To begin with, the buying and selling of organs slowly have become an important concept in the field of healthcare and medicine....   [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Organ]

Better Essays
1913 words (5.5 pages)

Organ Donation As Ethical And Unethical Essay

- Organ Donation Donna Vega West Coast University Abstract Organ donations plays a major role in health care today. With thousands of people all across the United States in need of an organ transplant, organ donations have become a benefit. Unfortunately, there is a shortage of organ donors because of the myths and facts associated with organ donation. With many people being placed on a waitlist, there are very few people willing to be donors. In addition, factors such as complications during surgery, incompatibility between donor and recipient, and surgical procedures can inhibit the likelihood of one undergoing organ donations....   [tags: Organ transplant, Organ donation, Immune system]

Better Essays
1818 words (5.2 pages)

Ethical Dilemmas Of The Los Angeles Police Department Essay

- When somebody sees how moral difficulties are illustrated it gets to be conceivable to well-spoken methodologies to dispense with. The moral bursts of conduct performed by those inside of general society security areas. Cures of moral conduct with respect to cops start first with the choice and employing of experienced people. Police office ought to no more effectively discover "work-round" of least enlisting norms to select an individual from an uncommon hobby. Lawyer General Eric Holder as of late demonstrated as to Dayton, Ohio Police Department....   [tags: Morality, Ethics, Ethical dilemma, Police]

Better Essays
1216 words (3.5 pages)

Hypothetical Treatment of Ethical Dilemma Essay

- This paper is an analysis of a hypothetical vignette in which a counselor-in-training named Callie, a fairly experienced and nearly-licensed counselor supervisee, approaches her counselor supervisor for advice and direction regarding an ethical dilemma. The purpose of this paper is to identify the ethical and legal implications of the dilemma along with an optimal solution to ethically resolve the issue. Using the Forrester-Miller and Davis Decision Making Model Ethical dilemmas are situations that are difficult to navigate and include making a difficult choice....   [tags: Doctoral Student Ethical Scenario]

Better Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Essay on The Debate Of Organ Transplantation

- I am very interested in the topic of Organ transplantation. I am interested in biology and the process of surgeries. What intrigues me is the process of saving someone’s life in such a dramatic and complicated process. My dad happens to be a doctor and in his training he cut open a human body to see for himself the autonomy of the body. So being interested in the field of medicine is in my blood. Modern technology helps many people and saves people around the globe. However even with modern technologies that progress mankind, bio medical and ethical dilemmas emerge....   [tags: Organ transplant, Organ, Immune system]

Better Essays
1198 words (3.4 pages)

Essay on Blood is Thicker than Water in Ethical Dilemma

- ... Without airing too much, I will say there are two sides to my brother; the side he shows my family and the other side which I consider to be his true side. I have reason to believe that once my parents pass away; my relationship with him will be non-existent. I became aware of underhanded behavior concerning him during the divorce. He was hiding large quantities of money, alleging to give up his business so his income would be less resulting in less child support owed, and there were numerous accounts of him manipulating my sister-in-law into an uncontested divorce that would be detrimental to her....   [tags: dilemma, relationship, brother]

Free Essays
673 words (1.9 pages)

Essay on Organ Donation : A Viable Candidate For An Organ Transplant

- The first successful organ donation was in the last 50 years (7), and since then institutions have set up many regulations and processes that have saved many lives by allowing people to donate their organs, but government policies in the United States have set up laws that prevents individuals to make choices about their own bodies. When a person is in need for an organ due to being extremely ill for having a failing organ, doctors assess whether or not that person is eligible for a transplant (7)....   [tags: Organ donation, Organ transplant, Organ, Hospital]

Better Essays
1317 words (3.8 pages)

Essay on Ethical Dilemmas : Ethical Dilemma

- Ethical Dilemma Introduction Most organizations with their management team, as well as their employees, are usually challenged with ethical decision making in their daily activities. This arises due to conflicting circumstances involving moral values, ethical practices as well as legal perspectives. For instance, employees may be stuck in making a morally acceptable decision due to conflicting ethical consideration to their professional practice. Even though ethical dilemma situations may be rampant in business organizations, it can be mitigated by maintaining moral integrity through following some set of code of ethics....   [tags: Ethics, Morality, Virtue, Integrity]

Better Essays
1178 words (3.4 pages)

Ethical And Legal Aspects On Organ Transplantation Essay

- Ethical And Legal Aspects On Organ Transplantation Recent reports of public figures receiving life-saving transplants have brought renewed attention to the scarcity of organs and the importance of organ transplants. Although more transplants are being performed in the United States each year the transplant waiting list continues to grow. It has been considered that the decrease in organ donors is due to the unsuccessful measures taken by health care professionals. This is a limited view of the matter because health care professionals are not directly responsible for the policies and other guidelines for procuring organs....   [tags: Organ Donation Donor Essays]

Better Essays
6402 words (18.3 pages)