Summary Of Confederation Vs America Compromise

617 Words2 Pages

In May of 1787, a developing nation was on the verge of crisis. Delegates from twelve states met in Philadelphia to find a solution. The fifty-five men hoped to revise the Articles of Confederation to fit the needs of the growing country. After four months of a heated debate, they reached an agreement leading to what is now known as the American Constitution and Bill of Rights. After realizing that the Articles of Confederation were insignificant to guide the country, a meeting was called in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Twelve of the thirteen states sent delegates. Rhode Island did not participate due to the fear of losing state rights. The representatives agreed that the country needed a structured, stable, and central government to lead going forward. George Washington, a trusted figure in the military, was elected to preside over the …show more content…

States were allowed one Senate seat, and state population determined house seats. This is also when it was decided that the president would be chosen by a newly formed electoral college and hold executive authority. Slavery was a critical problem when it came to deciding if slaves should be accounted for in Congress. Slavery in the north was minimal compared to the slavery in the south, because of this the southern states thought that slaves should be included in deciding how many seats the southern states obtained in Congress, contrary to the north's opinion of the matter. Due to this debate, the three-fifths compromise was decided on. The compromise stated that every three out of five slaves would be accounted for when it came to taxation and legislative representation. This agreement was necessary and unavoidable due to the southern states threatening to repeal the

Show More
Related

  • Separation Of Powers Dbq Essay

    515 Words  | 2 Pages

    In May of 1787, 55 white wealthy males drifted into Philadelphia to work on the Constitution. Each one came from eleven different colonies to change the Articles of Confederation because it wasn't working out. The states have too much power and the national government has little to none of the power. There was no army or taxes. They needed to change it so the nation could stay together and not fall apart.

    Read More

  • Us Constitution Dbq Essay

    760 Words  | 2 Pages

    From five states arose delegates who would soon propose an idea that would impact the United States greatly. The idea was to hold a meeting in Philadelphia called the Constitutional Convention in 1787 meant to discuss the improvements for the Articles of Confederation and would later be called the United States Constitution. The United States Constitution was greatly influenced by Ancient Rome, the Enlightenment, and Colonial Grievances.

    Read More

  • Articles Of Confederation Dbq Essay

    708 Words  | 2 Pages

    At the time, larger states like Virginia were creating an unfair amount of power for themselves that the small states didn’t have. In the new government, Congress was created to make laws, and was made up of the House of Representatives and the Senate. The House of Representatives would give states a number of Representatives they could have based on their population. This would give fair power deserved to the larger states. The Senate however would be two and only two Senators for each state, no matter how large or small, bringing some equality to Congress.

    Read More

  • The Three-Fifths Compromise, The Great Cocomise, And Slave Trade Compromise

    1137 Words  | 3 Pages

    The founders’ disagreements about this issue based on their economic backgrounds and coming from states with different economy had influence the creation of the Three-Fifths Compromise which dealt with how to count slaves as a part of the population. According to "The Slavery Compromises,” the Southern state 's economy, such as South Carolina, depends on the labor of slaves working in their large plantations (University of Louisiana Lafayette 2016). Since the Southern states that depended on slavery naturally owned more slaves, many of the founders from these states wanted slaves to be counted as any other white people to gain more representatives and more voice in Congress. On the other hand, the Northern states’ economy does not heavily rely on slavery, and many of these states are “free” states which restrict slavery (University of Louisiana Lafayette 2016). Many of these Northern delegates such as Elbridge Gerry countered that “Blacks are properties” and should be counted as properties that can be taxed, but not as people when they don’t have the rights of citizens (Hart et al. 111). From this, we can infer that the Northern delegates fear that the South will get more voice, more representation due to more slaves, and they thought it was ironic how the

    Read More

  • Creation of the United States Constitution

    1236 Words  | 3 Pages

    This task was easier said than done. The fear of creating a government with too much power was a fear that was very much alive throughout the states. Tyranny was a common factor in developing governments, the delegates were seeking to avoid this error. Two ground rules were put into place for the Convention. The first was that any and all deliberations were to remain secretive. The second was that no topic or decisions would be considered closed and could therefore be up for debate and revision at any time. Once these rules were agreed upon, business started. The two contenders were the Virginia Plan, which had the larger states rooting, and the New Jersey Plan, claiming the votes of the smaller states. Under the Virginia Plan, legislature would be two houses and would be represented based on population. Under the New Jersey Plan, legislature would be one house and each state would have equal representation regardless of population. An agreement could not be reached between these two plans, instead a compromise was made. The Great Compromise met each side with an upper and lower house. The upper house was the Senate and would provide equal representation that was elected by the lower house. The lower house was the House of Representatives and would be dispersed based on population of the states. This compromise satisfied the small and large states, giving a

    Read More

  • The Articles Of Confederation And The Constitution: An In-Depth Analysis

    934 Words  | 2 Pages

    In one house, the Senate, every state is represented equally regardless of population. In the lower house, the House of Representatives each state receives one representative for a set number of people. This satisfied all of the states and helped resolve one of the greatest conflicts while writing the Constitution. Another conflict that arose was with the counting of slaves in the census used to set the number of representatives per state. This was resolved under the Three-Fifths Compromise which stated that every slave would be counted as 3/5 of a person, although these slaves were given no voice or rights.

