Trading Liberty For Illusions By Wendy Kaminer

903 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Conclusion as to why security vs privacy is important

Security plays an important job in today’s society, which is to prohibit any type of incoming danger. People want to believe that security is accommodating sanctuary, on the other hand, it is just a false belief. In her article, “Trading Liberty for Illusions”, Wendy Kaminer, a lawyer, claims that people are giving up their privacy for security that is essentially non-existent. The reasons for Kaminer’s assertion is because of the problems of fear and distrust that are arising from face-recognition systems. From my perspective, Kaminer wants the readers, after reading the article, to regain their privacy and only trade it in for security that absolutely provides safety to the society.

Kaminer supports her claim by the effective use of various …show more content…

The major sections of the text focus on the negative side of face-recognition systems. One section focuses on the inaccuracy of face-recognition. The second section focuses on how innocent people can trigger the alarm of a face-recognition. The last section would focus on how people are abusing the face-recognition for their own amusements. For instance, looking up women’s skirts. This kind of organization makes the essay more persuasive because it mostly focuses on a single topic, which is basically that face-recognition is evil. The spotlight on face-recognition implements the idea in the readers’ heads that face-recognition is negatively impacting the society. When a reader focuses on a single topic, it makes it easier to be persuaded because of the abundance of information being thrown at the …show more content…

The strategy of showing that the government is unreliable when it comes to capturing criminals is a bit unfair. This would be unfair because why not show the millions of criminals that were actually caught by face-recognition. The second strategy, which was showing that face-recognition is terrifying because of people abusing it was a bit wierd. The fact that Kaminer mentioned people looking up women’s skirts, immediately made me completely against her. Cameras are never built on the ground, they are made to watch over a huge landscape. Kaminer’s article was mostly based on a single topic, which made it simple. Kaminer also provided assumptions on what people are assuming. Combiner’s assumption are that people are afraid and even ignorant to challenge the government. Kaminer’s article was focusing on only the negative aspects of face-recognition and forced me good aspects of face-recognition, which makes the article not that

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Why Privacy Matters Even If You Have Nothing To Hide

    496 Words  | 1 Pages

    The word “privacy” has a different meaning in our society than it did in previous times. You can put on Privacy settings on Facebook, twitter, or any social media sights, however, nothing is truly personal and without others being able to view your information. You can get to know a person’s personal life simply by typing in their name in google. In the chronicle review, “Why Privacy Matters Even if You Have ‘Nothing to Hide,'" published on May 15th 2011, Professor Daniel J. Solove argues that the issue of privacy affects more than just individuals hiding a wrong. The nothing-to-hide argument pervades discussions about privacy. Solove starts talking about this argument right away in the article and discusses how the nothing-to-hide

    Read More

  • The Lost Language Of Privacy Analysis

    915 Words  | 2 Pages

    Have you ever heard of the idea of body-mounted cameras on police officers? If not, David Brooks will introduce you to the idea that was discussed in an article from New York Times called “The Lost Language of Privacy”. In this article, the author addressed both the positive and negative aspects of this topic but mostly concerned with privacy invasion for Americans. Although that is a valid concern but on a larger scale, he neglected to focus greatly on the significant benefits that we all desire.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of The NSA Controversial Issues Spark Debate

    1598 Words  | 4 Pages

    The feeling that someone is always watching, develops the inevitable, uncomfortable feeling that is displeasing to the mind. For years, the National Security Agency (NSA) has been monitoring people for what they call, “the greater good of the people” (Cole, February 2014). A program designed to protect the nation while it protects the walls within as it singles people out, sometimes by accident. Whether you are a normal citizen or a possible terrorist, the NSA can monitor you in a variation of ways. The privacy of technology has sparked debates across the world as to if the NSA is violating personal rights to privacy by collecting personal data such as, phone calls and text messages without reason or authorization (Wicker, 2011). Technology plays a key role in society’s day to day life. In life, humans expect privacy, even with their technology. In recent news, Edward Snowden leaked huge pieces from the NSA to the public, igniting these new controversies. Now, reforms are being pressed against the government’s throat as citizens fight for their rights. However, American citizens are slammed with the counterargument of the innocent forte the NSA tries to pass off in claims of good doing, such as how the NSA prevents terrorism. In fear of privacy violations, limitations should be put on the NSA to better protect the privacy of our honest citizens.

