Why Is The Lottery By Shirley Jackson Wrong

1371 Words3 Pages

The morning of June 26, 1948 was clear and sunny, as people began to sit down with their morning coffee, to read The New Yorker. The issue released that day included the first published copy of Shirley Jackson’s short story “The Lottery,” The story about an ancient ritual stoning in a small modern town. According to Shirley Jackson’s biographer Ruth Franklin, “For the rest of her life, Jackson would receive letters demanding an explanation for “The Lottery” (Franklin). The letters made claims about Jackson calling her: “perverted” and “gratuitously disagreeable,” with “incredibly bad taste," "but the vast majority of the letter writers were not angry or abusive but simply confused. More than anything else, they wanted to understand what the …show more content…

The story is told from a third person perspective, making the gruesome ending unforeseeable and creating a bigger focus on the traditional reasoning behind the unfortunate death of Tessie Hutchinson. There is a heavy description of the rituals that are still in place and also attention is placed on the parts of the ritual that have been forgotten. The narrator explains, "The original paraphernalia for the lottery had been lost long ago, and the black box now resting on the stool had been put into use even before Old Man Warner, the oldest man in town, was born"(The Lottery). This account describes how ritual of the traditional stoning of a member of the town was lost to time. The narrator further states that, "Mr. Summers spoke frequently to the villagers about making a new box, but no one liked to upset even as much tradition as was represented by the black box" (The Lottery). This is the statement that underlies the moral of the story. The fact that society is more worried about upsetting tradition, than upholding a high moral practice, that is fair and justifiable to all. Jackson’s argument of senseless tradition is reiterated through the conversations held by the townspeople. In a conversation held between Mr. Adams and Old Man Warner, Mr. Adams brings up the fact that other towns have given up the lottery. Old Man Warner replies by describing the other towns as a, “Pack of crazy fools” (The Lottery) Old Man Warner further claims, “There’s always been a lottery”(The Lottery) Old Man Warner’s proclamations are taken by the younger members of the town as a good enough reason to uphold such a horrid tradition

Open Document