The Smell of Disappointment: A Study of the Mind, the Body, and the Building

1728 Words4 Pages

The narrator in “The Axe” by Penelope Fitzgerald is the Manager of an unsuccessful company. This unnamed protagonist addresses a letter to his elitist, stereotypically self-important boss. The Manager explains the outcome of the redundancies that he had been assigned, reporting in full detail the termination of his clerical assistant, W.S. Singlebury, an older gentleman whose work is “his life” (Fitzgerald 667). In his letter, the Manager repeatedly makes reference to a pungent smell in the office, about which many staff members complain. The smell of the building is brought up at crucial points in the narrative, and thus the sickening scent, combined with dampness, becomes a strong motif throughout the story.
What is the smell that permeates the office building? This essay will argue that the smell in the office is a physical manifestation of the attitudes and emotions of its inhabitants. The reactions of different characters to the smell in the office building will be examined from cognitive and anthropological viewpoints. For the purpose of this essay “cognitive” will refer to the emotional associations that the characters make with the physical smell and the function of memory in its relation to smell. From the “anthropological” aspect, this essay will focus on the cultural representations of scent appraisal within the narrative. The reader learns about many of the static characters by their reported reactions to the smell: their persistent complaints are contrasted by Singlebury and his alleged understanding of its origin. In this way, the smell in the office building acts as a foil for the Manager, Singlebury and their colleagues. The smell lurks antagonistically throughout the story, growing stronger, highlighting crucial ...

... middle of paper ...

...n the air, and readers of “The Axe” might suspect that it is more than just a smell. The noxious odour represents the guilt of the manager, the bitter memory of W.S. Singlebury, and the relationship between Singlebury and his colleagues. The air of greed and self-absorption is more than stale; it can be a silent killer.

Works Cited
Dowdey, Sarah. "How Smell Works." HowStuffWorks.com. 29 October 2007. Web. 23/02/
2014. .
Fitzgerald, Penelope. "The Axe." The Broadview Anthology of British Literature: The Twentieth
Century and Beyond. Ed. Don LePan. Toronto: Broadview Press, 2006. 666-680. Print.
Howes, David., Anthony, Synnott., and Constance Classen. "Anthropology of Odor." David-
Howes.com. The Concordia Sensoria Research Team. Web. 20/02/2014.
.

Open Document