Honor Killings : The Shafia Family Essay

Honor Killings : The Shafia Family Essay

Length: 2244 words (6.4 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Strong Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

HOW DOES TWO CULTURES CLASING LEAD TO MURDER?
HONOR KILLINGS - THE SHAFIA FAMILY.
Honor killings are acts of retribution, frequently causing death. These acts are often committed by the male family members against female family members. Victims of honour killings are believed to have brought dishonor or shame upon the family. In 2007, a study by Dr. Amin Muhammad and his colleague, Dr. Sujay Patel of Memorial University, Canada, researched how the tradition of honor killings was brought to Canada The report highlighted that ‘’When people come and settle in Canada they can bring their traditions and forcefully follow them. In some cultures, people feel some boundaries are never to be crossed, and if someone would violate those practices or go against it, then killing is justified to them’’ (Leaders-Post, 2007). The Shafia family homicide is a perfect example of culture crisis leading to crime. The tragic murders really emphasize all the key aspects of how two cultures clashing can lead to murder.
On June 30th, 2009 Zainab Shafia (19), Sahar Shafia (17), Geeti Shafia (13) and Rona Amir Mohammed (50), bodies were pulled out of a black Nissan Sentara at Kingston Mills Locks. Zainab, Sahar and Geeti were the daughters of Mohammad Shafia (58) and Tooba Mohammad Yahya (41). The couple also had son Hamed (18) and 3 younger children. Rona Amir Mohammad was Mohammed Shafia’s first wife; the marriage became incredibly bitter after she was discovered to be infertile. Mohammad Shafia was a fortunate business man who bought him and his family’s way into Canada in 2007 under the federal investor’s immigrant program. They all lived in polygamous household in Montréal, Canada. Originally from Afghanistan Moh...


... middle of paper ...


...uments of the Shafia family murder trial.
Retrieved November 16, 2014, from http://www.ctvnews.ca/facts-and-arguments-of-the-shafia-family-murder-trial-1.760461


The Leaders Post (Ed.). (2007, June 27). Cultural 'honour ' killing brought to Canada.
Retrieved November 25, 2014, from http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/story.html?id=d05e437f-4661-4965-9455-ff30c6b9d4a5


News, C. (2012, January 29). Key players in Shafia trial react to verdict. Retrieved
November 22, 2014, from http://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/montreal/key-players-in-shafia-trial-react-to-verdict-1.1269600


The House of Shafia [Motion picture]. (2012). Canada: CBC News, Fifth Estate.
http://www.cbc.ca/fifth/episodes/2011-2012/the-house-of-shafia


Adler, F., Laufer, W., Mueller, G., & Grekul, J. (2012). Criminology  (Second Canadian
ed., p. 365). Library and Archives Canada Cataloguing.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Honor As A Islamic People Essay

- Honor is one of the many things that cannot have one accepted definition, it and its meaning change from person to person, culture to culture, time period to time period. A definition for honor that is generally accepted is that it has to do with high respect and nobility. This, however, only raises more questions. What do different peoples, different cultures, or even people of different times think of honor. These are some of the questions that we will answer, or at least try to. In this report, we will go over what honor is within other periods of time (including modern day), what it is within different cultures, describe what honor is to an American, and compare this American honor to th...   [tags: United States, Culture, Islam, Douglas MacArthur]

Strong Essays
957 words (2.7 pages)

Essay about Islamic Traditions and Norms

- There are many traditions and norms in religious culture. In Islam specifically, there are traditions and actions that are normal in Islamic societies, but may seem unorthodox to western nations. These are cultural differences that societies eventually get used to and accept, but there are certain practices that are morally wrong in all forms and goes against basic human rights. This issue and practice is honor killing, where women in families are murdered for bringing dishonor to the household....   [tags: culture, honor killing, religion]

Strong Essays
880 words (2.5 pages)

