Freedom Of Speech Threatened On Campus Essay

Freedom Of Speech Threatened On Campus Essay

Length: 1745 words (5 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Better Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

In the debate, “Freedom of Speech Threatened on Campus”, four panelist argued either in favor or against the motion. In this case the winners of this debate where the pro side due to their good use of supporting arguments. As for the opposing team they lost audience support due to their weak presentation of arguments. This paper will focus on one of the opposing panelist whose arguments were unsupported. Shaun Harper the Director of the center for the study of Race & Equity in Education, of the University of Pennsylvania argued that freedom speech is not threatened in universities by speech codes rather students who are judging does students voicing their opinion are the ones who are threating their freedom of speech. In order to understand Harper’s opinion it’s important to analyze his arguments. Harper began his speech by introducing to the audience a situation a student encounter where some people could have interpreted as a violation to that students rights. The student by the name of Damien attended a university whose most of its student population is of the white descent. Damien and six of his classmates receive perfect scores on a test which excuse them from class and from the rest of the test. As the students existed Damien was the only one stop by the professor and question for his score due to his color. Harper emphasize that Damien did not say anything to his professor even though he faces humiliation in front of his peers. These types of situation are seen in many universities that Harper attends. Based on Damien’s story Harper concluded that Damien’s rights where the ones affected not the professors. Continuing with his debate, he talked about how one of the students wrote a column about the Halloween party event. A...


... middle of paper ...


...
Harpers statements where unsupported making them unreliable according to our, “Rule for Arguments” book. His conclusion didn’t analyze the background of the argument making easy for the opposing team to win because they weren’t able to stand on their own. His argument about race discrimination blinded him from actually focusing on the real issue which was how the entire student body is affected. In one of his statements he believe that and email was not a form of the campus informing speech code but he lack the supporting arguments to prove this true. Also in his argument about people wanting to engage with others about was easily was countered with examples of situations where this was not the case. After reading this debate I can conclude that Shaun Harper needed to provide better though out arguments in order for them to and them to be validated in this debate.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Freedom Of Speech And Expression

- Freedom of Speech and Expression Although we are guaranteed freedom of speech in our fundamental freedoms under section two of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, and freedom of expression under section two (b) of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, the Anti Terrorism Act infringes this right. Much of “political activity, including expression and activism that challenges government policy is and always has been a target of high policing in Canada.” (Larsen, M., 2015) Perhaps the government feels threatened by new ideas and does not want to be challenged....   [tags: Freedom of speech, Censorship, Freedom of thought]

Better Essays
879 words (2.5 pages)

Should The First Amendment Violates Freedom Of Speech?

- College campuses have always been a hot spot for free speech arguments. Whether students are arrested for protesting the Vietnam War or getting expelled for using racial slurs, it all boils down to one common argument: the constitutional rights we have as American citizens according to the First Amendment. The First Amendment protects freedom of speech without prosecution, but some consider it a grey area. One major question that faces college campuses is, is it possible to create speech codes limiting the spread of offensive discourse that do not violate the First Amendment....   [tags: Freedom of speech]

Better Essays
867 words (2.5 pages)

Freedom of Speech

- College in America – A place of unrivaled independent thought and haven for those who wish to better themselves through higher learning – or is it. Unfortunately, our impression of college, especially those of naive high school students, is far from its actual reality. When entering college, we expect to embark on the journey of self-enlightenment and expression known as education, on which our forefathers established the opportunity for us to pursue, yet all too often are we met with restrictions on what we thought were the most basic of our rights....   [tags: liberties, college, consitution]

Better Essays
899 words (2.6 pages)

Essay on Media Attention For What Can Only Be Described As A Scandal

- On May 24th 2016 DePaul University, a prominent and private university in Chicago, Illinois, garnered some negative media attention for what can only be described as a fiasco. A student organized event, by the university’s College Republicans group, was violently interrupted and brought to a halt when Black Lives Matter protesters barged into the room the event was being held in. The point of contention, speaker Milo Yiannopoulos had made DePaul a stop on his Dangerous Faggot Tour. Yiannopoulos, a British Journalist for Breitbart News, openly gay conservative, and self proclaimed provocateur, is known for his stances against modern third-wave feminism and Black Lives Matter....   [tags: Freedom of speech]

