Who Is Tabachnick's An Occurrence At Owl Creek Bridge

386 Words1 Page

In his article "A Possible Source for the Conclusion of Ambrose Bierce's 'An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge'", Steven Tabachnick explores an idea expressed by F.W. Boege in 1950. That idea, which appeared in an article entitled "Point of View in Dickens", was that an "interesting parallel" exists between the closing scenes of Bierce's "An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge" and Dickens's "A Visit to Newgate". Tabachnick points out that Boege provided no elaboration regarding these parallels and then expressed an intent do so himself. In the process, Tabachnick describes how the protagonists from both stories are awaiting execution when they dream of their wives and of escape. Ultimately, they both awaken to the realization that they still face death. Tabachnick describes Bierce's version as more dramatic, due to the readers' lack of awareness that Farquhar is dreaming and the immediacy of his execution. He points out that as a piece of fiction, "An …show more content…

That seems indisputable. While it appears highly plausible that these parallels are due to Dickens' influence on Bierce's work, I also find it conceivable that two authors independently came upon the same ideas. It is after all, common to speak of one's "life flashing before his/her eyes" right before death. In these last moments, those who are aware of their fate are often filled with thoughts and visions of the things they will be leaving behind. It seems likely that those images which would be the most pressing and prevalant would be those involving the person whom the condemned individual loves the most. What may be unique to these stories is how well the visions were described for the readers from the protagonist's perspective and how long they seemed to last. I find the idea that one was based on the other an interesting, but unconvincing

Open Document