Honor Killings : The Value Of Your Reputation Essays

- Honor Killings: The Value of your Reputation over your Family Arbab Khatoon, 16, was stalked and raped by three men. Seven hours after Arbab reported this to the police her father stabbed her over and over again until she died. His reasoning. “My daughter lost her virginity before marriage. Rape does not justify that at all. Arbab brought dishonor to our family and needed to pay for it” (Chesler). The “category” this murder falls under is an Honor Killing. Honor Killings have been seen worldwide and continue to grow in the amount of victims....   [tags: Islam, Middle East, Sharia, Qur'an]

Strong Essays
1876 words (5.4 pages)

Honor Killings in Our History Essay

- Honor Killings Would you kill for the sake of preserving your honor. Some parents would go as far as killing their very own children in order to keep their family name pristine. Approximately five thousand women are murdered in honor killings every year according to the United Nations. However, according the women advocacy groups about twenty thousand women are killed annually. Honor killings are murders committed by those in a person’s family toward those who are believed to be bringing upon dishonor to the family....   [tags: reputation, family, parents ]

Strong Essays
727 words (2.1 pages)

Blood Cleans Honor, or So We Are Told Essay

- ... While few girls are able to escape if they are to be killed in an honor killing, “Betrayed” by Latifa Ali, tells the true story of Latifa Ali as she is escaping from her father who would have her killed in honor because she is not a virgin. In “Betrayed” Ali tells the story of Pela, a girl who was killed. Pela’s family thought that Pela was not a virgin so they killed her. After being inspected it was found that she was still a virgin. Ali continues to describe this as “murder, as plain as that” (Ali 257)....   [tags: honor killings in Irak]

Strong Essays
1196 words (3.4 pages)

The Issue With Honor Killings Essay

- Around the world there are many situations that the human race has to deal with and one of them is honor killings. This is an issue that has not been completely touched upon because it is not and an issue that everyone gets to see. The main idea is to understand what an honor killing is and what’s its status around the world but specifically to the country that is Pakistan. One main point that should be remembered is that it is all based off of tradition and not religion. A honor killing is a violent action towards a person that has brought shame or dishonor to their family (What Is Honor Killing)....   [tags: Pakistan, Crime, Tradition]

Strong Essays
1612 words (4.6 pages)

The Horror of Honor Killings Essay

- Women have the right to live their own life the way that they please. Women are not properties, nor are they incompetent. Women have the same opportunities to thrive in society as does any male, but some customs and traditions of some cultures prevent women from soaring to such heights. Culturally traditional men want complete dominion over their women. But who can blame them, it’s how they were raised and these things have been rooted in them since they were young children. When one thinks of a culture’s virtue, they automatically think of women’s behavior within her family context....   [tags: women, sexuality, murder]

Strong Essays
1224 words (3.5 pages)

The Issue Of Honor Killings Essay

- part of the world” (Women in the Sun 5). He also brought together 400 women and discouraged them from listening to the Women’s Model of Parliament, which encourages women to end the hostility women face. Unfortunately, protests against this film for being Islam phobia caused this film to end it’s broadcast. Honor Diaries, produced 2014, focused on the treatment of women in Muslim majority countries, specially the issue of honor killings. The film was based on the narratives of nine women, activists for women’s rights in Muslim committees in various parts of the world....   [tags: Islam, Qur'an, Muhammad, Women's rights]

Strong Essays
1129 words (3.2 pages)

Essay on Honor Killings

- Honor Killings Human rights violations against women have, for too long, been denied the attention and concern of international organizations, national governments, traditional human rights groups and the press. Meanwhile, hundreds of millions of girls and women around the world continue to endure debilitating and often fatal human rights abuses. These are only a few instances of abuse which occur every single day all around the world. Human rights violations against women must be documented, publicized and stopped....   [tags: Violence Death Murder Honor Women Essays]

Free Essays
2129 words (6.1 pages)

Essay about Honor Killings

- Honor Killings For thousands of years women have been looked down upon in society and have not been treated as equals. It wasn’t very long ago that women in America weren’t allowed to have jobs or vote, men were always the leaders. Just tonight my father was saying how when he was growing up if you talked back to your father or husband you would be punished, and that was only about thirty or forty years ago. I believe that today’s American woman take their freedom for granted. In some cultures women still do not have the privilege of being considered an equal and have no rights....   [tags: Papers]

Strong Essays
534 words (1.5 pages)