Examining of Estrich´s and Pineau´s Discussion on Rape Essay example

Examining of Estrich´s and Pineau´s Discussion on Rape Essay example

Length: 1473 words (4.2 double-spaced pages)

Rating: Powerful Essays

Open Document

Essay Preview


This essay will examine Susan Estrich’s and Lois Pineau’s discussion on rape. Both contribute insights on our society’s negligence when it comes to the protection and justice for women. Estrich provides a peak into the legal system on how it determines rape. We will see that the law is shaped in a way that continues to oppress women and leave them unprotected. Pineau furthers the conversation on placing responsibility on the victim to prove the crime. She narrows her focus on date rape and raises an objection to the model of consent that shapes our culture’s attitude and our country’s law. Pineau proposes a communicative model of sex. From this proposal, I will conclude my essay with an objection of her model and will ultimately defend her model against such an objection.
As Estrich demonstrates, the law on rape has major flaws. The law exposes traditions and attitudes that surround women and sex. It condones the idea that sex contains male aggression and female passivity. The law uses three different criteria to label an act of sex as rape: mens rea, force, and consent. Estrich feels that these features demonstrate sexist attitudes within the law. Our legal system abandon’s mens rea which is Latin for “guilty state of the mind.” It is the perpetrator’s ability to understand force and non-consent. A woman must demonstrate resistance. The man can escape by stating he did not realize the woman was not consenting. So, the court turns to the woman to see if she provided proper evidence that she did not consent to the sex.
Turning away from the defendant and looking at the victim’s actions makes the legal system seem rather sexist. Other than the obvious that it makes the woman rehash the terrible details of the...


... middle of paper ...


...leground that protects men and expects too much from women. It is the only type of case where the victim must show they did enough. When a person comes through the window and steals your TV, the victim does not have to prove meticulously that they did in fact lock and close all windows and doors. The justice system assumes that they are honest citizens and that the evidence of their testimony, lack of TV, and fingerprints is enough evidence. Our attitudes towards women suggests more than just lack of reform in our legal system, but also our overall problem with how we see women and their bodies. Our society just does not see a woman’s body as private property. Women have lost bodily autonomy, if they ever had it in the first place. It is a sad, sad world when people can sue companies for a hair in their food, but a woman cannot see justice when she is raped.

Need Writing Help?

Get feedback on grammar, clarity, concision and logic instantly.

Check your paper »

The Discourse Of Rape Culture Essay

- I have chosen to write my paper on the discourse of rape culture in Western society. I hope to break down the rhetoric of rape in the media and in everyday life to determine how it is framing people’s perceptions of sexual assault. A focus of my paper will by on my analysis of the conversations and ongoing themes in Kesha and Dr. Luke’s court battle. In summary, Kesha, a musician, is trying to break her recording contract on the grounds that Dr. Luke, her producer, sexually assaulted her and prevents her from recording and releasing music....   [tags: Feminism, Third-wave feminism, Rape]

Powerful Essays
1028 words (2.9 pages)

The Rape of Nanking Essay examples

- Throughout The Rape of Nanking, the brutal massacre of thousands of innocent Chinese citizens is brought forth through the invasion of this ancient city taken over by the Imperial Japanese army. Iris Chang illustrates the graphic details of the murder and rape of these victims through the perspectives of different sides of the attack. Chang; furthermore, ties in the mass genocide and destruction displayed throughout the book with the example of the Japanese government’s desperate attempt to cover up the incident and the reluctance of the survivors to discuss it....   [tags: Japan, Nanking]

Powerful Essays
1027 words (2.9 pages)

Why rape? Essay

- *Why rape?* The Rape, Abuse, and Incest National Network (RAINN) (2009) is the “The nation's largest anti-sexual violence organization.” According to this accredited anti-sexual violence charity, every two minutes someone in the United States is sexually assaulted. Furthermore, they report that approximately 1 in every 6 women has been the victim of an attempted or completed sexual assault. In 2003, 9 out of every 10 rape victims were female (RAINN). The statistics speak for themselves and support the theory that sexual assault is a prevalent issue in the United States....   [tags: Crime]

Powerful Essays
1168 words (3.3 pages)

