Rosemary Jackson's Definition of the Fantastic

779 Words2 Pages

Throughout Rosemary Jackson's work three significant points could me made about her definition of the fantastic. Jackson writes about the fantastic as a genre or mode, how it should be interpreted by the reader, and more specifically, what it embodies. According to Jackson, because the fantastic is not a literary category it can not be defined as a genre and should therefore be referred to as a mode placed between the marvelous and the uncanny. Referring to the fantastic as a "mode" helps and leans towards a definition of this type of literature. Typically, a mode is a constant and distinct manner of doing or thinking, if it is altered in any way the mode changes. Applying this idea to the fantastic implies that the fantastic itself is a mode, if it is altered it immediately becomes marvelous or uncanny, which leads to Jackson's definition. The fantastic is the grey area which lies between the marvelous and uncanny, it is located on either side of a principle axis and distorts one's image of what is real by challenging and disorientating the reader's perceptions. In fact, the fantastic has conditions which is must satisfy with respect to the reader. First the text must oblige the reader to consider the world of the characters as a world of living persons and to hesitate between a natural and supernatural explanation of the events described. Second, this hesitation may also be experienced by a character. Third, the reader must reject all poetic and mythical interpretations (Jackson 28). The fantastic uncanny leans towards explanations that can be explained by logic and rules of the world as we know it whereas the fantastic marvelous doesn't question the supernatural.

A series of events in Edgar Allan Peo's "The Black Cat" r...

... middle of paper ...

...ory tells one of a regular couple who have been cursed with four "idiot" sons and a daughter whom they idolize and favorite. At the end of the narrative, the four sons decapitate their sister just as they had observed what had been done to the chicken. At no point in the story does a happening occur which leaves the reader questioning the events described. Although the series of these incidents seem strange, the reader is not forced to chose between a natural and supernatural explanation of these events. Therefore, Jackson's definition of the fantastic does not apply and the story can be categorized as merely uncanny.

According to Jackson many conditions must be respected in order for a story to be fantastic. Both narratives were solved by logical explanations and although some instances of may have confused the reader, they do not remain in a fantastic mode.

Open Document