    Read More

  • Invasion Of Privacy Examples

    1884 Words  | 4 Pages

    Privacy is a complex concept with no universal definition as its meaning changes with society. Invasion of privacy occurs when there is an intrusion upon the reasonable expectation to be left alone. There has been a growing debate about the legitimacy of privacy in public

    Read More

  • The Unacceptable Privacy Infrigment

    1185 Words  | 3 Pages

    When we mention the word ‘privacy’, we mean that there is something very personal about ourselves. Something that we think others are not supposed to know, or, we do not want them to. Nevertheless, why is it so? Why are people so reluctant to let others know about them entirely? This is because either they are afraid of people doing them harm or they are scared that people may treat them differently after their secrets are known. Without privacy, the democratic system that we know would not exist. Privacy is one of the fundamental values on which our country was established. Moreover, with the internet gaining such popularity, privacy has become a thing of the past. People have come to accept that strangers can view personal information about them on social networking sites such as Facebook, and companies and the government are constantly viewing a person’s activity online for a variety of reasons. From sending email, applying for a job, or even using the telephone, Americans right to privacy is in danger. Personal and professional information is being stored, link, transferred, shared, and even sold. Various websites, the government and its agencies, and hospitals are infringing our privacy without our permission or knowledge.

    Read More

  • Privacy Essay

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    Different people, cultures, and nations have a wide variety of expectations about how much privacy is entitled to or what constitutes an invasion of privacy. Privacy is the ability of an individual or group to seclude themselves or information. Personal privacy has been declining in the past year which is caused by today’s technological society. With the latest technology such as face scanners, data collecting, and highly advanced software’s, privacy can be compromised, which is exactly what is being done today and it is unconstitutionally intrusive.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Epidemic Of Facelessness By Stephen March

    234 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Epidemic of Facelessness is about the deception of communication created by social media. The author Stephen March opens the article with a convict sending messages, over the internet, to a member of the parliament. Stephen introduces the problem that social media creates people who send life threatening messages to random people as a new form of comedic expression, these people are called “trolls”. According to March “the world without faces is coming to dominate”, and that is a big problem. March suggests a possible solution to combat facelessness is confrontation. According to ancient Rome “no man could be sentenced to death without first seeing his accuser.” However March continues on to say that due to the vastness of the internet

    Read More

  • Without Conscience by Robert D. Hare

    1924 Words  | 4 Pages

    “Without Conscience" by Robert D. Hare is one aimed towards making the general public aware of the many psychopaths that inhabit the world we live in. Throughout the book Hare exposes the reader to a number of short stories; all with an emphasis on a characteristic of psychopaths. Hare makes the claim that close monitoring of psychopathy are vital if we ever hope to gain a hold over Psychopathy- A disorder that affects not only the individual but also society itself. He also indicates one of the reasons for this book is order to correctly treat these individuals we have to be able to correctly identify who meets the criteria. His ultimate goal with the text is to alleviate some of the confusion in the increase in criminal activity by determining how my of this is a result of Psychopathy.

    Read More

  • Privacy Of Personal Information

    1580 Words  | 4 Pages

    have suggested that until powerful information technologies were applied to the collection and analysis of information about people, there was no general and systematic threat to privacy in public. Privacy, as such, was well-enough protected by a combination of conscious and intentional efforts (including the promulgation of law and moral norms) abetted by inefficiency. It is not surprising, therefore, that theories were not shaped in response to the issue of privacy in public; the issue did not yet exist. (17)

    Read More

  • The Right to Privacy

    804 Words  | 2 Pages

    Privacy is one of the severe issue in today’s Modern Technology era, tied to human right around the world. Most countries have started thinking differently regarding between the people’s right and national security, and trying to leverage on new technology to detect potential national threats without hurting people’s privacy. However, there's a blurred line between privacy violation and government surveillance. (Sánchez, Levin & Del, 2012) It would be a learning process for governments to seek an optimum balance between retain integrity of privacy right and eliminate national threats in order to make the country better.

