Claude Monet Water Lis Comparison

922 Words2 Pages

Nymphaeas, an aquatic flowering herb, has been a popular theme in literature, mythology and fine arts throughout history. It bore various symbols in many ancient cultures and have been deciphered by different artists in their own ways. In this essay two paintings of such will be evaluated: Water Lilies by Claude Monet (1840-1926) and Lotus by Chang Dai-chien (1901-1984).

Water Lilies, painted by French impressionist painter Claude Monet, is a collection of approximately 250 oil paintings of Monet's water-lily pond in Giverny, France. The artwork was composed of light vertical strokes and patches of bright colours, giving a grand perspective of scattered blossoms of water-lilies with a shimmer of light lingering with reflections from above. …show more content…

To achieve so, both pieces were constructed with an unseen light source from the top of the painting, allowing increased tonal contrast and luminosity while minimising half-tones as the shadows would appear as outlines of the subject. Evidence of such can be observed in the wide leaves: Monet painted ovals strokes of colours to illustrate lily pads, while Chang splashed patches turquoise water-ink amongst lines of leaf-stems. Little hue transitions were involved, as most colours came in discrete …show more content…

Due to the cultural and philosophical implications embedded in the painting, it appears that few individuals have full access to Chang's inspirations when he painted Lotus. I am unfortunately not one of them. Knowing only the basics of traditional Chinese philosophy and having too little life experiences, I could appreciate the grace in the brush strokes, but find it slightly difficult to relate my own life to the intrinsic charms and wisdom of the artwork. Furthermore, it appears to me that Lotus is not as unique as Water Lilies. The flower is a such popular theme in Chinese literature and arts that it acquired a set character of tenderness, elegance and nobility that is highly praised in Chinese culture. Chang portrayed such qualities to perfection in many ways, but I would like his work more if it had more personal feelings in it.

Indeed, though having certain similar qualities, Water Lilies and Lotus had approached a common theme of Nymphaeas in divergent ways. I reckon this is due to different cultural backgrounds and personalities of Monet and Chang that they used varying materials and techniques to express their own philosophical inspirations upon the flowers. I admire both of their masterpieces greatly and I believe that they are both very beautiful in their own

Open Document