    Read More

  • The Growing Opposition to Slavery

    1222 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Three Fifths compromise states that a slave be counted as three-fifths of a person. Therefore, the population of the southern states equaled the population of the northern states. Now that the populations were balanced, the south and the north sent the same amount of representatives to the House of Representatives. Pro-slavery southerners felt as if the north still had an advantage, but it was actually the south that had the advantage in the Senate and the House of Representatives.... ...

    Read More

  • The 1787 Constitutional Convention

    1940 Words  | 4 Pages

    These compromises are found in four main places within the Constitution. The first is the three-fifths compromise, which detailed how slaves would influence the population of each state for the purpose of determining representation and taxation. Located in Article 1, Section 2 of the Constitution the compromise states that three-fifths of the slave population would be counted for enumeration purposes (Dolbeare, 71). This compromise was important for the Southern states, whose populations consisted of large numbers of slaves, because without it they would have a significant smaller number of representatives in the House. Article 1, Section 9 of the Constitution prohibit...

    Read More

  • The U.S. Constitution and Slavery

    408 Words  | 1 Pages

    The south and the north made numerous compromises to create a great nation. The first indirect compromise was when the constitution didn’t mention slavery in the constitution, they left that for the states to deal with. After years after when the congress decide to stop the slave trade in 1808, they gave the south time to adjust to this but they new that by the time the slave trade died line was over the slave would have reproduces and they would have more slaves. Third compromise gave the south more power. They had notice that they had less seats in the house of representative. States with the most slaves, for instance Virginia and Maryland, were get out number in the house of representative, so the compromised to have the slave counted as part of the population. They got three counts for every five slaves. This helped balance the house of representative.

    Read More

  • Articles Of Confederation

    564 Words  | 2 Pages

    Analyze the degree to which the Articles provided an effective form of government with respect to any two of the following: Foreign Relations, Economic Conditions, or Western Lands

    Read More

  • 3/5 Compromise Analysis

    989 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the reasons that the convention decided to compromise on the idea was because they wanted to make sure that both sides were pleased. They did not want more chaos in the nation. All they wanted was to have peace in America, and compromising on ideas like this would help create it. Additionally, they wanted to make sure that each states tax burden would be fair. If they didn't count the slaves, then the North would be paying a majority of the taxes, and if they counted the slaves then the South would be paying an unfair amount of the taxes. This lead to a compromise so that each states’ tax burden would be fair and equal according to their different populations. Lastly, they wanted to create a compromise so that they could start trying to abolish slavery. Compromising like this meant that the South would have to stop the importation of slaves in 20 years. This would help the U.S be on its way to abolishing something that it began to morally question. Overall, the 3/5 Compromise helped keep peace in our nation. Even though Charles Pinckney did not get blacks to count the same as whites, he did help get the two sides to compromise on the idea. This was an important lesson that helped make America the country that it is

    Read More

  • The Creation Of The Constitution

    1073 Words  | 3 Pages

    Furthermore, the creation of The Constitution caused much debate between the elite and democratic states because they thought that if the Government got all of the power, they would lose their rights. The conflict between the North and South played a major role in the development of this document. The North felt that representation in Congress should be based on the number of total people and South felt that it should be based on number of whites. However, The Three Fifths Compromise settled this when it was said a slave will count as 3/5 of a free person of representatives and taxation. Article one section two of the Constitution defines how the population will be counted, obviously there was a strong opposition to this by Southern states like Virginia because their economy was based on slave labor and they had a bigger population because of it.

    Read More

  • Persuasive Speech At The Constitutional Convention 1787

    794 Words  | 2 Pages

    Amidst all the discussions, delegates began to listen to the idea of creating presidential electors. Some were still hung up on the popular vote, many worried that the position of an elector was not very significant, and no respectable man would want the job. When someone suggested that the electors be appointed by the members of congress, it passed with substantial support. Although this idea did not escape without lots of criticism, once everyone realized it was the only option they had that would not only work, but still allow the people to have a say in the election, the framers began working out all the details. On July 19th, Oliver Ellsworth of Connecticut proposed that electors be appointed based on the population of a state. Any population with less than one hundred thousand people would only receive one elector. If the state had between one hundred thousand and three hundred thousand, they would be awarded two

    Read More

  • What Were the Key Issues Leading To the Civil War?

    2033 Words  | 5 Pages

    Since the beginning of their new nation, the United States had many differences between the Northern and Southern states. During the Constitutional Convention they disagreed on how to determine their representation in the house based on population; the Southerners wanted to count their slaves and the Northerners did not, which lead to the three-fifths compromise. Later in the Convention there were concessions given to the South, which left the Northerners feeling uneasy, such as: a guarantee that the slave trade would not be interfered with by Congress until 1808 and slave owners were given the right to recover refugee slaves from anywhere in the United States. While many Northern delegates were disappointed with the rights given to the South, they felt it was necessary for the good of the Nation. This was necessary to form a strong central government and union between the states.

    Read More

  • Strengths And Weaknesses Of The Anti-Federalists

    853 Words  | 2 Pages

    One agreement the Constitution consisted of was the three-fifths Compromise. Foner states that the Constitution did not allow the national government to meddle with slavery in the states. This meant that three out of every five slaves could be counted as part of the state 's population. The powerpoint mentions that this raised their representation in the House of Representatives. The congress could not mess with the slave trade until

    Read More

More about Summary Of Confederation Vs America Compromise

Open Document