Why I Black John Mcwhorter Analysis

598 Words2 Pages

Black or African-American, it really doesn’t matter What's in a name? Apparently quite a lot, when it comes to matters of race. Today, in popular culture and journalistic discourse, the terms black and African-American are often used interchangeably, and neither has established a leg up over the other as the more progressive linguistic choice. But there are some people prefer to be called by only either one or another, and John H. McWhorter is an example for that. The title of his ineffective essay “Why I’m Black, not African American” has clearly pointed out his desire to show his true identity. But, his essay doesn’t persuasive me, to be called “African-American” is better than to be called “Black”. According to McWhorter, the term “African-American” is too negative and not represents who they really are, it is also said to set them (people who were ‘mistaken’ as African-American) far apart from their root …show more content…

But it just doesn’t enough; because using “Black” or “African American” is depend on each person, on when or where they feel to say it, or simply saying “Black” is because it is shorter and more concise. “African American” may sound a little bit loftier, but let’s imagine “an African American and an African American” then say a Black and a Black”. Besides, when meeting somebody who comes from Africa for the first time, we are more comfortable to use “African-American”, to show more respect and to prevent offensive comments. And secondly, we don’t really care about your history or who your ancestor was, when treating people all the same despite of their history is more important. To Erika Hall, a professor at Emory University, for white Americans, the term "black" contents the negative associations and lower perception of ability than

Open Document