Frankenstein's Origin: Assessing Thompson's Argument for the Creature's Literary Ancestors

Frankenstein's Origin: Assessing Thompson's Argument for the Creature's Literary Ancestors

Length: 1434 words (4.1 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview

The greatest modern stories often hail from ancient myths, and Mary Shelley's novel,
Frankenstein, proves no exception to this claim. Replete with references to John Milton's
Paradise Lost and the ancient Greek myth of Prometheus, the story of Frankenstein seems, in
many ways, very much like the Creature himself—which is to say, cobbled together from various
scraps of previously existing parts. Terry W. Thompson, however, argues convincingly that
scholars continue to ignore one of Frankenstein's most influential literary antecedents: the Greek
hero known as Hercules (Thompson 36). In his article, "'A Majestic Figure of August Dignity':
Herculean Echoes in Frankenstein," Thompson even goes so far as to list, point-for-point, the
story and character points that align the Creature with the Greek hero. All in all, Thompson
makes a compelling argument demonstrating the interconnectivity of literature. After offering a
brief summary of Thompson's article, I will next analyze the merits and flaws of his arguments
before finally demonstrating how his article serves as a useful template for examining the
influence of older art works on more modern art works.

Thompson begins his article by listing literary works mentioned by Mary Shelley in her
journals from 1815 and 1816 (36). Thompson seizes upon the story of Hercules as contained in
Ovid's The Metamorphoses—which Shelley, in her journals, claims to have read—as being one
among many interpretations of this myth that may have served as part of Shelley's inspiration for
the tale of Frankenstein (36). For the bulk of the article, then, Thompson builds on this initial
comparison, noting, for example, that just as Zeus marks the birth of Hercules with a m...


... middle of paper ...


...the
Creature parallel one another, Thompson convinces the reader that Shelley may indeed have
drawn on such myths while writing Frankenstein. Although Thompson fails to discuss the
differences between Hercules and the Creature—not to mention the overall significance of his
argument—his article nevertheless proves a useful tool for considering the ways in which
different works of art influence one another. The article helps us see how all art is connected,
and this understanding of influences empowers us to understand culture more fully.




Works Cited

Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein. New York: Penguin Books, 2003.

Thompson, Terry W. "'A Majestic Figure of August Dignity': Herculean Echoes in

Frankenstein." ANQ: A Quarterly Journal of Short Articles, Notes, and Reviews 17.3

(2004): 36-41. MLA International Bibliography. Web. 12 October 2010.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

Essay on The Big Bang Theory of the Origin of the Universe

- INTRODUCTION Since the beginning of time, people have wondered about why we are here, how we got here, and where we came from. Although many of these questions have not been answered, the question of where the universe we see today came from has been answered, or at least answered as well as possible with the technology available. Currently the leading theory for the origin of the universe is the Big Bang theory. Although some scientists still dispute this model for the development of the universe, the vast majority of scientists accept it as truth....   [tags: Origin of the Universe]

Powerful Essays
2982 words (8.5 pages)

Romanticism in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Essay

- Mary Shelley, with her brilliant tale of mankind's obsession with two opposing forces: creation and science, continues to draw readers with Frankenstein's many meanings and effect on society. Frankenstein has had a major influence across literature and pop culture and was one of the major contributors to a completely new genre of horror. Frankenstein is most famous for being arguably considered the first fully-realized science fiction novel. In Frankenstein, some of the main concepts behind the literary movement of Romanticism can be found....   [tags: Frankenstein]

Powerful Essays
2058 words (5.9 pages)

Literary Technique in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Essay

- Mary Shelley genially wrote Frankenstein. A book that has been re-told a countless number of times, a story that almost every child heard as they grew up, becoming almost an American tradition. Various aspects of the story even though fiction were reflections of Mary Shelley’s personal life. Shelley uses tragic and shocking events to develop her characters. The symbolism she uses is that of what happens in the world at all times, mirror images of our true society. Shelley’s writing was odd for her time period....   [tags: literary analysis, literary criticism]

