She's So Cold Comparison Essay

907 Words2 Pages

The poems, “She’s So Cold” by Mick Jagger and Keith Richards, and “When You Are Old” by William Butler Yeats are two similar, yet different stories where the men fall madly in love and unfortunately the feeling are not reciprocated. The primary similarities and differences between the poems are the tones of the writers, sense of imagery used, and the speaker. In Yeats opening line, he says, "when you are old and grey and full of sleep”. Yeats uses these words to provide us with the mental image that this woman is most likely old and fatigued. Likewise, Richards includes a line about when the woman becomes older, nobody will see the beauty he saw in her. Richards and Yeats both use a similar sense of imagery in their writing. They both try …show more content…

Yeats talks about the woman in the poem like she was his world. He has a caring and authentic tone to his writing. He uses the word “grace” to express that she was an elegant lady. Yeats tone starts to turn directions when he says, “but one man loved the pilgrim soul in you” (line 7). He uses the word “but”, which signifies that he no longer feels that way towards her. The way Yeats talks about her beauty in the beginning to how he no longer loves her like he did, he changes his tone to make her feel ashamed. He sounds as if he wants her to feel regret after her decision of letting him go and never loving him back. Richards has a likewise approach towards the woman he is talking about. You can tell he has stronger feelings for the woman when he says, “I’m so hot for her and she’s so cold” (line 2). Richards is trying to get the point across that he is really into her and she is heartless. He mentions countless times that he is hot for her and that she is beautiful, but the main point he keeps making is that she is so cold. The strong repetitive tone he has while saying it infers that she is cold-hearted and never cared about him. Richards seems to be broadcasting the fact that she does not love him back unlike the way Yeats makes it seem more

Open Document