More handpicked essays just for you.
Ethical issues of tuskegee study
Detailed Knowledge of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study
Detailed Knowledge of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Ethical issues of tuskegee study
The Tuskegee experiment was an experiment that involved African American men and syphilis. It was hypothesized that African Americans reacted differently to syphilis than whites did. These men were brought into the experiment without knowing what was happening, that they had syphilis, or that there was a cure for it already established. Many of those in the experiment believed that it was "bad blood", and never heard it termed syphilis. The health care providers that were administering the experiment were whites as well as African Americans. The experiment lasted for 40 years before it was finally brought to the public attention. Over 3/4 of the participants had died from the fact they were not being treated. This caused mistrust among the
A simple definition of autonomy is that patients are able to participate and decide on treatments concerning their care (Edge and Groves, 2007). In other words, the patients have a voice. In the Tuskegee study, every man in the area was tested and later was put on a list that kept them from getting treatment, joining the war, and leaving town. The government doctors do not ask the men if they wanted to participate in the study. The nurse who participates in the study with the doctors is also forced to deny patient autonomy because of the government’s assumed authority over her. The doctors did not give the patients informed consent or allowed them to have a say in whether or not they wanted to stay in the study (Strait and Diianni, 2011). Because of gender and race, the nurse and black men were forced to stay in this study. Overall, this ethical principle was nonexistent.
When a person, who is a citizen of this country, thinks about civil rights, they often they about the Civil Rights Movement which took place in this nation during mid 11950s and primarily through the 1960s. They think about the marches, sit-ins, boycotts, and other demonstrations that took place during that period. They also think about influential people during that period such as Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Medgar Evers, John Lewis, Rosa parks, and other people who made contributions during that movement which change the course of society's was of life in America. In some people view, the Civil Rights Movement began when the Supreme Court rendered their decision in Brown vs. Education, or when Rosa Parks refused to give up her seat on a Bus and the Montgomery Bus-Boycott began. However, the Civil Rights Movement had already begun in several cities in the South. This was the case for the citizens of African descent of the city of Tuskegee.
Healthcare providers have an ethical obligation to tell their patients the truth about their conditions as well as all possible treatment options. In the Tuskegee Study, this obligation was blatantly disregarded. The characters Dr. Sam Brodus, Dr. Douglas, and Eunice Evers, RN are prime examples of this disregard for transparency between the provider and the patient.
Some of these scientists mainly did unethical experimentations on blacks by mistreating and abusing African American slaves, children, and the overall population of blacks just to gain more scientific studies. For example, Dr. Thomas Hamilton was said to be a southern gentlemen and known as a well-respected physician; however, Hamilton bought and raised slaves just for experimentation. One of Hamilton’s experimental victims was John Brown, where he burned him to the point of blisters, fainting, and flayed skin and also performed surgical torture on him (54). This example indicates that these praised upon doctors and these so called “health-care providers” were gaining the appraisal and the title of “providing for others” that they should not have because of their torturing experimentations done on blacks. Although these physicians came about multiple treatments and other beneficial research, they targeted specifically minorities and performed illegal actions on them in order to get their research results, which indicates the evilness presented in these doctors that many whites trust. Another example of a physician that was highly respected and praised for treating patients was James Marion Sims. Sims performed extremely cruel experimentations on black children and black women. For
Even to present day the there is still a bias among doctors when it comes to treating and diagnosing of black people.The things that kill black the most are preventable and curable Washington says“that blacks are not dying of exotic, incurable, poorly understood illness nor from a genetic disease that target them only but rather from common ailments that are more often prevented and treated among whites than among blacks”(Washington 2006). The most experiment that show how true this statement is the Tuskegee syphilis experiment sponsored by the government of the United States. In this famous experiment, black was infected with the bacteria that causes syphilis.This ...
This article exemplifies the prevalence of discrimination within the Tuskegee Airmen. There were nearly 1000 Tuskegee Airmen from 1941 to 1945 that came out of the Alabama Institute. Out of 1000 airmen, only 66 were killed in combat and another 33 were captured and used as prisoners throughout the war. They faced discrimination tremendously on the base. At one point, 104 Tuskegee Airmen were arrested for protesting against not being able to use military base facilities. The author also stated how this helped in the Brown vs. Board of Education case which helped pave the way for the civil rights movement. One famous quote that they generally went by was by pilot Harvey Alexander in which he mentioned, “[he] was aware of discrimination on the
The Tuskegee Study was carried in and around Tuskegee in Macon County, Alabama, from 1932 to 1972. The United States Public Health Service (USPHS) initiated the study to gather more information about the effects of untreated syphilis in African American males. The subjects comprised of 399 African American males who were presumably in the late stage of syphilis which was not contagious. These subjects only received some initial treatment after which they were kept on aspirin and iron tonic under the assurance of being treated. The study also consisted of 200 controls who were subjects without the disease. They, too, were cared for and administered similar medications. (Reverby, S.M., 2009)
The movie “The Tuskegee Airmen”, made in 1995, follows a African-American man, Hannibal Lee, as he gets accepted to be part of the Tuskegee Airmen. On his way to the base, he meets many black and white soldiers, training to become pilots for air battles. Lee made many friends and also enemies while staying at the base. The white soldiers are always putting down Lee and his comrades, saying how blacks can’t do anything to help the war. However, as World War II progresses, the African men prove to everyone that they can do the same thing as the white men, giving them a reputation as the Tuskegee Airmen. In the movie, these black men assisted their country while going through many discriminations and deaths of many friends.