Powerful Essays
711 words (2 pages)

Frankenstein is Not a Natural Philosopher Essay examples

- Smith’s article ‘Frankenstein and natural magic’ takes a literary approach to the analysis of ‘Frankenstein’ although this is supported by some background scientific knowledge. Through the article, Smith describes the impacts science has made on Frankenstein’s life . Smith plays close attention to Frankenstein’s childhood, where he discovered the ancient philosophers, and his Ingolstadt years. It is in these periods where Smith argues that Frankenstein is not a natural philosopher but a natural magician due to his affinity for the ancient natural sciences, the romantic genius he posses and by contrasting Frankenstein against traditional, enlightenment stereotypes of the natural philosophers...   [tags: Shelley Frankenstein Analysis]

Powerful Essays
1234 words (3.5 pages)

Frankenstein as a Modern Cyborg? Essays

- Frankenstein as a Modern Cyborg.      The creature ("demon") created by Victor Frankenstein in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein, or, The Modern Prometheus occupies a space that is neither quite masculine nor quite feminine, although he is clearly both created as a male and desires to be in the masculine role. Judith Halberstam describes this in-between-ness as being one of the primary characteristics of the Gothic monster--being in a space that's not easily classified or categorized, and therefore being rendered unintelligible and monstrous....   [tags: Frankenstein essays]

Powerful Essays
1534 words (4.4 pages)

The Myth of Prometheus in Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Essay

- Knowledge is a distinctively human virtue. After all, if not for the want of human beings to learn of and master our habitat, would we not still be counted among the beasts. For all of the good that knowledge brings to us, however, knowledge can just as easily bring pain. We discover new types of medicine to extend our lives, but that is balanced by our awareness of our mortality. We find new advances in technology with which to bring convenience into our lives, but those advances are countered by the resulting pollutions that are poisoning our world....   [tags: Frankenstein 2014]

Powerful Essays
2900 words (8.3 pages)

Origin of Religion Essay

- The origin of religion goes back to prehistoric times when the earliest people of China sought answers to the same basic questions that have baffled man over time: what is the unseen force that brings darkness and light, winters and summer, drought and rain, life and death: what must men do to appease this force (Schafter 60-61). Ancient China has three main religions: Taoism, Buddhism, and Confucianism. Confucius was concerned mostly with laws made by people and whether people were naturally good or naturally evil....   [tags: Essays on Origin of Religion]

Free Essays
746 words (2.1 pages)

Frankestein Essay

- Once landing on shore, evening has fallen. Light is transitory, and the wind is rising violently. The narrator becomes exceedingly anxious, and resolves that either the creature or he will die tonight. Elizabeth observes his agitation and questions him; Victor gives her a vague answer, saying that the night is dreadful. Believing that he can spare Elizabeth a grisly combat scene, he bids her to retire before him, that he might gain knowledge of the creature's whereabouts. He walks up and down, waiting....   [tags: Elizabeth Frankestein]

Free Essays
400 words (1.1 pages)

Essay on Frankenstein

- Great knowledge of the world and its mysterious ways is something many would love to have. With this great knowledge we have been able to find many of the technologies, medicines, and amazing works of art that we have today. But “evil” comes in hand with the power of such knowledge. In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein the powerful knowledge that Frankenstein possessed brought him nothing good but his end. His creation wasn’t something that was “good” or that brought him joy as he initially believed it would....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Mary Shelley]

Powerful Essays
1698 words (4.9 pages)

Frankenstein Essays

- “I am alone and miserable: man will not associate with me; but one as deformed and horrible as myself would not deny herself to me” (Shelley 127). A monster with bad intentions generates a bad reputation in society. However, does a monster whose sole purpose is to achieve and excel treated wrongly because of the way he looks. According to John Bugg’s “Master of their language: Education and Exile” The creature’s narrative of education unfolds from a personal realization of alterity. Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein portrays the creature’s motivation to broaden his education in order to be accepted by society....   [tags: Literary Analysis, Mary Shelley]

Powerful Essays
1045 words (3 pages)