Essay on Discussion of Margaret Atwood's Rape Fantasies

- Discussion of Margaret Atwood's Rape Fantasies The author of the short story Rape Fantasies is Margaret Atwood - She is a renowned Canadian writer of poetry and fiction, she is best known for her novel The Handmaids Tail. The short story that I chose Rape Fantasies comes from Atwood?s first collection of short stories called Dancing girls and Other Stories.      ?Remember no one can make you feel inferior without your consent.                               Eleanor Roosevelt           The story Rape Fantasies is about a bunch of females who are sitting around the lunch room during their lunch hour talking about fantasies that they consider to be called ?Rape Fantasies?....   [tags: Short Stories Rape Fantasies Essays]

Powerful Essays
1354 words (3.9 pages)

Rape, Racism, And Rape Essay examples

- ... Rape culture was brought up in this discussion and what we thought about it which was the same for pretty much everyone which was the stereotypes how women who dress sexy or slaughtered dressed somehow likelier to be raped and also younger women are more vulnerable to be rapped , A lot of Normalizing grabbing goes on. Men talk to women so normalizing men sense of entitlement to to discuss women body a way of life that normalizes more attractive women to violate . Also speaking about normalization the dress code for young ladies things they wear may sometimes put them at risk....   [tags: Rape, Sexual intercourse, Sexual assault, Gender]

Powerful Essays
832 words (2.4 pages)

Date Rape : Rape And Rape Essays

- DATE RAPE Introduction I’m assuming that you 've all heard of date rape. Apart from knowing what the physical side of rape is, there are many students who aren 't aware of the facts in depth of what really happens in these circumstances. So today I’m going to briefly talk about this. I‘m sure you’ll all agree with me that it’s quite scary at any time learning about date rape, but so much worse if you become a victim. No one wants to be a victim, so it’s important that we know about the drugs used and furthermore, what to do if you become a victim....   [tags: Rape, Date rape drug, Sexual intercourse]

Powerful Essays
1011 words (2.9 pages)

Rape Culture : Rape And Rape Essay

- Rape Culture Did you know that ninety-seven percent of rapists will never spend a day in jail. (RAINN) This fact is depressing considering the large percentage of rape victims. Things like rape and violence have a severe impact on the mentality level of people. Their lives will change forever after going through an intense situation such as being molested, beaten, or anything along those lines. It has caused people to commit the same crime, become severely depressed and suicidal, as well as many other unfortunate events....   [tags: Rape, Sexual intercourse, Sexual assault]

Powerful Essays
1065 words (3 pages)

Is Rape A Murder? Essay

- ... You had a great time, too.” Being drunk or under the influence does not mean that a person can take advantage of someone. To have someone force you against your will to do something is not acceptable. If a woman is unable to say no, than that is not her saying yes. The lack of consent is the absence of a “yes.” While being under the influence, one is not able to clearly decide if he or she is willing to give full consent to making such a life changing decision. The person unable to decide to have sex is the only person that can decide if they want to have sex or not....   [tags: Rape, Sexual intercourse, Sexual assault]

Powerful Essays
1205 words (3.4 pages)

Rape And Its Effects On Women Essay

- Rape is something that has been taken very seriously in the United States, or may I say in the world. There are many victims that play apart of this problem. Schools are taking charge and making sure that the safety of this issue is being set. What many don’t know is that Marital Rape is also a big that can happen to girls. There are people that pay no attention to this factor because there is a marital relationship between the two. Marital Rape is affecting many women physically and emotionally because of the lack of interest people have for it....   [tags: Rape, Marriage, Spousal rape, Woman]

Powerful Essays
761 words (2.2 pages)

Rape As A Rape Victim Essay

- We live in a world where we care more about a rape victim 's clothes than the fact that they were assaulted and it’s time we address that. No one cares about rape victims today. It’s old news; nothing but some exaggerated tale crafted by the dreaded feminazi. These cases are all too easy to dismiss―we have lots of practice at it. For example we’ve coined many phrases such as: they could have fought back. They should have walked a different street. They’re lying. Men can’t be raped they can defend themselves....   [tags: Rape, War rape, Rape culture, Sexual slavery]

Powerful Essays
1260 words (3.6 pages)