Better Essays
1380 words (3.9 pages)

Essay on Academic Freedom Of Colleges And Universities

- Academic Freedom in Colleges & Universities: A Social Problem Academic Freedom in Colleges & Universities is a social problem in America. Academic freedom is the freedom of teachers and students to teach, study, and pursue knowledge and research without unreasonable interference or restriction from law, institutional regulations, or public pressure. Examples of barred topics can include recent controversies such as the shooting of Mike Brown, Yemen & the upcoming Presidential Election. In Academic Freedom, professors can question any subject....   [tags: University, Higher education, College]

Better Essays
1821 words (5.2 pages)

Freedom Of Speech On College Campuses

- In her op-ed, "In College and Hiding From Scary Ideas", Shulevitz discusses the idea behind freedom of speech on college campuses and how safe spaces are snuffing it out. Shulevitz uses multiple examples of problems that have arisen because of safe spaces at universities such as Brown University, Columbia University, and Oxford 's University 's Christ Church college. Debate cancellations, essay opinions that caused protest, and other situations involving freedom of speech that Shulevitz uses to back up her opinion that safe spaces are nothing but harm to college campuses....   [tags: Thought, Idea, University, Freedom of speech]

Better Essays
1094 words (3.1 pages)

The Freedom Of Speech By Robert Garmong

- The First Amendment protects the right of freedom of speech, which gradually merges into the modern perspective of the public throughout the history and present. The restriction over the cable TV and broadcast media subjected by the Federal Communications Commission violates the freedom of speech, irritating the dissatisfied public by controlling over what can be said on the air. Should the FCC interfere with the free speech of media. The discretion of content being presented to the public should not be completely determined by the FCC, but the public in its entirety which enforces a self-regulation with freedom and justice, upholding and emphasizing the freedom of speech by abolishing the h...   [tags: Freedom of speech]

Better Essays
1244 words (3.6 pages)

Political Correctness or Freedom of Speech

- The term political correctness (PC) has infringed on our freedom of speech by assuming that the populace is too ignorant to realize what appropriate speech is. This term is now as common in our society as the term, ‘freedom of speech’. It is incomprehensible how these two words have had such an effect on the manner in which our society communicates. The trend casts a negative view on our society by letting political views determine what is appropriate in our social sector. Political correctness, as applied in today’s society, seeks to control freedom of speech and poses a true danger to a free society....   [tags: Freedom of Speech]

Better Essays
1460 words (4.2 pages)

Freedom Of Speech : The Greatest Hockey Team Ever

- Freedom of speech allows us to freely express ideas, to worship in the way we choose, to agree and disagree with each other and to stay informed. As long as we don’t incite violence on others or any of the other things that the First Amendment does not protect us from, we are free to express ourselves as we wish. An individual can support or condemn anything they want; “don’t eat red meat, it’ll kill you”, “the president should be praised”, “the president should be impeached”, “the Chicago Blackhawks are the greatest hockey team ever.” These declarations can be well thought out, researched and fact-checked, or simply phrases repeated because they sounded good to whomever heard them at the ti...   [tags: Hate speech, Freedom of speech, Censorship]

Better Essays
852 words (2.4 pages)

Freedom of Speech: A Double-edged Sword

- Freedom of speech has been a topic of discussion for many years. Since democracy was established in many countries to provide safety and rights, freedom of speech has been one of the most important rights in any constitution. Freedom of speech constitutes a human right that all people should have and one that must be respected. As individuals, we are entitled to express our opinions, write, publish or communicate, and such expressions must be, if not shared, respected. Different countries have certain level of tolerance at the moment of executing this right....   [tags: Freedom of Speech]

Better Essays
807 words (2.3 pages)