The Tuskegee Syphilis study was a 40 year long experiment held by the U.S Public Health Service from years 1932-1972. The study put at risk the lives of many innocent black males, the study was for the disease Syphilis, Syphilis is an STD which is easily spread through unsafe sexual contact with a partner. “In the male negro”, The study had 600 illiterate black males 399 of those patients were not actually infected with the disease. Illiterate and uneducated males were used because of their lack of concern to their health, or rather not being concerned with what doctors said, for they were the ones who “knew all”. They trusted the doctors because they were the ones who were educated and supposedly knew more than the patients. The researchers withheld information that could’ve saved the test subjects from the disease and long
The Tuskegee Syphilis Study was conducted by the United States Public Health Service (USPHS) and involved the participation of 600 black men: 399 all of whom had contracted syphilis before being enrolled in the study, and 201 who did not have the disease (Schmidt & Brown, 2015, p. 33). While it is required by law to provide full disclosure of all aspects of a research study (informed consent) these men were misled by researchers and told they were being treated for “bad blood.” Additionally, penicillin treatment (found to be effective against syphilis) was withheld for research purposes (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, 2017, para. 2−5). With this in mind, these men were never told about the actual study or its real purpose and
The Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male, better known as the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment was a conducted clinical experiment created in 1932 by the U.S. Public Health Service to study the effects of untreated syphilis on 399 black men. The study severally affected hundreds of black families for 40 years. Many scientist and doctors have tried to justify the unethical reasoning for why the study was done to so many innocent people. I think that the overall reason was because the experiment could be kept under the radar if black lives were affected instead of white lives. From the very start of the experiment, the doctors knew the outcome syphilis would have on those men and they didn’t see any harm being done. “Syphilis is a highly contagious disease caused by the Treponema pallidum, a delicate bacterium that is microscopic in size and resembles a corkscrew in shape. The disease may be acquired or congenital. In acquired syphilis, the spirochete (as the Treponema pallidum is also called) enters the body through the skin or mucous membrane, usually during sexual intercourse, though infection may also occur
When the Great Depression hit, the poor became poorer and living on a daily basis was tough. A lot of African Americans could not afford basic essentials such as health care. In 1932, a total of 600 African American males were offered free health care and a cure for “bad blood” if they participated in a study, which none of them knew the purpose of. The deal was enticing because the African Americans were promised free meals and transportation, which were things they were not used to. The problem is that they were using these African Americans as guinea pigs to find out more about the sexually transmitted disease syphilis. This was a government sponsored study and the government knew how unethical it was because “It was said that the reason for the deception was that it would be the only way the men would stay in the study and the researchers wanted to closely observe the course of the disease over a large sample-size to see the effects as the disease progressed,
When the study began the men involved in the study were misled and not given enough information to provide legal consent to the experimentation. They were told they were being treated for “Bad blood” (“The Tuskegee Timeline” 2016). James H. Jones, author of an article called “Bad Blood,” stated, “The Tuskegee Study had nothing to do with treatment. No new drugs were tested; neither was any effort made to establish the efficacy of old forms of treatment.” (Coleman, et al. 41). The participants were not treated to cure their illness, they were not given the option to leave the study, and when penicillin became the drug commonly used to treat syphilis, the participants were not given the drug as a treatment. Coleman states, “…However, they deliberately denied treatment to the men with syphilis and they went to extreme lengths to ensure they would not receive therapy from other sources” (Coleman, et al. 41). The study was only supposed to last for six months, but instead lasted for forty years, beginning in 1932 and ending in 1972. The men who participated in the study were misled, left untreated and were unable to leave the study when a working cure for syphilis had been found. The way these men were treated is the very definition of unethical and thus the Tuskegee Syphilis Experiment serves as an important historical example of the necessity of medical ethics and IRB review processes, even though they may seem
There was no good outcome from doing the Tuskegee study. The government has to pay to the damage that was caused. The Tuskegee study went on for 40 years without any benefit for the black community. With the second theory the researcher were wrong in doing the study. According to Burkhardt”(2014) define deontology as “of ethics based upon the rationalist view that the rightness or wrongness of an act depend upon the nature of the act, rather than its consequence”(p.44).based on this theory doing the research were wrong. They did not tell them why the study is conducting, they did not tell them the risk and benefit of the research, and they withheld the only treatments available to continue their study with human
To generate knowledge in science experiments need to be conducted. But, first it is important to know what is knowledge. Knowledge is anything that is backed up by evidence and to support it first experiments need to be conducted as a proof. To derive knowledge about the syphilis disease, the medical experiment named Tuskegee Syphilis experiment was conducted. Using reasoning as a way of knowing, doctors would seem that it is logical for them to use black men as laboratory equipment, as the causes and symptoms of Syphilis can be known. It is actually beneficial to know about Syphili...