    Read More

  • Privacy vs. Security

    1260 Words  | 3 Pages

    Solove, Daniel J. “5 Myths about Privacy” Washington Post: B3. Jun 16 2013. SIRS. Web. 10

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons: The Surveillance And Technological Dilemma

    1011 Words  | 3 Pages

    The inevitable truth about our technological advances has become an ongoing controversial dilemma. It begs to question whether or not our technology is taking us closer to the world of Big Brother. It even subjects us to address all the pros and cons this said technology, as a whole, has to offer. These days when people talk to each other, some no longer share eye contact because they are too busy on social media, texting, checking emails, looking for the next big thing, and so forth. Many people are blinded by the fancy & entertaining applications, availability of gps, and most importantly, being able to surf the web at the palm of their hands, but little do they know that those

    Read More

  • A Summary On Privacy

    1179 Words  | 3 Pages

    In his book Holtzman discusses how new technology threatens our privacy and how the law is incapable of protecting us. Holtzman has received a B.S. in Computer Science (326). He has worked as a security advisor in several organizations (326). By restating the title of the book in the introduction Holtzman claims that having no control over our personal information has resulted in the loss of privacy (xix). As Senator Evan Bayh mentioned in the foreword, the book examines the thin border “between protecting the United States and protecting our civil rights” (vi). Altogether, the main point of Privacy Lost is to deliver the message that “you have the right to control information about yourself” (xxv).

    Read More

  • Privacy Vs Security Essay

    1377 Words  | 3 Pages

    Along with Privacy and security comes the issue of terrorism, Constitutional rights, and Prisoners of War (POW). The privacy vs security debate has two sides to it. Many think that it has influenced governmental interaction with citizens. Sometimes the law focuses on the wrong interests. Just as security cameras are made for thief’s, there come along violations within a person’s workspace or personal life. Privacy emerged early on including Jewish and Roman laws safeguarding against surveillance. Once populations began to grow citizens around the world started filing complaints about noise and unlawful search and seizures. Security and Privacy become an internationally growing issue that affected the world. Security is known as a sort of Independence from danger. Privacy is a freedom from the Undesirable. “He noticed that the needle on his gas gauge was getting low and decides to pull over. As he walks into the gas station he pays for the gas with his credit card, steals a pack of cigarettes and a newspaper without the clerk knowing. B Horton proceeds out the doors and recognizes a security camera as he walks to his car. Later he is contacted and tried for theft. Some believe the camera was an invasion of his privacy but others say that Horton took from society” Webster 21) In America this was and still is a serious issue. The founders saw it coming and implanted laws against home invasions based on national security or to protect others. The fourth amendment in the Bill of Rights is one plan of action that the founding fathers implemented into the United States Constitution to give people a sense of privacy from law enforcement. Also the Fifth Amendment placed a specific procedure on how police go about arresting an individual. ...

    Read More

  • Law Enforcement Cameras an Invasion of Privacy

    1067 Words  | 3 Pages

    The past decade has seen a proliferation of law enforcement security cameras in public areas, with central London having more cameras than any other city. In cities like New York, Los Angeles, and central London, cameras can be found at almost every intersection. Terrorist attacks have been a major basis for this significant increase in law enforcement security cameras; however, privacy advocates, along with many of the public, feel that it’s an invasion of privacy. People are concerned that all this video surveillance, which is continuously expanding, has created a “Big Brother” society, where people are constantly watched. This creates paranoia and unease for people that just want to go about living there private lives, without feeling that their every move is being watched. The increased presence of surveillance cameras is almost compared to George Orwell’s novel from 1984, where he imagined a future in which people would be monitored and controlled by the government. One question that needs to be asked is: does the benefits of law enforcement security cameras outweigh the negative sides to it? Although the invasion of privacy is a serious argument against law enforcement cameras; nevertheless, it should be seen as a valuable tool to help fight crime. As long as surveillance cameras are in public places and not in people's homes, privacy advocates should not be concerned.

    Read More

More about Trading Liberty For Illusions By Wendy Kaminer

Open Document